- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents EDICT, a text-to-speech framework combining reference-conditioned timbre editing with within-utterance expressive control.
A notable design is its representation of relative timbre-editing requests as structured attribute operations, explicitly specifying which dimensions to modify, the direction and magnitude of changes, and which attributes to preserve. A trainable editor uses these operations and reference speech to generate a reusable edited codec reference. A frozen TTS backbone then uses this reference to maintain a consistent voice, rebuilding its KV cache at instruction boundaries with updated conditions and retained acoustic context to support local control and continuity.
The authors introduce two bilingual benchmarks, TimbreEdit-Bench and IntraTTS-Bench, and validate the framework through automatic metrics, listening tests, and ablations, supplemented by ESD and MED-TTS experiments. Results show improved target-voice matching and a favorable balance between local instruction adherence, speaker consistency, and transition quality, with trade-offs in preserving unedited attributes and speech content accuracy.
Critical strengths
1.Structured relative timbre editing provides a useful control interface. Explicit operations specify which attributes to change or preserve, producing an edited voice reference reusable across texts and delivery conditions.
2.KV cache reconstruction is supported by informative ablations. Comparisons with persistent and truncated caches demonstrate its benefits, while results across two TTS backbones and MED-TTS provide further evidence of effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
1.Selective timbre editing is insufficiently validated. EDICT preserves unedited attributes less reliably than Qwen3-TTS-VD, and evaluation checks edit direction but not the specified magnitude. Real-speech experiments also lack fine-grained attribute evaluation, leaving uncertainty about targeted editing while preserving other attributes.
2.Direct comparisons with the closest methods are missing. The experiments do not directly compare against relative timbre-editing methods such as VoxEditor or the KV-cache control method of Kang et al., limiting assessment of the contribution beyond prior work.
Questions for authors
1.Selective editing on real speech. The real-speech experiments in H.1 lack attribute-level evaluation, and target-speaker similarity alone does not establish selective editing. Could the authors evaluate single- or dual-attribute edits on real references, measuring both the requested changes and preservation of unedited attributes, and report their joint success rate?
2.Effectiveness of edit magnitude. The structured operations distinguish one-level and two-level changes, whereas Up/Down evaluation checks only direction. For the same reference and attribute, do different magnitude instructions produce ordered and perceptually distinguishable changes? Could the authors provide a targeted evaluation?
3.Comparison with the closest methods. Table 6 supports recomputation over truncating and reusing old KV states, but the advantage over the KV-cache control method of Kang et al. remains unclear. Could the authors provide a direct comparison and a TED-TTS baseline using the same edited reference? For timbre editing, could they compare against an editing–synthesis pipeline incorporating a method such as VoxEditor, or explain the specific limitations preventing such a comparison?
Follow-up on Our Response
Dear Reviewer RkY2,
Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. Our responses include attribute-level evaluation on real speech references, an acoustic analysis of pitch-edit magnitude, and comparisons with Kang. The corresponding revisions are highlighted in blue in the updated manuscript.
As the discussion period draws to a close, we would be grateful if you could take a look at our responses and the revised manuscript.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors