acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

TGO-MAS: TEMPORAL GRAPH ORGANIZATION FOR MULTI-AGENT SYSTEMS

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large language model systems with multiple agents must decide both which agents interact and when each interaction becomes available during execution over multiple steps. Workflow descriptions and static communication graphs can encode endpoints or order, but they do not make the activation step of a typed interaction an explicit decision variable. We therefore formulate temporal graph organization that is aware of execution steps around the insight that interaction timing is part of organization rather than execution metadata. TGO-MAS instantiates this formulation as a closed scheduling loop. It represents candidates that pair typed interactions with activation steps, scores them from the observed execution prefix, selects a feasible set for the next step, and revises the next decision after delivery, failure, or completion. Structural analysis establishes several consequences of this construction. Static projections can discard temporal distinctions, static schedules are contained in the action space for the next step, and the optional accounting and event record extensions satisfy stated feasibility and reconstruction conditions. TGO-MAS outperforms the strongest baseline, the DyTopo reimplementation, by 2.94% on HumanEval-heldout-124 and 1.88% on MMLU-validation-1531.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
multi-agent systems, large language models, LLM agents, agent orchestration, communication topology, temporal graph, execution-aware scheduling, closed-loop replanning, agentic AI

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_XtDwOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors proposed TGO-MAS that models LLM multi-agent interaction as a step-aware scheduling problem, where a closed-loop organizer processes execution history and uses separate readiness and value heads to score candidate actions, and selects feasible steps under budget constraints, and replans based on real-time feedback.

Critical strengths
  • The framing is clear and novel: compared to static topologies and post-hoc traces based organizations of multi-agent interactions, the proposed method treats agent interaction activation timing as explicit decision variables, illustrated by examples, which facilitates optimizations such as dynamic planning aware of execution status.
  • Solid and well-motivated problem formulation. The authors modeled a real-world scenario in a clear way, defining the typed temporal decision objective, and hence formulating prefix online scheduling and task objective. Clean and easy to follow.
  • Promising experimental study was proposed, showing stronger results compared to existing static and dynamic baselines across benchmark datasets. It is worth noting that the proposed method achieved improved performance with reduced token consumption.
Critical weaknesses
  • Minor: In Section 3 it may help to have a list of the definition not only for the notations, but also for the operations.
  • The experimental study is sort of bound to a fixed small number of agents and limited task domains, which may not effectively illustrate the application towards various real settings. For example, as the number of agents increases, a graph node may become a super node connecting to many other nodes which implies a possible information propagation bottleneck, and hence impacts the planning and scheduling.
  • The authors should clarify if the proposed mechanism is confounded with the ablation design. The authors concede this caveat, but should address it in the experiment or clearly call out its impact in the experimental observations.
  • The paper acknowledges that its findings cannot claim statistical significance or proven superiority over baselines. While I appreciate the honest of the authors, it brings some confusion on how to properly interpret the experimental observations. The authors should clarify it.
Questions for authors

