- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose TaoGraph, a method that dynamically reorganizes spatial features based on the 'task instruction' and the overall semantics of the scene. TaoGraph uses Semantics-Induced Spatial Reorganization, which reorganizes generic spatial characteristics based on the task instruction and the overall semantics of the scene, and Change-Aware Procedure Distillation, which induces learning based on the prediction differences between two teacher models, allowing the model to effectively learn the procedural knowledge required for action sequence reasoning. As a result, in task planning reasoning metrics and graph generation quality metrics, the proposed method has improved performance compared to the prior research MomaGraph and other closed VLMs.
Critical strengths
- TaoGraph dynamically reorganizes spatial features based on the 'task instruction' and the overall semantics of the scene. As a result, spatial cues essential for the task goal remain and unnecessary information is deleted, so the graph composition is flexibly adapted to the task.
- The proposed Change-Aware Procedure Distillation is a procedure-guided graph supervision method that distills knowledge through procedure-enriched graph predictions. It induces learning based on the prediction differences between two teacher models, making the model effectively learn the procedural knowledge required for action sequence reasoning.
- In the task planning reasoning metrics and graph generation quality metrics, the proposed methodology has better performance compared to the prior research MomaGraph and other closed VLMs.
Critical weaknesses
- Metrics such as Sequence-Sensitive Subset, Sequence Planning, Node F1, Spatial F1, and Edge F1 may show better performance simply because TaoGraph is more overfitted to the output of this context. There is insufficient evidence that this actually leads to better spatial knowledge or better downstream tasks compared to the baseline (especially non-finetuned ones).
- To verify generalization on unlearned external benchmarks (External Evaluation), external benchmarks called BLINK and MMSI-Bench are used, but even these might be favorable conditions for a model trained to output a specific form of graphs.
- Tests were conducted in the ManiSkill 3D simulation environment. Although it provides a qualitative demo where the scene graph extracted by the model (e.g., the open/close relationship between the handle and the microwave oven, sequential operation of two stove knobs) is input to the planner and the robot actually determines and executes the interaction targets and action sequences, there is no verification on whether this leads to a meaningful improvement compared to baselines such as MomaGraph.
Questions for authors
Has it been verified in what setup, for which downstream task, for what reason, and by how much having better graph generation or a graph better aligned with the instruction actually leads to improvements?
8 comments
Response to Reviewer yuFd (2/4)
W2 : To verify generalization on unlearned external benchmarks (External Evaluation), external benchmarks called BLINK and MMSI-Bench are used, but even these might be favorable conditions for a model trained to output a specific form of graphs.
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We agree that it is important to examine whether the choice of external subtasks and the evaluation protocol favor models trained to generate graphs in the target format. To address this concern, we explain how the selected subtasks relate to the information needed for embodied task planning and report a controlled comparison to assess whether TaoGraph’s gains persist when the Qwen baselines also receive scene graph training.
1. Rationale for the external evaluation
First, BLINK and MMSI-Bench are general-purpose public benchmarks used in prior evaluations of vision-language models (e.g., LLaVA-OneVision [1], LLaVA-Interleave [2], and ViLaSR [3]). We use them only for external evaluation (Appendix D.1) and score each question by the correctness of the final multiple-choice answer (Section 4.1).
Second, TaoGraph is designed for embodied task planning. It builds a task-oriented scene graph from multi-view observations and a task instruction. The graph captures task-relevant objects, interactive parts, and their functional and spatial relations, which help the planner identify interaction targets and reason about action order. We selected external subtasks that probe similar information, such as functional correspondence and relative object positions, to test whether the learned graph representation transfers beyond MomaGraph-Bench (Section 4.2.4). Tasks that rely on other visual cues may benefit from representations tailored to those cues.
2. Comparison with Fine-tuned baselines
We evaluate the same Graph SFT baselines as in our response to Weakness 1 on BLINK and MMSI-Bench. The table below reports the accuracy (%).
| Method | Func. Corr. | Obj. Loc. | Spatial Rel. | Obj.–Obj. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MomaGraph-R1 | 20.00 | 40.16 | 79.02 | 28.72 |
| Qwen2.5-VL-7B + Graph SFT | 26.15 | 54.10 | 79.72 | 34.04 |
| Qwen3-VL-8B + Graph SFT | 23.85 | 49.18 | 82.52 | 24.47 |
| Ours* | 33.85 | 58.20 | 79.72 | 35.11 |
* Ours uses Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct as its vision-language model backbone.
