- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Graph Process Neuron (GPrN) for sequential recommendation. Leveraging the irregular temporal information in users' interaction histories, GPrN constructs a continuous process using a Gaussian smoothing function. This process is then vectorized with a cosine basis, which is designed to produce a distinct, candidate-specific user representation.
Critical strengths
[S1] In a time-aware manner, modeling user histories as a continuous process offers a fresh perspective.
[S2] The proposed model achieves fast inference time, which supports its scalability.
[S3] The motivation behind the design choice is well justified from the view of sequential recommendation, and the mathematical formulation built upon it is sound.
[S4] The ablation studies and hyperparameter analyses are thorough.
Critical weaknesses
[W1] The role of the continuous process appears limited.
- The expressiveness of the continuous process is governed by the number of cosine bases and the temporal smoothness of the Gaussian smoothing function (Eqs. 5 and 7). However, the model is highly robust to both hyperparameters; even with or and , there is no substantial performance degradation.
- This suggests that the performance gains may stem not from capturing fine-grained temporal dynamics through the continuous process, but rather from its interaction location or from the additional learnable components that follow it (Eqs. 8, 9, 11, and 12).
[W2] The experimental results raise concerns about the validity of the proposed model.
- The datasets used in the experiments are overly limited in both domain diversity and scale.
- There is a concern that the baselines may be underfitted due to insufficient tuning (see Q1–Q3).
- The choice of baselines is questionable.
- Some baselines are not standard for sequential recommendation: TGT is a multi-behavior model, and SURGE is a CTR prediction model.
- The general sequential recommendation baselines, such as GRU4Rec, SASRec, and BERT4Rec, are relatively outdated, whereas recent graph-enhanced and time-aware sequential recommendation models, which are directly relevant to the proposed method, are not included.
Questions for authors
The following observations raise concerns about whether the baselines were appropriately selected and sufficiently tuned, and thus whether the reported improvements faithfully reflect the contribution of GPrN.
[Q1] The w/o Reader variant, which removes all components that constitute the core contribution of GPrN, already outperforms all baselines on Beauty and Sports (its results on ML-100K are not reported). This makes it somewhat difficult to attribute the reported gains to GPrN itself. One possible explanation is that the baselines may not have been fully tuned, or that the comparison may not include sufficiently strong relevant models. Could the authors comment on this result?
[Q2] Among the baselines, classic models such as GRU4Rec and SASRec achieve the best performance on ML-100K, and SASRec achieves the best performance on Sports. Since many subsequent models have been reported to outperform these classic models under comparable settings, this result suggests that the selected baselines may either be weaker than expected or may not have been sufficiently tuned. Could the authors explain this result, and comment on whether the conclusions would still hold against stronger recent models?
[Q3] Although the reported post-processing statistics and leave-two-out protocol are consistent with prior work, the overall performance scale differs noticeably from that reported in previous studies on the same datasets. Could the authors clarify the source of this discrepancy (e.g., full ranking vs. sampled negatives, metric computation, or preprocessing details), and describe how the hyperparameters of each baseline were tuned?
[Q4] Why is necessary? It appears that its effect could already be controlled by alone. This seems to be supported by the reported results, where the optimal performance is consistently determined by the product .
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for the time and effort you devoted to this paper. We have decided to withdraw the paper from OpenReview in order to protect the intellectual property involved. We sincerely appreciate all the valuable suggestions you raised. We wish you all the best.
Best regards,
The Authors