acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Allocating Agency: Structure-Preserving Multi-Agent Reasoning for Recommendation

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) have introduced a new paradigm of agentic recommendation, yet effectively integrating LLM agents into mature recommender systems remains challenging. Existing recommendation models already encode substantial intelligence through collaborative signals, retrieval mechanisms, and behavioral priors, making unrestricted LLM autonomy an insufficient solution. We formulate this challenge as the Agency Allocation Problem: how to assign LLM reasoning authority to unresolved recommendation decisions while preserving the intelligence already captured by specialized recommenders. Based on this perspective, we propose Agent-R, a structure-preserving framework that allocates LLM agency across two complementary decision spaces. In the Consideration Space, a Planning Agent coordinates heterogeneous recommendation evidence to adapt candidate coverage around a reliable retrieval backbone. In the Preference Space, a Ranking Agent learns contextual preference residuals over an explicit recommendation prior to refine ranking decisions without replacing existing structures. Experiments across diverse recommendation domains demonstrate that Agent-R consistently improves both candidate coverage and ranking quality, achieving up to 28.3% relative gains in Recall@10 over strong fusion baselines. Further analyses show that structured agency allocation enables LLMs to provide complementary reasoning while retaining the strengths of specialized recommendation models.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Agentic Recommendation, Large Language Models, Multi-Agent Systems

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_nqiCOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tackles an interesting topic about what parts can be replaced by LLM in a recommendation system. The paper proposed a framework with a planning agent that determines how recommendation evidence should be coordinated around the existing candidate backbone, and a ranking agent to refine the inherited ranking structure. Experiments are conducted across diverse recommendation domains demonstrate that Agent-R consistently improves both candidate coverage and ranking quality.

Critical strengths

The paper is well-organized and easy to follow. The topic discussed is very practical and could have potential real-world impact. The experiment is detailed and informative.

Critical weaknesses

One of the major issues I noticed is that in Table 1 and Table 2 the performance of Agent-R on Industrial dataset is quite different. I wonder if that is typo or any misunderstanding of the experiment results.

Another of my naive concern is that I agree on the framework design, but I wonder why is LLM necessary to work as ranking agent and planning agent. Any additional impact does LLM bring to the system comparing to non-LLM setting?

Questions for authors

Why is LLM necessary to work as ranking agent and planning agent? Any additional impact does LLM bring to the system comparing to non-LLM setting?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer nqiC

We sincerely thank you for your careful review, encouraging assessment, and thoughtful suggestions. Your questions regarding experimental consistency and the necessity of LLM agents have motivated us to further examine the contributions of individual components and strengthen our empirical evidence. In response, we have carefully revised the manuscript and conducted additional controlled experiments and analyses. We hope the following responses address your concerns and provide a clearer and more convincing understanding of the contributions of Agent-R.


Reply to Weakness

Reply to W1 - Correction of Industrial Results

We sincerely thank you for carefully identifying this inconsistency. After examining our experimental records, we confirmed that the discrepancy originated from an inadvertent dataset-to-result mapping error during result consolidation, where results from another dataset were mistakenly reported as Industrial in Table 1. The intended benchmark is Amazon Industrial, and we apologize for this oversight.

To fully resolve this issue, we re-evaluated Agent-R and its ablations on Amazon Industrial and updated all affected results in the revised manuscript. The corrected results are:

MetricCorrected Result
NDCG@100.0229
Recall@100.0420
NDCG@500.0348
Recall@500.0950

The updated results are now fully consistent across Tables 1, 2, 5, and 6. Importantly, Agent-R continues to outperform the reported fusion baselines on all four Industrial metrics, preserving our main experimental conclusions.

We have also updated the manuscript PDF and anonymous code repository with data, including the corrected evaluation pipeline and benchmark data, to ensure that these results can be independently reproduced.

We sincerely appreciate your careful review, which helped us improve the accuracy and reproducibility of our experimental evaluation.

Reply to W2 - Why LLM Agents? Understanding Their Contributions Beyond Conventional Recommendation

We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful question. We agree that the value of introducing LLM agents should be demonstrated beyond simply adding more powerful models. Our motivation is not to replace conventional recommenders with LLMs, but to assign contextual intelligence to specific decision processes while retaining existing recommendation structures. To clarify these contributions, we conducted several additional controlled experiments.

1. The complete Agent-R framework provides significant benefits beyond standalone LLM fine-tuning.

We independently fine-tuned a MAS-independent Qwen2.5-7B ranker using the same backbone, LoRA architecture, and listwise training objective, but without agent-generated memory, planning, or multi-route coordination (Appendix B.10, Table 10).

