- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes IHC-LDL for imbalanced hierarchical classification. It combines label enhancement, random oversampling, and a hierarchical consistency module. The method builds soft labels from sample features, label hierarchy, and original labels. It also adjusts the weights of classification and label distribution losses based on the difference between soft and original labels.
Experiments on seven datasets compare the method with several baselines and test the effects of label distribution learning and oversampling. The method improves some metrics on several datasets, but the gains are not consistent across datasets.
Critical strengths
-
The method considers both label hierarchy and class imbalance in one framework. This is useful for tasks where rare, fine-grained classes must be predicted consistently with their parent classes.
-
Experiments on seven datasets include images, animal attributes, and proteins. The baseline comparisons and ablations provide useful evidence about where the approach helps, although the gains are mixed.
Critical weaknesses
-
Eq.2 does not ensure a valid label distribution, and Eq.5 can produce values above 1. Eqs.6–8 also mix prediction outputs with scalar losses. These issues make the training objective difficult to verify and reproduce.
-
Removing LDL improves all four metrics on F194 and DD. The paper also lacks separate ablations for the adaptive weighting and the modified hierarchy constraint. Since the method largely combines existing components, this missing evidence weakens its contribution.
Questions for authors
-
How do you ensure that the label distributions in Eqs.2-4 are nonnegative and sum to one, especially when the original labels contain multiple positive entries?
-
How do you prevent Eq. 5 from producing values above 1? Does restricting the maximum operation to k descendant levels still guarantee hierarchical consistency?
-
Are HCCM_d and HCCM_l prediction vectors or scalar losses? Please clarify the exact training objective implemented in Eqs. 6-8.
-
Why should a larger difference between soft and hard labels lead to greater weight on the soft labels? Do you have ablations comparing this rule with fixed weighting?
5.Removing LDL improves all four metrics on F194 and DD. Are these results consistent across random seeds, and what evidence supports the claimed benefit of LDL despite these failures?