- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work propose MineLoop, for inner-time world modeling, to improve the token prediction performance based on historical evidence. To verify the performance, this work compare MineLoop with other methods on MineCraft benchmark.
Critical strengths
- This work leverage historical content to refine and improve the token prediction.
- The method part presents well for understanding the detailed approach.
Critical weaknesses
- The word "inner-time" appears in the title, abstract and other essential parts, but seems lack the explaination of this term. What "inner-time" actually is?
- The comparison is limited. Would the method also work fine on scenarios except MineCraft benchmark, like the real-world task? Also, the amount of compared method is not enough. More world model methods are needed to be compared.
Questions for authors
Please see "Critical Weaknesses" part for reference.
2 comments
Thank for the authors' feedback. However, as the evaluation is limited (no expansion to other world model benchmarks, and no comparison to existing world model approaches), I think it is not available for a higher rating.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their constructive comments and valuable feedback. Below, we use C to denote the reviewer's questions or concerns, and R to present our corresponding responses.
C: The word "inner-time" appears in the title, abstract and other essential parts, but seems lack the explaination of this term. What "inner-time" actually is?
R: Thank you; we agree the term should be defined precisely at first use. Formally:
In plain terms, inner time counts the recurrent prediction steps for one token while the history stays fixed. After the K-th step, a token is sampled and world time advances. The revision gives this definition at the first mention in the introduction and in Section 3, and uses "recurrent prediction steps" elsewhere.
C: The comparison is limited. Would the method also work fine on scenarios except MineCraft benchmark, like the real-world task?
R: Thank you for raising this; we acknowledge it as a limitation and state it explicitly in the revision. We chose MineWorld because it is an open, action-conditioned, token-autoregressive world model with a public tokenizer and data pipeline. This allowed us to train the baselines from scratch on identical data at three scales, with matched estimated training FLOPs at two of them. That control is what isolates the effect of the architectural change.
MineLoop makes no Minecraft-specific assumption: it requires only an interleaved visual-action token sequence and a causal backbone. Real-world domains such as driving video are an important next step.
C: Also, the amount of compared method is not enough. More world model methods are needed to be compared.
R: Thank you. Our comparison is designed to isolate a single change. MineLoop and MineWorld share the tokenizer, training data, frame resolution, action representation, and training recipe, and differ only in how each token's prediction is computed; at Small and Medium they are also matched in estimated training FLOPs. World models from other works differ in several of these factors at once, so differences in their reported numbers could not be attributed to the prediction architecture. For this reason, we prioritized controlled comparisons at three scales, complemented by counterfactual action tests and an independent inverse-dynamics evaluator.
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we added one more controlled comparison: MineLoop Small trained with a single recurrent step (K = 1) and otherwise identical. Under the Table 1 rollout protocol:
The improvement over MineWorld appears only with the recurrent prediction steps.