DatasetFine-tuned LLM RankerAgent-RΔ NDCG@10 [95% CI]
Software0.07970.0851+0.0054 [0.0034, 0.0075]
Industrial0.01190.0229+0.0111 [0.0080, 0.0142]
KuaiRec0.05670.0615+0.0048 [0.0020, 0.0076]
MicroLens0.01770.0199+0.0022 [0.0013, 0.0032]

All four improvements are statistically significant. This demonstrates the additional value of the complete multi-agent recommendation pipeline beyond independently fine-tuning an LLM ranker. The comparison measures the combined effects of candidate adaptation and structured contextual modeling, rather than the isolated contribution of any single LLM component.

2. LLM-generated memory and contextual preference refinement contribute complementary information.

The Memory Agent constructs reusable short-term and long-term preference representations from user histories. Removing this component reduces NDCG@10 from 0.0851 to 0.0836 on Software and from 0.0229 to 0.0205 on Industrial, with statistically significant differences.

Meanwhile, contextual residual refinement improves ranking beyond the inherited recommendation prior. For example, NDCG@10 increases from 0.0155 to 0.0615 on KuaiRec and from 0.0142 to 0.0199 on MicroLens relative to Prior Only.

Our additional non-LLM residual comparisons further clarify that the structured semantic context and residual-learning interface are important, while the 7B LLM ranking backbone is not universally indispensable. Lightweight text-based rankers can also effectively leverage these representations. Thus, we distinguish the contribution of contextual preference modeling from claims of LLM-specific ranking superiority.

3. The Planning Agent provides constrained, user-conditioned evidence coordination.

Unlike conventional fixed-weight fusion, the Planning Agent generates per-user adjustments over heterogeneous recommendation evidence, while a deterministic executor remains responsible for candidate selection.

To isolate its contribution, we additionally compare against budget-matched non-LLM expansion strategies (Appendix B.11):

DatasetBase Only R@50Static UniformStatic DEV-TunedLLM Planner
Software0.29800.31630.31910.3185
Industrial0.08000.09470.09460.0950
KuaiRec0.12030.13220.13150.1308
MicroLens0.07260.09320.09370.0934

Candidate adaptation significantly improves Recall@50 across all four datasets. The LLM Planner additionally outperforms uniform expansion on Software (+0.0022, 95% CI [0.0005, 0.0039]) and achieves performance comparable to DEV-tuned static policies across all datasets, while generating user-specific adjustments without supervised planner-policy training. We acknowledge that its incremental accuracy advantage over optimized static policies is not universal.

Taken together, these results clarify why we introduce LLM agents and where their value lies. LLMs provide flexible semantic preference representations and user-conditioned coordination within a constrained recommendation pipeline, while specialized recommenders and deterministic execution retain responsibility for reliable item-level decisions. Importantly, our additional controls show that effective agency allocation does not require every component to be implemented by a large LLM.

Reply to Question - Why Use LLMs for Planning and Ranking?

We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful question. The key motivation behind Agent-R is not that every recommendation decision requires an LLM, but that LLMs can provide complementary contextual intelligence where conventional recommendation structures remain insufficient. Our framework therefore assigns LLMs constrained responsibilities rather than replacing specialized recommendation models.

Specifically, the two agents address different limitations:

ComponentRole of the LLMExisting Recommendation Intelligence Preserved
Planning AgentInterprets heterogeneous evidence and generates user-specific coordination policiesRetrieval routes, calibrated evidence, and deterministic item selection
Ranking AgentModels contextual user–item compatibility using preference memory and item semanticsOriginal ranking prior and bounded residual intervention

First, the Planning Agent provides flexible evidence coordination without requiring supervised policy training. Unlike fixed-weight fusion, it generates user-conditioned adjustments over multiple recommendation sources. Our new budget-matched experiments (Appendix B.11) show that LLM planning achieves coverage comparable to DEV-tuned static policies across all four datasets, with a significant improvement over uniform expansion on Software (+0.0022 Recall@50, 95% CI [0.0005, 0.0039]). This demonstrates a practical advantage of LLM-based coordination, although we do not claim it universally outperforms optimized static policies.

Second, the Ranking Agent leverages semantic preference information beyond conventional ranking scores. For instance, Agent-R improves NDCG@10 over Prior Only from 0.0155 to 0.0615 on KuaiRec and from 0.0142 to 0.0199 on MicroLens. LLM-generated preference memory also provides additional contextual information, with significant improvements when included on Software and Industrial.

