acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Engagement Process: Modeling Agents and Environments Evolving in Time

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In real-world interaction, computation, action execution, and environmental events overlap across different timescales. Synchronous observation–action loops bind computation and interaction to shared decision boundaries, obscuring their distinct temporal structure. We introduce Engagement Process (EP), a new interaction paradigm that explicitly represents agent execution state and models the agent and environment as two processes evolving on a shared physical timeline. This makes computational progress and duration explicit while removing the one-to-one coupling between observations and actions. We formalize EP, analyze the utility of timely observations and access to computational progress, and present basic value-learning and policy-gradient methods. Guided by EP, we augment LLMs with TimeRoPE for temporal awareness and an EP interaction protocol that coordinates agent–environment interaction as both evolve in physical time. Experiments show that EP agents can learn when to compute, wait, and act, enabling more effective interaction under deadlines and asynchronous events.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Real-time interaction, Decision Making

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 25%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.75 over 4 reviews, above 25% of the others.
Reviewer_wNPqOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces an interaction paradigm called the “Engagement Process” (EP) for modeling time in sequential decision-making. It first describes EP and argues why it is needed. It then injects time into an LLM by adding a rotary positional encoding of timestamps to the tokens, which the authors call TimeRoPE. The toy experiments compare modeling under EP against instantaneous clock advancement, and the LLM experiments compare supervised fine-tuning and post-training of LLMs with TimeRoPE inserted and the interaction modeled as an EP against the standard, non-time-aware setup.

Critical strengths

Many different tasks have been considered.

Critical weaknesses

The authors clearly did not put much effort into writing this paper, so I will keep my points short and list only the main issues without going into detail.

The formulation of EP is informal and inaccurate. Moreover, as the authors themselves point out, it can be defined as a single POMDP. The authors' argument for why a POMDP is insufficient is weak and inaccurate: if a POMDP can represent an EP, the different parts of the transition can be modeled separately, so there is no value in defining EP.

The authors present reinforcement learning under EP as part of their contribution, and the paper redefines all standard algorithms and terms for EP as new concepts, in jargon-heavy language. All of these definitions and descriptions are established concepts applied to a particular POMDP, or to their EP.

The idea of adding a time index to tokens has been explored before, but the authors do not cite any of that work, and the related work section appears only in the appendix. For example, "Rotate Both Ways: Time-and-Order RoPE for Generative Recommendation" explores the same idea.

All figures look AI-generated, and the authors did not spend time polishing them.

The experiment section is written very unclearly, with most of the important details deferred to the appendix while the main text gives only vague, high-level descriptions.

The toy experiments appear to be contrived: the comparison is against a variant of the authors' own method that does not see time, or from which the "wait" action has been removed, and is therefore not fair. The LLM experiments likewise evaluate on time-sensitive environments where the baselines are not time-aware.

Overall, I found the paper very hard to follow for what is a simple idea; it is full of jargon, unclear descriptions, and unclear experiments. There are many more issues and weaknesses in this paper, but I believe the ones listed above are sufficient grounds for rejection.

Questions for authors

None

Reviewer_iYfaOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper suggests a framework called Engagement Process (EP), which handles evolution of two systems (agent, environment) in the shared physical timeline, but in asynchronous manner. Hereby asynchronous means that agent (inner) state and environment state could evolve independently to each other. This design is motivated by the fact that there could be overlap between inference and new events in the real world -- when we use step-synchronous approach, the inference should be done to get the new observation, which could have affected the inference results. In this asynchronous framework, the agent state (m_t) and the environment state (s_t) evolves based on the states from the previous time step, along with optional actions or observations. To implement this framework in LLM, the authors provided TimeRoPE and EP interaction protocol. Using these tools, LLM inference can be done considering the remaining time budget or the newest observations from the environment. The authors validated this approach across rythm tasks, Timed MATH-500 tests, and 14 heterogeneous environments that test the observation delivery.

Critical strengths

The inspiration of this work seems to be valid, and the asynchrnous formulation sounds like a reasonable solution for the suggested problem.

Critical weaknesses

I'm not familiar with LLM inference, but it seems that there are fair amount of previous work that address the similar problem ([1], [2]). Is there a way to compare EP with these similar approaches? Currently there is no comparison to any other baseline methods (there are baseline variants, but they do not handle asynchronous nature for sure), which concerns me.

Also, it would be better to polish the figures in the paper, as they look AI-generated and I feel authors did not polish them at all.

[1] Real-Time Reasoning Agents in Evolving Environments [2] Asynchronous Tool Usage for Real-Time Agents

Questions for authors

No particular questions.

Reviewer_MYE3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper investigates how agents can jointly learn what to do and when to think, wait, and act, addressing the challenge that changes in the world and changes in the model do not necessarily occur sequentially. Its contributions lie in proposing a temporal encoding scheme and an interaction protocol, and validating the effectiveness of the proposed design through multiple experiments.

