- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CSF U-Net, which replaces same-scale skip concatenation with a bidirectional recurrent block that fuses all aligned encoder scales. The block uses gated prediction, innovation, and correction steps, motivated by a Kalman recursion under a linear-Gaussian model along the scale axis and an analysis of the squared-loss risk gap. On SegPC, ISIC, GLaS and MoNuSeg, CSF U-Net achieves the lowest HD95 on all four datasets and the highest Dice on three. It requires 4.0× the latency and 3.8× the training memory of a parameter-matched concatenation baseline.
Critical strengths
-
A well-justified problem is presented in the paper: do non-matching encoder scales offer information additional to the matching skip? Frozen-feature probes with paired-and-shuffled controls show that they do.
-
CSF outperforms vanilla U-Net on all four benchmarks and achieves the lowest HD95 for each one. The authors have also acknowledged the limits of the theory and the computational expense.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is limited, and the connection between the theory and the method is weak. Eq. (4) is very similar to a ConvGRU over scales and has most of the components already present in [A-C]. The Kalman analysis does little to distinguish the method; the gate does not receive the reliability , while retention and damping have no counterpart in the theory.
- Evaluation includes U-Net variants from 2015-2022 and FuseUNet (2025), but excludes the current state-of-the-art segmentation models, e.g., [D-F].
- The baselines may be under-tuned. Reproduction of UCTransNet's results is lower than the published results for GLaS (87.70 vs. 90.18) and MoNuSeg (73.53 vs. 79.08). TransUNet has also been trained without pre-training.
- CSF is substantially more computationally expensive than the baselines, while several accuracy gains are within the reported variation. An equal-cost comparison is required to determine the advantage of using it as a drop-in replacement.
[A] UNET 3+: A FULL-SCALE CONNECTED UNET FOR MEDICAL IMAGE SEGMENTATION
[B] Bi-Directional ConvLSTM U-Net with Densley Connected Convolutions
[C] FuseUNet: A Multi-Scale Feature Fusion Method for U-like Networks
[D] Scalefusionnet: transformer-guided multi-scale feature fusion for skin lesion segmentation.
[E] When Mamba Meets xLSTM: An Efficient and Precise Method with the xLSTM-VMUNet Model for Skin lesion Segmentation
[F] VM-UNet: Vision Mamba UNet for Medical Image Segmentation
Questions for authors
- Could you compare CSF with a ConvGRU/ConvLSTM scan over scales and with non-recurrent adaptive scale weighting? These comparisons would help clarify what the Kalman-inspired structure adds beyond gated recurrence.
- Gate does not directly obtain or . Does decrease with the addition of noise at scale , as expected due to reliability-driven gain?
- Explain the difference between the reproduced and published UCTransNet results, and report the results of TransUNet with pre-training.
- Could you add [D-F] and an equal-cost baseline? Is the latency at a characteristic of the method, or is it due to the implementation?
- Where is the "decoder-stability analysis" referred to in the Reproducibility Statement? Please specify the data splits, model selection, metric calculations, and ablation implementations as well.