- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes GuidedEvolve, a prompt-evolution framework for multimodal misinformation detection. At each iteration, an analyst VLM examines a batch of validation cases and generates structured diagnoses covering the error type, overlooked evidence, likely source of confusion, and a proposed revision. The framework accumulates these suggestions and uses them to produce a feedback-guided prompt alongside a standard evolutionary candidate; the candidates are compared using validation performance. The evaluation covers MMFakeBench, AMG, and DeceptionDecoded, with additional backbone comparisons on AMG. GuidedEvolve reports the best F1 among the compared methods on all three datasets, with the largest margin over GEPA on MMFakeBench and smaller margins on AMG and DeceptionDecoded. Ablations suggest that both diagnostic feedback and the guided-candidate branch contribute to the final performance.
Critical strengths
1. A relevant problem and a modular optimization design.
The paper recognizes that heterogeneous failures may require different prompt revisions, while aggregate fitness provides little guidance about what to change. Using case-level diagnoses to guide one branch of an evolutionary search is a reasonable and practically deployable idea. It does not require fine-tuning the task VLM, and in principle it can be integrated into existing prompt optimizers.
2. Broad baseline coverage and component ablations.
The evaluation spans three multimodal misinformation benchmarks and compares against a range of prompt-optimization approaches. The ablation removing diagnostic feedback performs worse than the full method, providing preliminary evidence that feedback contributes beyond unguided candidate generation. The effort to keep total LLM-call budgets close also makes the comparison more informative than an evaluation with unconstrained extra search.
Critical weaknesses
1. The claimed discovery of reusable decision criteria is not directly demonstrated, and the distinction from existing reflective optimizers remains unclear.
The method adds structured error diagnosis to an evolutionary optimizer, but the paper does not isolate which part of this structure is novel relative to natural-language reflection in methods such as GEPA and PromptAgent. The accumulated feedback is described largely as a set of suggestions; it is not clear how duplicate or contradictory suggestions are consolidated into stable rules, or how a rule inferred from one case is distinguished from an overfit correction for that case. The reported F1 improvements demonstrate utility of the full pipeline, but do not by themselves demonstrate that it discovers interpretable, reusable, or transferable decision criteria.
2. The empirical analysis does not sufficiently explain the performance differences, and the evaluation protocol leaves robustness and cost questions open.
The gain over GEPA is relatively small on AMG and DeceptionDecoded, while the paper reports means over three seeds without paired confidence intervals or significance tests for these comparisons. The larger MMFakeBench gain is encouraging, but the run-to-run variability also warrants a paired analysis. Further, because the same validation set is repeatedly used to diagnose errors and select candidates throughout evolution, the final prompt may adapt to idiosyncrasies of that set. The paper does not adequately analyze this risk or show which error categories are corrected by the feedback.
The compute comparison also matches call counts rather than input/output tokens, monetary cost, or wall-clock time. Calls used for multimodal inference, diagnosis, and candidate generation can have very different costs. Finally, the multi-backbone study is limited to AMG and a subset of baselines, so it supports preliminary robustness rather than broad cross-dataset generality. Reporting paired per-seed results, error-category transitions, a validation-to-test generalization analysis, and token/cost measurements would make the evidence more convincing.
Questions for authors
- Novelty and mechanism: What specifically distinguishes the proposed structured diagnosis from the natural-language reflection used by GEPA or PromptAgent? Do the authors have examples or existing analyses showing that diagnoses are consolidated into stable criteria, rather than remaining case-specific suggestions?
- Robustness and validation reuse: Can the authors report paired per-seed comparisons or confidence intervals against GEPA, especially on AMG and DeceptionDecoded? Given that the validation set is repeatedly used for diagnosis and selection, is there evidence that the gains are not primarily due to adaptive overfitting to that set?
- Practical cost and error analysis: Can the authors provide token usage and runtime, in addition to call counts, and identify which error types are corrected by the diagnostic feedback? This would clarify both the source of the gains and the actual cost of obtaining them.
4 comments
Reponse to authors
Dear Authors,
I checked my original review doc, this is indeed a mistake. I have updated my review.
Thanks.
Response to Reviewer xRgj (Part 1)
Q1: Novelty and mechanism.
