- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces cross-view dense video object captioning, which associates observations of the same target across cameras into a global trajectory and generates one caption for it. The authors construct CRTrack-Cap from CRTrack, curating reference captions for 335 of its 425 global trajectories, and extend CHOTA to cross-view evaluation. The reference framework combines VECA and CEG and achieves the highest CV-CHOTA among the compared methods on both the in-domain and cross-domain tests.
Critical strengths
- The task is well motivated. Different cameras can provide complementary appearance information, and combining cross-camera identity association with object captioning is a useful extension of single-view DVOC.
- The dataset retains links between captions and the original identity annotations, specifies which identities are eligible for caption evaluation, and provides scene-disjoint in-domain and cross-domain splits. These choices provide a useful basis for future work.
Critical weaknesses
- Some experimental details are not fully described. Section 5.1 discusses tracker fine-tuning and association with MvMHAT, but it is unclear how each baseline produces a single global caption from its local outputs. The training settings for the captioning modules are also insufficiently specified. These details affect caption scores and are needed to reproduce the results and interpret the performance gaps in Table 2.
Questions for authors
- How does each baseline convert its local outputs from multiple views into one global caption? Are the captioning modules fine-tuned on CRTrack-Cap, and what training data and settings are used?
- Under Eq. (4), the cross-domain VECA results in Table 3 imply that the combined METEOR and SPICE improvement of CEG over MVMean is approximately 4.94. In Table 6, the corresponding improvements are 3.40 and 3.11 for the three and four-view groups. Do these groups cover all 49 cross-domain identities, and were they evaluated using the same predictions, matching, and per-identity scoring as Table 3? Please report the group sizes and explain how these values can be reconciled if these conditions hold.
- Please expand the related work discussion to cover cross-view caption consistency [1] and object captioning from multiple views [2, Fig. 6(b)], and clarify how these works relate to and differ from the proposed task.
[1] Embodied Image Captioning: Self-supervised Learning Agents for Spatially Coherent Image Descriptions. ICCV 2025.
[2] Describe Anything: Detailed Localized Image and Video Captioning. ICCV 2025.