Importantly, our additional non-LLM controls reveal that the residual ranking mechanism can also be implemented using smaller models. We view this as a useful clarification: the value of Agent-R lies in its structured coordination of candidate evidence and contextual preference information, not in requiring an LLM for every computation. The Ranking Agent is therefore a flexible component within the broader agency allocation framework.

As further demonstrated in Appendix B.10 (Table 10), the complete Agent-R framework significantly outperforms an independently fine-tuned, MAS-independent LLM ranker across all four datasets, confirming that its benefits extend beyond standalone LLM fine-tuning.

In essence, Agent-R addresses not only whether LLMs can improve recommendation, but where their capabilities should be integrated with existing recommendation intelligence. This is precisely the motivation behind our Agency Allocation formulation.


We sincerely appreciate your constructive feedback and encouragement throughout the review. Your suggestions have helped us substantially improve the rigor, completeness, and positioning of our paper, particularly in clarifying the distinct roles of LLM agents and conventional recommendation components.

We hope that our detailed responses, additional experimental evidence, and revised manuscript have adequately addressed your concerns and further strengthened your confidence in the soundness and practical value of our work. We would be very happy to provide further clarification or address any remaining questions, so please feel free to let us know.

We would also be very grateful if you could consider raise your assessment and rating of our paper in light of these additional experiments and revisions. Thank you again for your time, thoughtful consideration, and valuable support.

Reviewer_6XG9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper asks how much decision authority an LLM should receive inside a recommender that already has retrieval routes and a ranking prior, which the authors call the agency allocation problem. The proposed Agent-R keeps a protected prefix of the base collaborative route, turns its ordering into a prior, and adds two bounded LLM interventions. In the consideration space, a prompted planning agent emits per-user trust adjustments over the evidence sources, and a deterministic executor maps them to route weights and fills a 50-item slate with complementary candidates. In the preference space, a LoRA-fine-tuned Qwen2.5-7B cross-encoder outputs a bounded residual that is added to the rank-derived prior, so that zero residual weight recovers the prior exactly. Experiments on five datasets compare against specialized recommenders, single routes, and fusion methods given the same route outputs, and report the best Recall@10 on every dataset. Ablations on two datasets and appendix analyses cover route complementarity, prior-versus-residual variants, residual diagnostics, failure resolution, and serving cost.

Critical strengths

A clean two-space decomposition with diagnostics that separate the two effects. The paper shows that removing candidate adaptation moves Recall@50 while leaving NDCG@10 nearly unchanged, and that removing the ranking agent does the opposite. The residual analysis shows that ground-truth items concentrate among the candidates the residual scores highest, so it carries information the prior does not. The fusion baselines receive the same route outputs, model selection is done on validation data, and prompts, LoRA settings, and code are provided. This part would remain useful to practitioners regardless of the headline numbers.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Agent-R's results differ across tables, and the released code does not settle which Industrial numbers the ablations refer to. While checking Tab. 1 against the later tables, I noticed that its Industrial row for Agent-R does not match the Industrial values in Tab. 2, 5, and 6, and that the main text quotes the Tab. 2 value (§4.2). The base-route and prior-only entries in those tables do agree with Tab. 1, so the discrepancy is confined to the Agent-R rows. The report script in the anonymous repository hard-codes finalized Agent-R numbers for eight datasets: the script's Industrial entry matches Tab. 1, whereas the values labeled Industrial in Tab. 2, 5, and 6 match the script's entry for a CDs & Music dataset that the paper does not mention. Whether this stems from a labeling error or a different run, the paper presents two sets of Industrial numbers for the same system without saying which one the ablation tables reflect. Tab. 1 also reports higher Recall@50 for KuaiRec and MicroLens than Tab. 5, with identical NDCG@50, and the script's values for these two datasets match Tab. 5 rather than Tab. 1. Since the ranking agent reorders a fixed 50-item slate, I would expect Agent-R's Recall@50 to equal the prior-only variant's, as Tab. 5 shows; under those values Agent-R would trail some fusion baselines on Recall@50. I may be missing something about how Tab. 1 was produced, but as it stands the claim of consistent improvement is hard to assess.

W2. The structure-preservation thesis holds only where the prior is strong. The central argument is that a residual over an explicit prior, rather than free rein for the LLM, is what makes the gains possible (§1; §4.4). On the two datasets with the largest headline gains, KuaiRec and MicroLens, the no-prior Residual Only variant matches or slightly exceeds Agent-R (Tab. 5). App. B.3 describes this as mixed, but §4.2 discusses only Software and Industrial, where the prior helps. The Direct LLM Fusion comparator is described only as the same LLM ranking without the residual mechanism (App. B.1); whether it is fine-tuned is not stated, whereas the residual ranker is LoRA-trained with a listwise loss. Fig. 3(a) and Tab. 5 therefore do not separate structure from training. The formal support is also somewhat limited. Eq. 13 holds for any additive fusion once the residual weight is set to zero, so it does not describe the ranking under the selected α. Because neither α nor the prior map φ is reported, it is hard to tell how far the deployed ranking may move from the prior, and the correlations in Tab. 7 measure the average size of the intervention rather than bounding it. The evidence therefore seems to support a more specific conclusion: a fine-tuned reranker over the slate is beneficial, and the prior helps when it is strong. A related gap is that Tab. 1 and Tab. 2 report no variance or statistical significance, even though App. B.1 describes a bootstrap procedure.

Questions for authors

Q1. Could the authors explain the relationship between the Industrial row of Tab. 1 and the Industrial values in Tab. 2, 5, and 6, and between the Tab. 1 and Tab. 5 Recall@50 values for KuaiRec and MicroLens? In the released make_fusion_report.py, the finalized entry for a CDs & Music dataset equals the latter Industrial values. Were those ablation tables run on that dataset? If so, could you provide the corresponding ablation results on the Industrial dataset, together with a reconciled Tab. 1 and the paired-bootstrap significance described in App. B.1?

Q2. Is Direct LLM Fusion fine-tuned with the same data and loss as the ranking agent, or used zero-shot? How does the LLM column in Tab. 1 relate to the Direct LLM Fusion rows in Tab. 5, which give different values for Software?

Q3. Given that Residual Only matches or exceeds Agent-R on KuaiRec and MicroLens, how should the structure-preservation claim be qualified? Which α and prior type were selected per dataset, and does the selected α on those two datasets approach the no-prior regime?

Q4. The repository covers eight datasets, including Video Games, CDs & Music, and DoubanMusic, while the paper reports five. How were the reported datasets chosen? Does any experiment isolate the LLM planner from a non-LLM candidate expansion with the same budget, given that the ablation in Tab. 2 removes the whole expansion?

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 6XG9

We sincerely thank you for your careful review and insightful suggestions. We particularly appreciate your close examination of our experimental results and methodological claims. We have carefully revised the manuscript and conducted additional experiments and analyses. We hope the following responses and new evidence adequately address your main concerns.


Reply to Weakness

Reply to W1 - Correction of Result Inconsistencies

We sincerely thank you for carefully identifying these inconsistencies. Our intended benchmark was Amazon Industrial throughout; however, during result consolidation, some results were inadvertently misassigned to the Industrial entry in the original manuscript. This was an unintentional reporting error, and we apologize for the oversight.

To fully address your concerns, we re-evaluated Agent-R on the intended Amazon Industrial dataset and updated all corresponding results in the revised manuscript. The corrected results are:

MetricCorrected Result
NDCG@100.0229
Recall@100.0420
NDCG@500.0348
Recall@500.0950

We have also re-evaluated and reconciled all affected results across Tables 1, 2, 5, and 6, as well as the corresponding analyses and figures. The Recall@50 inconsistencies on KuaiRec and MicroLens have also been corrected. In particular, Agent-R and Prior Only now consistently report identical Recall@50 when operating on the same candidate slate, as expected from our ranking formulation.

Importantly, we have updated both the manuscript PDF and our anonymous code repository with dataset, including the corrected evaluation pipeline and multiple benchmark datasets (including Amazon Industrial and other dataset), to support independent reproduction of the revised results.

The corrected results preserve our main conclusions, with Agent-R achieving the best performance on 18 out of 20 dataset–metric combinations. We sincerely appreciate your careful review, which has helped us improve the accuracy, consistency, and reproducibility of our experimental evaluation.

Reply to W2.1 - Prior Anchoring Adapts to Prior Reliability

As you correctly noted, prior anchoring is not universally beneficial. Our additional analysis reveals that the appropriate intervention strength depends on the reliability of the inherited recommendation prior, rather than enforcing uniform preservation.

In the new Figure 9 (Appendix B.10), all datasets select the normalized rank prior (r)=-(r-1)/49, but with different validation-selected coefficients: Industrial (0.1), Software (0.5), MicroLens (0.5), and KuaiRec (0.75). Stronger priors favor conservative interventions, while weaker priors permit greater contextual refinement.

We also explicitly acknowledge that Residual Only outperforms Agent-R on KuaiRec and MicroLens. This supports a more precise conclusion: effective agency allocation requires adapting the degree of prior preservation, rather than assuming that stronger anchoring always improves accuracy. We have updated Section 4.4 and Appendix B.3 accordingly.


Reply to W2.2 - Does the Gain Come Merely from Fine-Tuning?

Your concern is well taken: comparing a fine-tuned Agent-R with a zero-shot LLM does not isolate the benefit of structured agency allocation.

We therefore introduce an independently fine-tuned, MAS-independent Pure Ranker (new Table 10). It uses the same Qwen2.5-7B backbone, LoRA architecture, and listwise training objective, but only raw user history and item information over the original collaborative candidate slate, without MAS-derived memory, planning, or recommendation evidence.

Agent-R significantly outperforms this fine-tuned baseline on all four datasets:

DatasetPure Ranker N@10Agent-R N@10Improvement [95% CI]
Software0.07970.0851+0.0054 [0.0034, 0.0075]
Industrial0.01190.0229+0.0111 [0.0080, 0.0142]
KuaiRec0.05670.0615+0.0048 [0.0020, 0.0076]
MicroLens0.01770.0199+0.0022 [0.0013, 0.0032]

Recall@50 also improves significantly on all four datasets (+0.0204/+0.0151/+0.0105/+0.0208).

These results demonstrate that standalone LLM fine-tuning does not reproduce the benefits of the complete Agent-R framework. This comparison evaluates the combined contribution of candidate adaptation and structured preference modeling, not the additive prior alone. Our additional matched within-slate analysis confirms that explicit prior anchoring has dataset-dependent benefits and is not universally superior to an unanchored fine-tuned ranker.

We also clarify that the original Direct LLM Fusion baselines were both zero-shot: Table 1 uses listwise reranking over an RRF-selected prefix, while Table 5 uses strict pointwise scoring. Their different protocols explain the reported differences.


Reply to W2.3 - Nonzero-Intervention Structure Preservation

You rightly pointed out that the original =0 property does not establish preservation under deployed configurations. We have strengthened this analysis with a nonzero-intervention guarantee:

\quad\Longrightarrow\quad s_u(i)>s_u(j),$$ which follows directly from the bounded residual |r(u,i)|1. For Industrial (=0.1), **66.9% of candidate pairs are guaranteed to preserve their relative ordering**, with zero observed violations. For larger coefficients, this sufficient condition provides no nontrivial guarantee, so we additionally measure actual ranking changes. The new **Figure 10** reports top-10 preservation of 91.8%/77.0%/64.1%/49.6% on Industrial/Software/MicroLens/KuaiRec, respectively, with corresponding Spearman correlations of 0.987/0.882/0.840/0.752. These results directly quantify the deployed intervention strength and show that **Agent-R preserves reliable structures conservatively while permitting greater correction where needed**, rather than relying on the limiting case of =0.

Reply to W2.4 - Statistical Significance

We performed paired-bootstrap testing with 10,000 user-level resamples. The new Table 11 consistently compares Agent-R against Prior Only and Residual Only across all four datasets, reporting 95% confidence intervals.

The main findings are statistically supported:

  • Residual refinement: NDCG@10 improvements over Prior Only are significant on Software (+0.0061, CI [0.0052, 0.0071]), KuaiRec (+0.0460, [0.0421, 0.0501]), and MicroLens (+0.0057, [0.0051, 0.0063]).
  • Prior anchoring: Relative to inference-only Residual Only, Agent-R significantly improves NDCG@10 on Industrial (+0.0065, [0.0040, 0.0091]) and Software (+0.0039, [0.0027, 0.0050]), while Residual Only is better on KuaiRec and MicroLens.
  • Candidate adaptation: Recall@50 improvements are significant on Software (+0.0204, [0.0173, 0.0235]) and Industrial (+0.0151, [0.0094, 0.0208]).
  • Strong fusion baselines: Agent-R significantly improves NDCG@10 over LambdaMART on Software (+0.0069, [0.0055, 0.0083]) and KuaiRec (+0.0115, [0.0084, 0.0146]).

We do not claim universal significance across all datasets or metrics.

Your suggestions motivated substantial additional validation. The revised PDF now includes Figures 9–10 and Tables 10–11 (Appendix B.10), establishing that the benefits of Agent-R extend beyond standalone LLM fine-tuning, while clarifying when prior anchoring helps and how strongly existing recommendation structures are preserved.


