- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents an effort to create a model for collision avoidance SGA-planner. It also includes a benchmark to evaluate collision avoidance SCA-Bench.
Critical strengths
The paper presents an evaluation benchmark for collision avoidance, grounded on real data.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The authors mention that one episode contains 240 intervals ( two hours) for avoidance and recovery. This is not sufficient, and does not resemble what is used in a typical CAM (Collision avoidance manouver), first of all, a manouver is performed in the orbital periods before the TCA (Time of Closest approach), since one period is between 80-128 minutes, for LEO, this does not give enought time to perform a manouvre, and even less to return to the nominal orbital afterwards.
In a non-automated case, CAM are planned with 1-2 days in advance before TCA. Starlink, which has the quickest and more automated process, still plans and performs it in a 12h window before TCA.
(2) It is not clear in which environent this is created.
(3)The test set is limited to 128 cases. The kelvins dataset can only give dataset wide statistics. There are far more collision avoidance cases that can be simulated following the process described in the paper.
(4) The authors should include Basilisk RL in the related work section. The authors fail to identify the novelty of the proposed solution against orbitzoo, which is a general environment that can be used not only for collision avoidance, but also for other tasks, such as orbit transfer or station-docking.
Other small errors:
It is not clear what test128 is. If it is the test set, and there is no other test set, just call it test set.
Foreman missing year L038
Figure 4: some figures are low quality png instead of vectorized images
Incorrect in text citation use L107
Incorrect bibliography:
Review of conjunction probability methods for short-term encounters | request PDF. ResearchGate. URL https://www.researchgate.net/publication/289311065_Review_ of_conjunction_probability_methods_for_short-term_encounters. ( just an example)
Questions for authors
(1) What is the environment used? The code seems incomplete with some imports refering to base_work. What is base_work? (2) Do you consider your new environment to be a novel and relevant part of the paper. Or can your model be used within OrbitZoo or Basilisk RL?