R1: We thank the reviewer for the suggestions. GuidedEvolve integrates structured case-level diagnosis, feedback accumulation, and evolutionary search through a nested inner–outer loop framework. To validate these components, we conduct two additional ablations: Free-form Feedback, replacing structured diagnosis with unrestricted feedback, and w/o Feedback Accumulation, using feedback from only one case per update.
| Method | MMFakeBench (F1/Acc./Prec./Rec.) | AMG (F1/Acc./Prec./Rec.) |
|---|---|---|
| Free-form Feedback | 47.12 / 51.91 / 52.38 / 46.68 | 26.43 / 40.31 / 31.81 / 31.04 |
| w/o Feedback Accumulation | 51.54 / 54.60 / 54.85 / 53.48 | 23.57 / 42.10 / 28.10 / 26.21 |
| GuidedEvolve (Full) | 58.15 / 59.58 / 61.66 / 57.84 | 26.94 / 48.12 / 29.85 / 30.17 |
GuidedEvolve improves F1 over Free-form Feedback by 11.03/0.51 points and over w/o Feedback Accumulation by 6.61/3.37 points on MMFakeBench/AMG, supporting the contributions of structured diagnosis and multi-case feedback accumulation.
Representative Case. For MemeMind_train_002986 (“DONALD SHRUMP”), the original prompt incorrectly predicted harmful (1) instead of harmless (0). Diagnosis identified insufficient consideration of contextual humor and targeting intent, leading to the following guidance:
“Before labeling as harmful, verify whether the humor is neutralized by context (e.g., public figure name + pun) and whether it avoids targeting vulnerable groups or sensitive topics.”
The revised prompt also corrected another example outside the diagnostic batch:
| Example | Ground Truth | Before Revision | After Revision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chuck Norris meme | Harmless (0) | Harmful (1) ✗ | Harmless (0) ✓ |
This illustrates how case-level diagnosis can yield reusable decision criteria beyond the original diagnostic example.
Q2: Robustness and validation reuse.
R2: We provide additional analyses of statistical reliability, optimization sensitivity, and disjoint validation to assess robustness and potential validation overfitting.
(1) Paired Statistical Reliability. We compare GuidedEvolve against GEPA across three matched seeds, with 10,000 paired bootstrap resamples over aligned test predictions.
| Dataset | Seed 42 | Seed 43 | Seed 44 | Mean ΔF1 | SD | Bootstrap 95% CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MMFakeBench | 0.88 | 4.60 | 8.74 | 4.74 | 3.93 | [4.02, 5.46] |
| AMG | −0.01 | −0.29 | 2.82 | 0.84 | 1.72 | [−1.07, 2.69] |
| DeceptionDecoded | −1.33 | 0.84 | 3.19 | 0.90 | 2.26 | [−0.69, 2.48] |
GuidedEvolve achieves positive mean gains on all benchmarks, outperforming GEPA across all three seeds on MMFakeBench, whose prediction-level bootstrap interval is strictly positive. AMG and DeceptionDecoded show smaller, less consistent gains, with intervals including zero. Across-seed variability and prediction-level uncertainty are distinct, and additional seeds remain future work.
(2) Optimization Sensitivity Analysis. We evaluate validation/held-out test F1 (%) at different optimization iterations.
| Iterations | MMFake Val/Test | AMG Val/Test | Deception Val/Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 36.50 / 37.02 | 21.18 / 23.09 | 67.78 / 66.07 |
| 10 | 51.79 / 39.81 | 27.13 / 23.78 | 70.66 / 68.66 |
| 20 | 53.61 / 38.46 | 29.05 / 24.38 | 72.55 / 70.93 |
| 40 | 60.93 / 48.39 | 31.27 / 24.39 | 74.20 / 72.56 |
| 60 | 62.71 / 47.48 | 32.41 / 25.40 | 74.75 / 73.07 |
| 80 | 63.91 / 54.46 | 33.24 / 25.83 | 75.61 / 73.88 |
| 100 | 64.21 / 57.81 | 33.60 / 26.95 | 75.87 / 74.98 |
From iteration 0 to 100, held-out test F1 increases by 20.79, 3.86, and 8.91 points, respectively. Despite intermediate fluctuations and validation–test gaps, we observe no sustained deterioration in test performance within the evaluated optimization budget.
