acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

A Hierarchical Agent for Long-Horizon Multi-Robot Collaboration with Feedback-Driven Task Continuation

Abstract

Long-horizon multi-robot collaboration requires coordinating operations whose feasibility depends on the outcomes of other robots’ actions. A central challenge is aligning high-level decisions with physical execution: an unmet prerequisite, a failed operation, or a changed scene state can invalidate a planned next step. We present a hierarchical agent that coordinates multiple robots through a common execution interface. A vision–language agent selects robot roles and skills from the task, observations, structured physical-state feedback, capabilities, and execution history. The interface validates requests, dispatches learned manipulation and supporting skills, and returns outcomes or unmet conditions for the next decision. It also supports replaceable coordination models and skill backends. We evaluate direct handover, object-dependent sorting, model configurations, and task continuation in a four-robot simulation. Across 75 sorting episodes, the agent selects every receiver and destination correctly and completes 62 deliveries (82.7%). Under 45 recoverable post-handover drops, feedback-driven coordination completes 15 deliveries, whereas a one-shot plan with the same execution components completes none. A paired 2 × 2 study shows both high-level models operating with both backends and selecting all destinations correctly, while delivery varies with low-level performance. The results show that aligning decisions with physical feedback supports continuous collaboration across robots and configurable components.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Multi-Robot Collaboration, Hierarchical Robotic Agents, Feedback-Driven Coordination, Robotic Handover, Vision-Language Models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 1%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.00 over 3 reviews, above 0% of the others.
Reviewer_g34jOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a hierarchical system for collaborative manipulation. A vision-language coordinator selects robots, skills, and targets using observations, structured physical-state feedback, capabilities, and execution history. A common execution interface validates prerequisites, dispatches skills, and returns outcomes for subsequent decisions. The evaluation examines sorting, direct handover, interrupted-task continuation, and replacement of coordination models and skill backends in a four-robot simulation.

Critical strengths

The experimental reporting is transparent. The paper distinguishes destination selection, handover completion, final delivery, and appropriate stopping. It retains earlier failures and timeouts in relevant denominators and reports paired comparisons and confidence intervals.

The controlled-drop experiment demonstrates the value of execution feedback within the evaluated system. With the execution components held fixed, the closed-loop agent completes 15/45 recoverable-drop episodes, compared with 0/45 for the one-shot planner.

The implementation boundaries are described explicitly. The paper discloses simulator-derived state, manipulation assistance, and backend-specific execution configurations. These details help readers interpret the demonstrated capabilities.

Critical weaknesses

exceed the agent in most reported conditions: both achieve 59/75 normal deliveries; rules achieve 17/45 recoverable-drop deliveries versus 15/45 for the agent, and 23/24 B-held takeovers versus 18/24. Sorting differs by only one successful delivery. The rule controller also has lower runtime costs. These results establish the usefulness of feedback relative to one-shot execution, but provide limited evidence that the proposed model-based coordinator contributes additional capability.

The evaluated collaboration setting is narrow relative to the paper’s scope. Although the workcell contains four robots, each episode involves robot A, one receiver, and one object. Initial-state variation is restricted to translation within a 1 cm-radius disk, with fixed height and orientation. This provides limited evidence about more complex dependencies, concurrent collaboration, or adaptive reassignment.

Much of the task structure is supplied through state representations and execution contracts. Possession, readiness, docking, and delivery progress are derived from simulator geometry and executor state, while the interface explicitly checks prerequisites. Execution also includes attachment maintenance, release assistance, and modified collision constraints. These are legitimate engineering choices, but the paper needs to establish what the coordinator contributes beyond following the resulting state-transition structure, and how this advances the feedback-based planning approaches discussed in Section 2.2.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors identify a task variation, within the existing workcell, where the agent handles a changed instruction or capability configuration without modifying the controller, while the feedback-rule baseline requires additional programming?

  2. In the frozen-log evaluation, how does the coordinator perform when the overview RGB image is removed and only structured state and history are retained? This would clarify the contribution of visual reasoning.

