- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces fine-grained geometric visual perception (FGGVP), a capability that the authors argue is insufficiently captured by existing general-purpose VLMs. To address this limitation, the authors construct the FGGVP-22K dataset and fine-tune Qwen3-VL on it. Experimental results show that the resulting model achieves stronger performance on FGGVP-related tasks, outperforming several frontier foundation models, including GPT-5.6 and GLM-5.3.
Critical strengths
This paper raises a potentially meaningful topic, namely the distinction between recognizing geometric content and fine-grained geometric visual perception, which may help better characterize the geometric perception capabilities of current VLMs.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed formulation of “fine-grained geometric visual perception” is broader than what the actual solution and dataset support. In practice, FGGVP-22K mainly consists of coordinate prediction for predefined geometric primitives, query-conditioned localization of specified components, and analytic construction of a small set of relation-defined points such as midpoints, intersections, and perpendicular feet. These tasks are much narrower than the claimed notion of general fine-grained geometric visual perception and largely resemble specialized geometric grounding and coordinate prediction.
- It is difficult to understand what the figures are intended to convey, particularly Fig. 2. Furthermore, the aspect ratios are unreasonable, and the legends and fonts appear stretched. The authors need to carefully check the quality of the figures and ensure that the images accurately convey the intended ideas.
- The manuscript appears to deviate substantially from the standard ICLR formatting template, including the font problem. This should be corrected to ensure compliance with the submission guidelines.
Questions for authors
-
How do the authors justify framing FGGVP as a general fine-grained geometric perception problem, rather than a narrower form of geometric grounding and coordinate prediction?
-
Could the authors clarify the intended message of Fig. 2 and revise the figures to improve readability, aspect ratio, and font/legend quality?
-
Could the authors revise the manuscript to fully comply with the standard ICLR formatting template, particularly the font and overall typesetting?
The authors did not provide a rebuttal
The authors did not provide a rebuttal. I maintain my opinion of rejecting the submission.