Reply to Questions

Reply to Q1 - Clarification of Dataset Mapping and Corrected Results

As clarified in Reply to W1, the inconsistencies originated from a dataset-to-result mapping error during result consolidation.

We have re-evaluated the reported datasets and reconciled all affected results, including Industrial, KuaiRec, and MicroLens. The corrected Industrial results are R@10 = 0.0420, N@10 = 0.0229, R@50 = 0.0950, and N@50 = 0.0348, consistently reflected across Tables 1, 2, 5, and 6.

We have also updated the revised PDF and anonymous code repository, including the relevant datasets and reproducibility materials. Paired-bootstrap significance results are additionally provided in Appendix B.10 (Table 11).


Reply to Q2 - Clarification of Direct LLM Fusion and Fine-Tuning Fairness

Thank you for raising this important question. Both Direct LLM Fusion baselines are zero-shot, without fine-tuning, but follow different evaluation protocols:

  • Table 1 (Listwise): The LLM reranks the RRF top-15, preserving the RRF ordering for the remaining candidates.
  • Table 5 (Pointwise): The LLM independently scores candidates without an inherited ranking prior.

This explains the different Software NDCG@10 results (0.0653 vs. 0.0433). We have clarified this distinction in the revised manuscript.

More importantly, to address your concern about fine-tuning fairness, we conducted an additional controlled comparison with an independently fine-tuned, MAS-independent LLM Ranker (Appendix B.10, Table 10). Both use the same Qwen2.5-7B backbone, LoRA architecture, and listwise training objective, while the Pure Ranker operates on the original collaborative candidate slate without MAS-generated information.

DatasetFine-tuned Pure RankerAgent-RΔ NDCG@10 [95% CI]
Software0.07970.0851+0.0054 [0.0034, 0.0075]
Industrial0.01190.0229+0.0111 [0.0080, 0.0142]
KuaiRec0.05670.0615+0.0048 [0.0020, 0.0076]
MicroLens0.01770.0199+0.0022 [0.0013, 0.0032]

All four improvements are statistically significant. These results demonstrate that standalone LLM fine-tuning cannot fully explain the benefits of Agent-R's complete framework, which additionally integrates candidate adaptation and structured preference modeling. This system-level comparison does not isolate prior anchoring alone; its dataset-dependent contribution is further clarified in Reply to W2.2.

Reviewer_jb2sOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

To address the limitation that existing large language model (LLM)-based recommendation agents often fail to effectively leverage the established knowledge and decision-making structures of traditional recommender systems, this paper proposes a structure-preserving multi-agent recommendation framework, Agent-R.

This method divides the recommendation process into two stages: a candidate space and a preference space. In the candidate space, a planning agent coordinates heterogeneous recommendation signals such as collaborative filtering and semantic retrieval to improve the coverage of candidate items. In the preference space, a ranking agent learns preference residuals based on user context to optimize the final ranking while preserving the original recommendation ranking prior. Experiments conducted on five recommendation datasets demonstrate that this approach improves both candidate recall and the quality of the final recommendation ranking.

Critical strengths
  1. This article focuses on how large language models can work collaboratively with existing recommender systems, rather than completely replacing traditional models. The research motivation aligns with the multi-stage decision-making characteristics of real-world recommender systems.

  2. The proposed framework integrates multi-path candidate retrieval, LLM-guided evidence fusion, contextual preference modeling, and residual ranking into a unified structure, while preserving the ranking priors of traditional recommendation models—an approach that offers practical feasibility for real-world implementation.

  3. The study evaluates the framework across five recommendation datasets from diverse domains, comparing it against collaborative filtering, generative recommendation, and multi-path fusion methods. It further analyzes the contributions of candidate space adjustment, residual ranking, and heterogeneous recommendation signals, demonstrating a commendable breadth in its experimental scope.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper emphasizes that LLM-based reasoning should only be introduced for decision-making scenarios that cannot be addressed by traditional recommendation systems. However, while the Planning Agent generates evidence-fusion strategies for users and the Ranking Agent calculates residuals for candidate items, there is no explicit mechanism to determine which specific users or decisions actually require LLM intervention.
  2. Although the authors compared RRF, LambdaMART, and Direct LLM Fusion, they did not compare them with residual reordering models that do not use LLM, under the same candidate set, ordering prior, and user context. Consequently, the current experiments cannot definitively attribute performance gains to the LLM’s reasoning capabilities, as opposed to the additional trainable parameters or contextual features.
  3. In Table 1 (page 7), the results for Agent-R on the Industrial dataset are 0.0224, 0.0418, 0.0366, and 0.1045 for NDCG@10, Recall@10, NDCG@50, and Recall@50, respectively. Yet, in Table 2 on the same page, the corresponding figures for "Full Agent-R" are 0.0198, 0.0354, 0.0308, and 0.0852.
  4. The paper primarily reports on recommendation accuracy and model invocation configurations; it lacks a direct comparison with traditional Learning-to-Rank (LTR) models regarding real-world inference latency, GPU overhead, and throughput. It is therefore difficult to justify whether the relatively modest performance improvements are sufficient to offset the additional computational costs.
Questions for authors

Please see the weaknesses.

