- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
To address the challenge of debris tracking in complex scenarios within space environments, the authors propose a sample-rich debris tracking dataset, termed SDTD. Building upon this dataset, they construct a space debris tracking model, SDT-Net, which incorporates a DAE module to highlight debris features. Subsequently, a "debris offset" module is employed for cross-frame data association to generate a tracking trajectory for each debris object. In addition, the authors propose a DKA module, which exploits the physical spatial continuity of debris motion across frames to achieve accurate and efficient association. Relatively comprehensive comparative and ablation experiments demonstrate the value of the proposed dataset and the effectiveness of the proposed modules.
Critical strengths
(1) The authors appear to have proposed a relatively data-rich space debris tracking dataset, SDTD, whose release will contribute to a certain extent to the development of the community.
(2) The authors conduct relatively comprehensive comparative and ablation experiments, which can, to a certain extent, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model on this task.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The authors employ simulation tools to generate space debris. How do the authors ensure that the motion patterns and illumination of the simulated debris data remain consistent with those in real space scenarios? Should the authors not compare and analyze the simulated data against real data across multiple dimensions? For example, the authors assume the trajectory motion of debris to be linear motion. What is the theoretical basis for this assumption? The authors should provide a rigorous derivation from orbital kinematics to justify it.
(2) The methods compared in Table 2 are all from three years ago, whereas the authors also note in the paper that several papers on space debris tracking have appeared in the past two years. The authors should incorporate comparison results with these more recent methods. In addition, the fonts in figures such as Figure 5 and Figure 7 are too small, and there is overlapping and blurring, making them difficult for readers to read.
(3) In the SDT-Net network proposed by the authors, the allegedly innovative DAE and DKA modules are both rather common feature fusion and interaction operations in object tracking. Moreover, the overall network framework design adopts a very classic tracking network model, resembling the idea of an RNN model, so the novelty of the entire network is very limited.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the content of the Weakness section and provide detailed responses to each of the issues raised.