(3) Disjoint Validation Evaluation. We separate diagnostic feedback generation and candidate evaluation into non-overlapping validation subsets.
| Method | MMFake F1 | AMG F1 | Deception F1 |
|---|---|---|---|
| AlphaEvolve | 51.74 | 24.14 | 70.53 |
| GuidedEvolve (Original) | 58.15 | 26.94 | 75.02 |
| GuidedEvolve (Disjoint) | 52.33 | 25.12 | 74.02 |
Despite reduced performance relative to the original setting, **GuidedEvolve (Disjoint) still outperforms AlphaEvolve. Together, these results provide further evidence of GuidedEvolve's generalization capability and effectiveness under different validation protocols.
Response to Reviewer xRgj (Part 2)
Q3: Validation-set Overfitting and Generalization.
R3: We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. To assess potential overfitting from repeated validation reuse, we conduct two additional experiments: (1) optimization sensitivity analysis and (2) disjoint validation evaluation.
(1) Optimization Sensitivity Analysis. We evaluate the best prompts obtained at different optimization iterations on both validation and held-out test sets. The table below reports mean F1 scores (%).
| Iterations | MMFake Val/Test | AMG Val/Test | Deception Val/Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 36.50 / 37.02 | 21.18 / 23.09 | 67.78 / 66.07 |
| 10 | 51.79 / 39.81 | 27.13 / 23.78 | 70.66 / 68.66 |
| 20 | 53.61 / 38.46 | 29.05 / 24.38 | 72.55 / 70.93 |
| 40 | 60.93 / 48.39 | 31.27 / 24.39 | 74.20 / 72.56 |
| 60 | 62.71 / 47.48 | 32.41 / 25.40 | 74.75 / 73.07 |
| 80 | 63.91 / 54.46 | 33.24 / 25.83 | 75.61 / 73.88 |
| 100 | 64.21 / 57.81 | 33.60 / 26.95 | 75.87 / 74.98 |
Despite fluctuations at intermediate iterations, test F1 improves from iteration 0 to 100 across all three benchmarks, with gains of 20.79, 3.86, and 8.91 points, respectively. Notably, validation improvements are accompanied by overall test improvements rather than sustained test-performance degradation. These results suggest that repeated optimization does not cause progressive deterioration in held-out performance within the evaluated budget, although some validation–test gaps remain.
(2) Disjoint Validation Evaluation. We further separate the validation data into two non-overlapping subsets, using one for diagnostic feedback generation and the other for prompt evaluation and selection.
| Method | MMFake F1 | AMG F1 | Deception F1 |
|---|---|---|---|
| AlphaEvolve | 51.74 | 24.14 | 70.53 |
| GuidedEvolve (Original) | 58.15 | 26.94 | 75.02 |
| GuidedEvolve (Disjoint) | 52.33 | 25.12 | 74.02 |
Under disjoint validation, GuidedEvolve retains improvements over AlphaEvolve of 0.59, 0.98, and 3.49 F1 points, respectively. Although performance decreases relative to the original setting, these results indicate that the benefits of diagnostic feedback are not entirely dependent on using overlapping validation examples for diagnosis and candidate selection.
Overall, the two experiments provide complementary evidence: optimization sensitivity analysis demonstrates consistent overall improvements in held-out test performance across increasing optimization iterations, while disjoint validation preserves improvements over AlphaEvolve across all three benchmarks. These results provide complementary evidence for the effectiveness and robustness of GuidedEvolve across multiple benchmarks and under different validation protocols.
Request for Clarification Regarding Potential Review–Manuscript Mismatch
Dear Reviewer xRgj,
We sincerely thank you for your time and feedback. However, we noticed that several concerns raised in your review refer to concepts that are not discussed in our manuscript, including observability margins, linear transports, external anchors, and RRF recovery. The review also references Appendices Q.4 and Q.5, neither of which exists in our paper.
Our submission, GuidedEvolve: Feedback-Guided Prompt Evolution for Discovering Implicit Decision Criteria, focuses on structured diagnostic feedback and evolutionary prompt optimization, as described in Sections 3.1–3.3.
Given these discrepancies, we wonder whether some of the comments may have been intended for a different submission. We would greatly appreciate it if you could kindly verify whether your review corresponds to our manuscript.
Thank you for your time and consideration.