  3. In the no-recovery-skill condition, all 24 fault-exposed agent episodes initially request unsupported retrieval before most eventually terminate. Given that the capability catalog is supplied, how should this behavior be reconciled with the claimed state-consistent coordination capability?

Reviewer_wvPrOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The work presents a system that combines Qwen and Maniskill to solve multi-arm pick and place tasks using four mobile manipulators. The authors present some results in simulation, evaluation two choices for the VLM and two choices for the motion generator, reporting a framework based on the performant combination.

Critical strengths

Composing (mostly) out of the box tools like Qwen and Maniskill into reasonable performance in mutli-arm manipulation including handoffs is interesting. This does hold promise for the strengths of these components.

Critical weaknesses

The paper is not well written. There is overall awkward phrasing and non-standard terms strewn throughout the manuscript. Jargon is inconsistent with the area of robotics and multi-robot manipulation problems. The work also broadly omits discussing the related areas of multi-robot manipulation. The experiments are mostly reported as simulated ablations. The problems evaluated are not long-horizon (should not take more than a few actions). The problems also pose no significant manipulation, multi-robot, logical (task), or geometric complexity. There are several casual mentions of simplifications and relaxations that draw severe questions about a) the rigor of the results; b) the applicability to real robots. Specifically "The transfer implementation relaxes collision constraints on the giver’s fingers." -- lack of safety and practical applicability; "these facts are obtained from simulator geometry and executor state" -- potential access to privileged information.

Questions for authors

Specific comments/questions follow.

Consider Fig 1. The Z1 arms are on mobile bases. Why is the A robot not moving and placing the object into the bin? Fig 1 bottom left claims that one robot cannot complete the full route alone. Why not? Why can robots A and D not move simultaneously to perform the handover, i.e., is the wait necessary?

The authors refer to the transfer collision being relaxed for the fingers. What does this mean and why is this justified?

The authors also refer to the facts set potentially having access to privileged simulator (geometry) information. Is this accurate? What are the tradeoffs and limitations that this may expose? This needs a discussion even if clarified as an assumption or problem setup.

Fig 1. Image bottom right says "D transport blocked" in title and A/ TRANSPORT_BLOCKED in inset.

The entire draft has non-standard terms being presented without clarification or definition. Examples: In intro "acquisition" -> seems to be pick. In Sec 3.2 "full registered catalog" -> is this set of actions? Sec 3.3: "object ... possession" -> grasping? "docking" -> unclear what this means. "Handover requires giver possession and receiver readiness" -> giver possession refers to currently grasping robot. receiver readiness refers to feasible handover configuration. "Deliver" -> place or drop.

Manipulation, multi-arm manipulation, multi-arm object rearrangement are established robotics areas. It would be useful if the authors repurposed the terms and conventions from the robotics literature for exposition.

Due to the absence of videos, it is not clear whether the interdependent, coordinated operations can entail simultaneous executions by multiple robots or is it one robot moving at a time?

Insets in Fig 2 are too small. Fig 2 describes "before handover, after handover, and completed delivery" -- are these the only three sequential steps that ever arise in multi-robot manipulation?

What camera feed is made available to Qwen? Is it the top-down view of the entire scene? The workspace is unclear. Are the visual tags part of the workspace, i.e., in all images the zones are visually marked out, with text labels fixed into the simulator's meshes to also communicate text/semantics to the VLM. The authors also appear to give a whole host of other "facts" to the VLM. While these might make sense in a simulator, given the presented information and images, and in the absence of details of some of these "facts", it is unclear whether this will be possible in a real robot. While it is not necessary to make the framework work on a real robot, it is desirable for such a study to make arguments for how and in what manner the insights can be applied to real settings.

The task descriptions need improvement -- standard terms and potentially figures and supplementary videos. For example, "When retrieval is unavailable, success instead means an appropriate abort after exposure." -> what does this mean? The metrics section does not define the reported data columns. What are A/B/C/D? Bins (Fig 1)? Robots (Fig 1, 4)? This is never explicitly defined and might be used interchangeably.

The experiments vary the source object only by 1cm of translation. This is not a strong benchmark and raises questions about generalizing even in the presented scene?