n/a

Reviewer_pp85OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TGO-MAS, a temporal graph organization method for LLM multi-agent systems. It decides both which typed interactions occur and when each one activates during multi-step execution. The motivation is that interaction timing is part of organization rather than execution metadata. Workflows, static topologies and post-hoc traces do not make the activation step of a typed interaction an explicit decision variable. TGO-MAS separates readiness from value, selects a feasible interaction set under resource constraints, and replans after observed feedback. Against the DyTopo reimplementation, it reports gains of 2.94% on HumanEval-heldout-124 and 1.88% on MMLU-validation-1531 with fewer tokens. The authors describe these results as descriptive, without inferential intervals.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear problem formulation. The paper makes the activation step of a typed interaction an explicit decision variable, q = (u, v, r, a), under a stated information boundary that excludes future outcomes. Proposition 1 shows that static projections can discard temporal distinctions. This reframing of MAS organization is the main conceptual contribution and the main reason the work is of interest.
  2. Targeted timing intervention. Time permutation keeps endpoints and interaction types fixed. Under it, HumanEval pass@1 drops by 3.12 points, required-window coverage drops by 17.5 points, and the deadline-miss rate rises by 15.9 points (Figure 4). This is the most direct evidence that connects mistimed delivery to an end-to-end consequence, which is the paper’s core thesis.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Unverifiable implementation and results. Appendix K states that the supplied package contains no executable implementation or run manifest, and key settings such as the backbone LLM and how the encoder and assessor are trained are not reported.
  2. Insufficient evidence for the central claims. The gains over DyTopo amount to 2.19 and 1.45 points, reported without seed counts or inferential intervals, and no ablation tests the separation of readiness from value that defines the method.
  3. Undefined and mislabeled metric. The recovery metric reported in Figure 5 and Table 13 is never defined in Table 8, and the Figure 5 legend labels DyTopo as recovery while the caption attributes recovery to TGO-MAS.
  4. Unexplained baseline gap. The G-Designer results in Table 3 are far below those reported in its original paper, and the submission does not state the backbone LLM that would explain the difference.
  5. Inaccurate references. Several references have wrong titles, wrong authors or wrong links, which suggests they were not checked against the original sources.
  • Line 590, Kakarlapudi et al. 2022: the title “Communication and coordination in bandwidth-limited multiagent systems” does not exist. The given authors, venue and URL correspond to “Decision-Theoretic Planning with Communication in Open Multiagent Systems” (UAI 2022).
  • Line 599, Kesper et al. 2023: the cited title belongs to a different paper, Funk et al. (2021, IFAC Journal of Systems and Control). The given authors, venue and URL correspond to “Toward Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning for Distributed Event-Triggered Control” (L4DC 2023).
  • Line 603, Kim et al. 2019: the OpenReview link (id=HUAnBToP_a) does not point to this paper. The correct forum id is SJxu5iR9KQ.
  • Line 706, Tian et al. 2021: the title “Compact graph information bottleneck for multi-agent communication” matches none of the four arXiv versions. All four are titled “CGIBNet: Bandwidth-constrained Communication with Graph Information Bottleneck in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning”.
  • Line 733, Yun et al. 2026: the title “A unified framework for dynamic multi-agent system construction and orchestration” does not exist. arXiv:2604.17148 has a single version titled “Graph-of-Agents: A Graph-based Framework for Multi-Agent LLM Collaboration”.
Questions for authors

See weakness

Reviewer_das8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper formulates multi-agent communication as online, history-conditioned selection of typed interactions. The proposed framework, TGO-MAS, evaluates candidates using readiness scores alongside predicted relative value, applies budget and capacity constraints, and updates plans upon receiving feedback. Across 5-agent setups on HumanEval and MMLU, the authors report higher task accuracy with reduced token usage compared to their reimplementation of DyTopo.

Critical strengths

S1: Clear problem formulation. Decoupling message readiness from predicted relative value addresses a practical issue in multi-agent coordination (e.g., waiting for an unfinished verifier output). The execution state, observability boundaries, and interaction action space are formalized reasonably well.

S2: Informative control baselines. The trade-off between task quality and token overhead is well documented. In particular, including a rule-based scheduler and compute-matched single-agent baselines provides useful reference points, and the timing interventions demonstrate the importance of interaction timing for downstream task performance.

Critical weaknesses

W1: Missing implementation details. The actual scheduler used in the experiments is severely underspecified. The text defines the history encoder and the readiness/value heads only abstractly as functional interfaces. In the optimization section, the authors list several potential training targets rather than describing the exact objective, loss weights, and optimization protocol used to obtain the reported results. Crucially, the manuscript does not state the underlying LLM backbone.

W2: Unclear advantage over history-conditioned dynamic graph baselines. Although the paper formalizes longer-horizon scheduling, the evaluated implementation only selects interactions for the next step. As a result, its practical distinction from existing history-conditioned edge selection methods remains weak. Furthermore, while the ablation studies examine timestamps and execution history, they do not directly isolate the benefit of the readiness–value decomposition itself. It remains unclear how much of the performance gain stems from this decomposition rather than simply from using richer execution history.

Questions for authors

Q1: What specific LLM backbone was used across agents? What architectures were used for the encoder and readiness/value heads, and what loss functions and training signals were used during optimization?

Q2: How many independent random seeds were used in Table 3? Could the authors report the paired confidence intervals and corrected significance tests described in Appendix I.4?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.