- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Inspired by Bio-inspiredcontinual learning, the authors attempt to investigate whether a collaborative multi-learner architecture can benefit hyperspectral anomaly detection(HAD) in continuously changing scenes. The authors propose CL-SSMamba,a bio-inspired continual learning framework built on multiple spatial-spectral Mamba subnetworks for open-scenario hyperspectral anomaly detection. The method is evaluated on a six-task ABU sequence and five HAD100 scenes, with comparisons to several continual HAD baselines as well as component and learner-number ablations.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a practically relevant continual-learning setting in which sequential hyperspectral scenes must be adapted to without retaining historical raw HSIs. The framework based on Mamba subnetworks and parameter regularization provides a meaningful alternative to approaches relying on generative mechanisms or historical-data replay. The overall framework and experimental study are reasonably comprehensive. The method achieves strong final-stage performance on the six-task ABU sequence.
Critical weaknesses
1.The core multi-learner and continual-learning mechanisms are not sufficiently isolated. Increasing K from 1 to 2 also increases model capacity, but no parameter-matched single-learner baseline is provided. L_CL and L_EC are not individually ablated, and there is no direct evidence that the learners develop complementary representations. The update of parameter importance I and the value of λ are also insufficiently specified. The contribution of LSM is similarly unclear, as removing it slightly improves ACC and BWT at the final ABU stage.
2.The current evidence is insufficient to fully support the claims of continual-learning robustness and computational efficiency. Eq. (20) appears to measure mainly the final task transition rather than cumulative forgetting, while multi-seed and task-order evaluations are missing. CL-BioGAN also outperforms CL-SSMamba on all four final-stage HAD100 metrics, and the efficiency analysis is largely limited to parameter count and a reported 15% training-speed improvement over CL-CaGAN.
Questions for authors
1.How is the parameter importance I in L_CL computed and updated? What value of λ is used, and what additional state must be retained after each task?
2.Why is the learner aggregation weight defined as s = 1/T ? Does the method require the total number of tasks T to be known in advance?
3.Under a parameter-matched setting, does K=2 still outperform a widened single learner? How do removing L_CL and L_EC affect cumulative BWT and the full task-performance matrix?
4.Why does the benefit of LSM appear task-dependent? Since removing LSM slightly improves ACC and BWT at the final ABU stage, could the authors clarify under what conditions LSM is actually beneficial?
5.Could the authors provide a more complete efficiency evaluation, including training/inference time.
6.Appendix A.4.5 describes Fig. 13 as visualization results on the five sequential HAD100 tasks, whereas the figure caption refers to “five ABU datasets” and lists ABU scenes such as Los Angeles, Bay Champagne, San Diego, and Gulfport. Could the authors clarify which dataset and tasks Fig. 13 actually corresponds to and correct the inconsistency between the text and the figure caption?