Table 1 is not discussed in the text.

Many references only include an arxiv url instead of complete archival venues.

Reviewer_LocvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The manuscript presents a hierarchical agent framework for long-horizon multi-robot collaboration, aiming to bridge high-level task plans and dynamic physical execution states (such as unready receivers, unmet prerequisites, or dropped objects). The system features:

  • A High-Level Vision-Language Coordinator: Uses models like Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct or GLM-4.1V-9B-Thinking to select robot roles, skills, and targets based on task descriptions, visual observations, structured state feedback, and execution history.
  • A Common Execution Interface: Validates request prerequisites, dispatches low-level learned policies (ManiFlow or MT-ACT), and returns execution outcomes or unmet conditions.
  • Feedback-Driven Task Continuation: Updates subsequent coordination decisions using physical-state feedback while preserving the core task objective. The approach is evaluated in a MuJoCo simulation environment utilizing four mobile robots (Dingo bases with Z1 arms) across sorting, fixed-receiver delivery, controlled post-handover drops, and held-object initializations
Critical strengths

Strengths:

  1. The paper presents a rigorously evaluated framework for addressing execution-plan misalignments in multi-robot collaborative manipulation for a single task.
  2. The modular separation between VLM-based high-level coordination and low-level skill execution is sound, and the empirical ablation across recovery mechanisms and model replacements is thorough.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited Task Scope: Restricting the experiments solely to a single task family (object transfer and delivery through multiple robotic arms) lacks broad task validation and needs justification.
  2. Limited Conceptual Novelty & Centralization: Relying on a centralized single agent managing execution through a common interface offers limited novelty compared to more practical decentralized multi-agent operations under partial observability.
  3. A simulation result of only 82.7% accuracy does not seem sufficient for physical deployment or industry readiness for this handover task. This is expected to be lower in physical deployment and may damage the object, robot, or environment.
  4. Since the robots are fixed in position and in a fixed surrounding environment, why simple algorithms with sensor feedback won't work needs explanation. We may not need a vision-language model for this task since the robot's configuration space is fixed within a boundary.
  5. The related work section discusses how language models are used in robotics, but never explains why a language model is specifically needed for this task. For example, the authors said they used ManiFlow (Yang et al. 2025) for learned skills, but that work did not use any language model, just a vision transformer tested on physical robots for performing different challenging tasks.
  6. Even if a vision-language model is needed due to uncertainty, the authors did not discuss how their work is different from previous works. The absence of physical hardware experiments or sim-to-real validation leaves open questions about how robust the execution interface and ManiFlow/MT-ACT policies are to real-world sensor noise and slippage.
  7. The empirical comparisons are restricted to a "one-shot plan" and heuristic "feedback rules". Comparing against existing LLM-based multi-robot coordination architectures under the same simulated benchmark would substantially strengthen claims of superiority.
  8. As reported in Table 10, the total process time per episode is substantial (averaging 266 to 317 seconds per episode for normal delivery), with massive LLM waiting times (69 to 146 seconds). Iteratively querying an 8B/9B VLM at every decision boundary introduces severe latency bottlenecks that would challenge real-time deployment.
  9. Section 4.5 and Appendix A.4 evaluate "state-consistent decisions" across 1,971 decisions. However, the exact automated oracle rules mapping raw visual/geometric states to "canonical next actions" need more formal mathematical specification to ensure that the evaluation oracle itself does not introduce bias.
Questions for authors
  1. Why are other types of tasks not evaluated? This looks like a paper only about delivering or transferring objects through multiple robotic arms.
  2. Since the robots are fixed in position and in a fixed surrounding environment, why won't simple algorithms with sensor feedback work? Why do you need vision-language models, which are usually more computationally expensive?
  3. Why were competing multi-robot LLM/VLA frameworks (e.g., RoCo or COHERENT) omitted from the empirical comparison tables in Section 4? How does the proposed feedback-driven interface compare against their replanning or dialogue mechanisms?
  4. Given the high LLM wait and process times noted in Table 10, have the authors explored caching, smaller distilled local models, or asynchronous decision-making to reduce the per-episode runtime overhead?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.