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer jb2s

We sincerely thank you for your careful review and constructive suggestions. Your insightful comments on selective LLM intervention, controlled comparisons, experimental consistency, and computational efficiency have helped us identify important opportunities to strengthen our work. In response, we have carefully revised the manuscript and conducted substantial additional experiments and analyses. We hope the following responses and new evidence address your main concerns and further clarify the contributions and practical implications of Agent-R.


Reply to Weakness

Reply to W1 - Identifying When LLM Intervention Is Necessary

Thank you for this insightful observation. You correctly distinguish where LLM reasoning should intervene from which users actually require it. To investigate this, we conducted an additional Selective LLM Intervention Analysis (Appendix B.12), using lightweight, DEV-selected gates based exclusively on pre-LLM signals, including user history and recommendation evidence.

The results show that selective intervention can substantially reduce LLM computation while preserving most of its benefits:

DatasetPrior Only N@10Random Gate N@10Selective Gate N@10Full Agent-R N@10Gain RetainedCompute Saved
KuaiRec0.01550.03910.05300.061582%~50%
MicroLens0.01420.01700.01940.019991%~50%

Importantly, our analysis also reveals when LLM refinement is most valuable: on KuaiRec and MicroLens, stronger cross-route agreement is positively associated with ranking improvement. This suggests that LLM reasoning is particularly useful when relevant candidates are already available but their preference ordering remains unresolved—directly connecting our consideration and preference spaces.

We clarify that this is an additional feasibility analysis, not an existing invocation gate in Agent-R; the benefits are dataset-dependent. Nevertheless, these results provide concrete evidence that user-level LLM intervention can be guided by existing recommendation signals rather than applied uniformly, strengthening the practical implications of agency allocation.

Reply to W2 - Disentangling LLM Capacity from Structured Multi-Agent Reasoning

We sincerely appreciate your insightful suggestion. We agree that the improvements should be disentangled from additional trainable parameters and contextual features. We therefore conducted controlled experiments with non-LLM residual rankers under the same candidate slate, recommendation prior, contextual inputs, and listwise training objective.

1. Additional trainable parameters alone are insufficient; contextual semantic information is essential.

We conducted additional controlled comparisons with an MLP-based residual model and a fine-tuned BERT residual ranker. All methods use the same frozen 50-item candidate slate, recommendation prior, and listwise training objective.

DatasetPrior OnlyMLPResidual-BERTAgent-R
Software0.07900.07870.08350.0851
Industrial0.02200.02220.02290.0229
KuaiRec0.01550.01800.06320.0615
MicroLens0.01420.01410.02300.0199

The results reveal that additional trainable parameters alone are insufficient. The MLP remains close to Prior Only on Software, Industrial, and MicroLens. In contrast, models incorporating rich contextual semantics achieve substantially stronger ranking performance. Agent-R also significantly outperforms Residual-BERT on Software (+0.0015, 95% CI [0.0007, 0.0024]) and matches its performance on Industrial.

Residual-BERT remains competitive, including stronger results on KuaiRec and MicroLens. Accordingly, our contribution is not simply introducing more trainable parameters, but integrating contextual preference modeling into a structured multi-agent recommendation framework.

2. The complete Agent-R framework provides significant benefits beyond standalone LLM fine-tuning.

To examine the full multi-agent contribution, we additionally compare against an independently fine-tuned, MAS-independent Qwen2.5-7B ranker using raw user history and the original collaborative candidate slate (Appendix B.10, Table 10).

DatasetPure LLM RankerAgent-RΔN@10 [95% CI]
Software0.07970.0851+0.0054 [0.0034, 0.0075]
Industrial0.01190.0229+0.0111 [0.0080, 0.0142]
KuaiRec0.05670.0615+0.0048 [0.0020, 0.0076]
MicroLens0.01770.0199+0.0022 [0.0013, 0.0032]

All four improvements are statistically significant. Moreover, consideration-space adaptation independently improves Recall@50 by +0.0204/+0.0151/+0.0105/+0.0208 across these datasets. This system-level comparison evaluates the combined effects of candidate adaptation and structured preference modeling, rather than isolating the ranking backbone.