Compared with Qwen2.5-VL-7B + Graph SFT, TaoGraph achieves higher accuracy on Functional Correspondence, Object Localization, and object–object positional reasoning, and matches it on Spatial Relation.
We will add a description of the external evaluation setting and the above control results to the revised manuscript.
References
[1] Li B, Zhang Y, Guo D, et al. Llava-onevision: Easy visual task transfer[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2408.03326, 2024.
[2] Li F, Zhang R, Zhang H, et al. Llava-interleave: Tackling multi-image, video, and 3d in large multimodal models[C]//International Conference on Learning Representations. 2025, 2025: 81182-81199.
[3] Wu J, Guan J, Feng K, et al. Reinforcing spatial reasoning in vision-language models with interwoven thinking and visual drawing[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2026, 38: 143297-143330.
Response to Reviewer yuFd (3/4)
W3 : Tests were conducted in the ManiSkill 3D simulation environment. Although it provides a qualitative demo where the scene graph extracted by the model (e.g., the open/close relationship between the handle and the microwave oven, sequential operation of two stove knobs) is input to the planner and the robot actually determines and executes the interaction targets and action sequences, there is no verification on whether this leads to a meaningful improvement compared to baselines such as MomaGraph.
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We agree that a quantitative comparison is needed to determine whether TaoGraph improves task performance in simulation. To address this concern, we compared TaoGraph with MomaGraph-R1 in ManiSkill.
The experiments follow the process in Appendix F.2 and cover 3 tasks: turning on the kitchen sink faucet (spanning 8 kitchen layouts and 5 faucet models), and the two tasks in Figure 7, opening a microwave oven and sequentially rotating two stove knobs, with 57 configurations in total. In each configuration, the execution success rate is evaluated on two decisions, the action and the interaction target. The results are as follows (%).
| Task | # Trials | MomaGraph-R1 | Ours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Faucet | 80 | 55.00 | 80.00 |
| Microwave oven | 20 | 80.00 | 85.00 |
| Two stove knobs | 14 | 100.00 | 100.00 |
In addition, we conduct a test specifically on spatial relations in the same configurations: each configuration contains one multiple-choice question on the spatial relation between objects in the scene, evaluated by accuracy. The results are as follows (%).
| Task | # Questions | MomaGraph-R1 | Ours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Faucet | 40 | 20.00 | 32.50 |
| Microwave oven | 10 | 10.00 | 20.00 |
| Two stove knobs | 7 | 28.57 | 42.86 |
We will add the setup and results of the above simulation comparison experiments to the revised manuscript.
Response to Reviewer yuFd (1/4)
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We agree that it is important to assess whether TaoGraph’s reported gains can be explained by adaptation to the target scene graph format. To address this concern, we conducted two sets of additional experiments. First, we fine-tuned Qwen2.5 and Qwen3 for scene graph generation on the same training data used for TaoGraph and compared their graph generation and downstream planning performance. Second, we evaluated spatial and functional relations using metrics that require each relation to be assigned to the correct pair of objects.
1. Fine-tuned baselines
We applied supervised fine-tuning for scene graph generation (Graph SFT) to Qwen2.5-VL-7B and Qwen3-VL-8B using the same scene graph training data as TaoGraph. On the same graph validation split, the results are as follows (%).
We further compare the performance of these methods on MomaGraph-Bench (%):
Graph SFT improves both Qwen baselines on all three graph generation metrics, showing that task adaptation matters. TaoGraph scores higher than both fine-tuned baselines on all reported graph generation and downstream planning metrics.
2. Relation triplet evaluation
To assess whether individual relations are assigned to the correct object pairs, we follow prior work on scene graph evaluation [1][2] and represent each relation as a (subject, relation, object) triplet, such as (handle, openorclose, microwave) for a functional relation and (handle, in_front_of, microwave) for a spatial relation. The table below reports micro-averaged precision, recall, and F1 (%) separately for functional and spatial triplets [3].
Compared with Qwen3-VL-8B + Graph SFT, TaoGraph is 13.61 and 27.46 percentage points higher in functional and spatial triplet F1, respectively. This shows that the improvement lies in recovering relations on the correct object pairs, not merely in whether relation types appear at the graph level.
In summary, after the baselines receive the same scene graph fine-tuning, TaoGraph still recovers more accurate object-pair relations and achieves higher task accuracy. We will add the above fine-tuned baselines and relation metrics to the revised manuscript.