- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces VFlash, a method for fast, accurate visual planning through Flash Primitive Decoding. VFlash exploits the known structure of visual primitives to predict their coordinates jointly, using a lightweight drafter that generates an entire primitive in one forward pass. The layout adapts to the primitive's type, dimensionality, and length, supporting compact boxes and long, variable-length trajectories. Crucially, spatial accuracy need not require reproducing an autoregressive model's exact token sequence. VFlash therefore trains on annotated primitives and directly accepts structurally valid predictions without target-token agreement. Across the evaluated 2D and 3D robot trajectory tasks, VFlash consistently reduces prediction errors relative to autoregressive decoding. Preliminary single-rollout measurements indicate approximately 25x faster generation for 3D point motion forecasting. A world action model conditioned on VFlash plans achieves 70.2% average success across four MolmoSpaces task suites, compared with 62.6% for the baseline.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
As shown in Tables 2, 3, and 5, the performance improvements achieved by the proposed method appear limited and are not sufficiently significant to establish its superiority over competing methods. The authors should provide a more comprehensive analysis of the results to clarify the effectiveness of the proposed approach and identify the scenarios in which it offers substantial advantages.
-
Although quantitative results are reported, the authors do not provide sufficient visual comparisons to demonstrate the quality and accuracy of the predictions. In particular, visualizations of 2D trajectory prediction, 2D bounding box prediction, 3D trajectory prediction, and dense 3D motion prediction are missing. Such qualitative results are essential for assessing the accuracy, spatial consistency, and temporal coherence of the predicted outputs.
-
Given the practical relevance of the proposed method to robotics and autonomous driving, the authors should provide qualitative demonstrations illustrating its performance in these application scenarios. For example, visualized demos on real-world robotic platforms or autonomous driving datasets would help demonstrate the method's practical applicability, robustness, and effectiveness in complex environments.
-
The paper lacks a direct comparison with representative state-of-the-art decoding frameworks, making it difficult to determine whether the observed performance is attributable to the proposed method itself or to other factors in the overall system. The authors should conduct controlled experiments under consistent settings, comparing predictive performance, computational efficiency, and inference latency against existing decoding frameworks to better establish the advantages and contributions of the proposed approach.
Questions for authors
-
As shown in Tables 2, 3, and 5, the performance improvements achieved by the proposed method appear limited and are not sufficiently significant to establish its superiority over competing methods. The authors should provide a more comprehensive analysis of the results to clarify the effectiveness of the proposed approach and identify the scenarios in which it offers substantial advantages.
-
Although quantitative results are reported, the authors do not provide sufficient visual comparisons to demonstrate the quality and accuracy of the predictions. In particular, visualizations of 2D trajectory prediction, 2D bounding box prediction, 3D trajectory prediction, and dense 3D motion prediction are missing. Such qualitative results are essential for assessing the accuracy, spatial consistency, and temporal coherence of the predicted outputs.
-
Given the practical relevance of the proposed method to robotics and autonomous driving, the authors should provide qualitative demonstrations illustrating its performance in these application scenarios. For example, visualized demos on real-world robotic platforms or autonomous driving datasets would help demonstrate the method's practical applicability, robustness, and effectiveness in complex environments.
-
The paper lacks a direct comparison with representative state-of-the-art decoding frameworks, making it difficult to determine whether the observed performance is attributable to the proposed method itself or to other factors in the overall system. The authors should conduct controlled experiments under consistent settings, comparing predictive performance, computational efficiency, and inference latency against existing decoding frameworks to better establish the advantages and contributions of the proposed approach.
3 comments
Dear Reviewer,
This is a gentle reminder that the discussion phase will close soon. We would appreciate it if you could go over the authors’ rebuttal and share with us whether your original concerns have been resolved, or if you have additional points to raise with the authors.
Thank you for your effort.
Dear reviewer hHrw. Thank you for the thoughtful feedback and constructive comments. As the rebuttal deadline is approaching, we would be grateful if you could take a look at our rebuttal and the updated text to ensure we have addressed your concerns accurately. If that is the case, we would appreciate this to be reflected on the scores. If you have additional remarks, questions or requests, we are more than happy to address them! We appreciate your time and consideration.
Response to Reviewer hHrw
We thank the reviewer for the feedback. Below, we identify where VFlash offers the largest benefits, provide the requested visual comparisons and demonstrations, and add controlled comparisons with representative decoding frameworks.
We understand that there are common questions on the Decoder Design and Comparison to Others among all reviewers. As such, we address the common questions and concerns in the General Comment. Please kindly refer to the comment at the top of the page.
We respectfully note that the improvements are substantial in several settings, which we summarize below by primitive:
We will add this per-primitive analysis to the revision.
All qualitative results are available at this anonymous link. The videos compare AR and VFlash side by side on the same inputs. They cover 3D robot trajectories on real-robot scenes with ground truth overlaid, dense 3D motion, object localization and sub-task planning. The link also includes closed-loop policy rollouts on MolmoSpaces, LIBERO-Plus and LIBERO-PRO, with and without VFlash plans.
We address this question with more details in the General Comment. The paper has compared VFlash with DFlash in the same pipeline and hardware platforms (Figure 4, Appendix E), where VFlash is 2.6× faster per MolmoSpaces step on Thor. Tables R1–R4 in General Comment add the additional controlled comparisons requested here. In the response, we add three further controls under consistent settings and report predictive performance, efficiency and latency together (Tables R1 to R4): a multi-token-prediction (MTP) head, the speculative-decoding design that current open models such as Qwen3.5 ship; a conventional flow-matching head; and AR with matched training compute.
Under these settings, VFlash is both the fastest and the most accurate decoder. MTP speculative decoding is lossless but speeds up end-to-end decoding by only 2.1× over AR, compared with 18.2× for VFlash, and with direct acceptance its trajectories are clearly worse than VFlash's. The flow-matching head is less accurate on every 3D metric and 6.2× slower than VFlash end to end, and AR with matched compute remains far behind VFlash in 3D. This indicates that VFlash's gains come from its decoding design rather than from other parts of the system. We will add these comparisons to the revision.