Critical strengths

The paper provides relatively clear experimental evidence of the value of incorporating new information in a timely manner during the reasoning process and proposes a relatively novel method to achieve this. The paper separates the agent’s internal computational state from the environment state and unifies thinking, waiting, and acting under a common temporal objective. It further translates this formulation into a concrete protocol involving observation insertion, immediate commitment, and scheduled wake-ups, making the framework operationally actionable.

Critical weaknesses

The paper mentions some relevant prior work, but both the main text and the appendix lack fair, side-by-side comparisons with existing asynchronous methods. The incremental value of the TimeRoPE encoding design has not been sufficiently validated. In the pacing experiments, the Causal baseline uses only sequential positional information, whereas TimeRoPE additionally incorporates actual temporal information. The zeroing and shuffling ablations demonstrate that the model relies on this information. However, without comparisons against simpler timestamp-based methods or alternative encodings that provide the same temporal information, the current results cannot distinguish whether the improvements stem from the temporal information itself or from the specific design of TimeRoPE. Therefore, its advantages over simpler alternatives remain unclear.

Questions for authors

AgileThinker and RRARA have already demonstrated real-time responsiveness or asynchronous reasoning. What specific additional value does EP offer over these existing methods? Could the authors provide corresponding experiments to substantiate its advantages? Are there any comparative results using simple timestamps or alternative temporal encodings that provide the same temporal information as TimeRoPE? Can the existing evidence establish that the improvements stem from TimeRoPE’s specific encoding design, or does it primarily demonstrate that providing the model with actual temporal information is sufficient to improve performance?

Reviewer_bZ6pOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This work attempts to study the problem setting of LLM agents that interact asynchronously with an external environment that continuously evolves in time. The authors encode timing information into a positional encoding, and equip agents with a harness they designed for this setting. The approach is evaluated on synthetic benchmarks that incorporate some degree of time sensitivity.

Critical strengths

The problem of acting in an evolving world is indeed an important and understudied one.

Authors include extensive experimental details in the appendix.

Critical weaknesses

The writing is so unclear that it’s not really possible to understand the details. It is so incredibly dense with unexplained and undefined terms; nothing is precise.

For example, Section 2.2 lines 140-147 are completely impenetrable. This is just the standard RL objective of maximizing expected return restricted to a policy class, but obfuscated to an incredible degree. What is this “admissible class”? No idea what the last sentence (“Deliberation…”) means; what deadlines?

unexpected observations, asynchronous actions, and concurrent tasks, with observations and actions occurring at different or varying rates

Again very unclear. “Unexpected” meaning observation occurs at unknown times? What does expected mean in this context? Regular intervals? Or “unexpected” as in surprising? Also, what is an asynchronous action? This one I don’t even really have a guess for. Then “tasks” is also introduced. What does that even mean here?

No related work discussion in the main text and leaving it only in the appendix is a major issue in my opinion. I did look at the one in the appendix, and the related work seems to mostly only consider work applying RL in the context of LLMs, but there is plenty of other prior work on this topic of asynchronous or real-time RL that is omitted. The prime example that comes to mind is Ramstedt, S., & Pal, C. (2019). Real-time reinforcement learning. Advances in neural information processing systems, 32.

It’s a bit hard to tell because of the above issues, but I believe there is low novelty in the contributions here. Agents that choose to wait before requesting another observation have been around since AlphaStar in 2019 (if not earlier; that’s just a high-profile instance that comes to mind for me). Recurrent policies are also quite common in the literature (and were used in AlphaStar, coincidentally). There is maybe some slight novelty in their specific positional encoding, but without a detailed related work comparison, it’s hard to know.

The empirical evaluation is rather weak: a few toy tabular Q-learning experiments and then LLM experiments on synthetic tasks designed by the authors. These tasks seem quite trivial for a policy given time information, even a simple policy trained from scratch. It is unclear why an LLM or foundation model is needed for these problems. I understand the use of toy benchmarks in research but given the importance of generalization in foundation models, these particular experimental results have not convinced me that the findings will generalize to problems with actual real-time importance. Also, I’m not exactly sure of what those transferable findings would be.

Line 375: We evaluate EP across 14 heterogeneous environments with shared temporal and action-lifecycle semantics

So you created even more environments, which are described not at all in the main text? Even after looking through Appendices H and I, I don’t know hardly anything about these environments, no less enough to reproduce them. If they’re anything like the other synthetic environments, like MATH with time limits added, it still strikes me as a poor evaluation for these methods, as these are not problems where the reactivity and latency are fundamental to the sequential interaction. MATH with a time limit is just returning a final answer; a token budget is a simple baseline that solves this (i.e., appending a phrase to signal the end of thinking and then reading out the answer, as was done in Qwen 3 and GLM-V, for example). There are plenty of more motivating examples in real-world control.

Questions for authors

What was done to ensure the baseline is a fair comparison? Something that came to mind for me is that the very simple approach of adding time information in the text prompt, as well as appending an “end of thinking” phrase when an answer is needed would probably do very well on these benchmarks. Do you expect your approach to outperform such a baseline, and, if so, why?

100-turn cap;

Why? I mean if latency is important why do this? Would this penalize checking the clock? And what even is a turn here, since math is just returning a final answer (i.e., no user turns)? A tool call?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.