Taken together, these experiments clarify our central contribution: Agent-R's effectiveness is not simply a consequence of introducing a larger trainable ranker. It comes from coordinating complementary candidate evidence, contextual preference representations, and residual refinement within a unified recommendation framework. The non-LLM controls further reveal that this structured interface can support lightweight ranking backbones, strengthening its practical flexibility.

Reply to W3 - Correction of Industrial Results

We sincerely thank you for carefully identifying this inconsistency. After reviewing our experimental records, we found that the discrepancy originated from an inadvertent dataset-to-result mapping error during result consolidation, where results from another dataset were mistakenly reported under Industrial in Table 1. We apologize for this oversight.

We have corrected this error, re-evaluated Agent-R on the intended Amazon Industrial dataset, and updated the revised manuscript accordingly. The corrected results are NDCG@10 = 0.0229, Recall@10 = 0.0420, NDCG@50 = 0.0348, and Recall@50 = 0.0950. These results are now fully consistent across Tables 1, 2, 5, and 6.

We have also updated our anonymous code and data to support reproducibility. The corrected results preserve our main experimental conclusions, and we sincerely appreciate your careful review, which helped us improve the accuracy and consistency of our presentation.


Reply to W4 - Practical Inference Efficiency and Accuracy–Cost Trade-off

We sincerely appreciate your important concern regarding the practical computational cost of Agent-R. To address this directly, we conducted additional inference benchmarks against traditional LTR methods, measuring latency, throughput, and GPU overhead. We have added the complete results and implementation details to Appendix B.13.

1. Substantial inference acceleration without sacrificing accuracy.

We optimized Agent-R's inference through padding-free sequence packing, per-user prefix KV sharing, cached tokenization, and CPU–GPU pipelining, without changing the model or recommendation algorithm.

These optimizations achieve:

  • 2.2–3.3× lower inference latency and 2.6–3.7× higher throughput compared with our original implementation.
  • 65–95 ms p50 latency, with p95 latency at most 110 ms across all four datasets.
  • 56–82 GPU-seconds per 1,000 requests, corresponding to less than 0.1 GPU-second per recommendation.

Importantly, all four official recommendation metrics remain unchanged after optimization, as verified on the complete TEST population.

2. Meaningful accuracy improvements at a bounded inference cost.

The following table summarizes the measured accuracy–efficiency trade-off against strong classical LTR baselines:

DatasetBest Classical LTR (N@10)Agent-R (N@10)Relative Gainp50 Latency (LTR → Agent-R)Throughput (LTR → Agent-R)GPU-s / 1K
SoftwareLambdaMART (0.0782)0.0851+8.8%*4.6 → 83 ms217 → 14.270
IndustrialRRF (0.0215)0.0229+6.5%0.5 → 95 ms1,957 → 12.382
KuaiRecLambdaMART (0.0500)0.0615+23.0%*4.6 → 65 ms217 → 18.056
MicroLensRRF (0.0143)0.0199+39.2%*0.7 → 92 ms1,406 → 12.580

Agent-R achieves statistically significant NDCG@10 improvements of 8.8%, 23.0%, and 39.2% on Software, KuaiRec, and MicroLens, respectively. We acknowledge that the accuracy advantage on Industrial is smaller, illustrating that the accuracy–cost trade-off varies across domains.

3. The additional LLM computation is bounded, cacheable, and further reducible.

Importantly, Agent-R does not invoke all three LLM-based components for every recommendation request:

  • Memory and Planning Agents: Executed offline and cached per user preference state.
  • Candidate Executor: Deterministic CPU computation requiring only approximately 2 ms per request.
  • Ranking Agent: Performs non-generative residual scoring over a fixed 50-item candidate slate, rather than generating recommendations over the full catalog.

Furthermore, our additional selective-intervention analysis (Appendix B.12) demonstrates that Ranking Agent computation can be reduced by 50% on MicroLens while retaining 91% of the NDCG gain, or by 24% on KuaiRec while retaining 97%. These are optional deployment configurations rather than changes to the evaluated full Agent-R system.

Taken together, these results directly quantify the practical trade-off: although Agent-R is more computationally expensive than conventional CPU-based LTR, its optimized implementation provides sub-100-ms measured serving-stage latency, predictable GPU overhead, and substantial recommendation-quality improvements in domains where contextual refinement is particularly valuable.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.