acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

ACTIVE NEURAL MATTER: FINITE-WINDOW RESPONSE IN PHYSICAL SYSTEMS AND AI WORKFLOWS

Abstract

Delayed interactions carry local perturbations through shared states before they alter observable outcomes. Endpoint changes alone leave their sources and propagation unresolved. We formulate Active Neural Matter (ANM) as a finite-window local response theory linking source perturbations, retained shared states carrying information between interactions, and system-specific readouts. Readout maps and declared endpoint criteria define operating boundaries on accessible states; dynamics determine responses relative to them. Readouts may be scalar or vector-valued, with continued workability and stricter endpoint exactness as a nested two-level case. In a driven delayed-consensus network, numerical response amplitudes and phases agree with analytic coherent-mode predictions; a polar flock illustrates nonlinear steady-state separation of alignment and collective order. AI examples comprise an endpoint-informed typed-evidence graph calculation, replay of model records, and fresh readout calls following imposed propagation through an externally constructed graph. Fresh calls resolve candidate-support changes in some directions; only a minority pass the finite-step linearity check, and the all-direction response criterion fails. In a retrospective offline example with previously identified defects, reference calculations replace selected program outputs. Replacing only the selected output or both readouts gives correct outcomes for both archived cases; selective replacement yields fewer correct outcomes on constructed controls. ANM provides an auditable response-measurement protocol with realization-specific states and response functions. These measurements leave causal attribution and retained-state mediation unresolved. Joint state formation and use by multiple live agents lie outside their scope.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
local response theory, dynamical systems, delayed interactions, retained-state representations, perturbation analysis, distributed AI workflows, model evaluation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_eQY4OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose a framework called Active Neural Matter for physical systems and distributed AI workflows. The authors list contributions such as the capability of separating propagation from readout sensitivity. It is not very clear how this is a contribution the field will be interested in.

Critical strengths

na

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is with the comprehensibility of the manuscript. Terms are introduced without proper justification or motivation (such as retained state), and the paper is hard to follow. It is not clear what the problem setting is, nor do the contributions seem like genuine contributions to the field.

Questions for authors

I have no questions that could materially affect my judgement.

Reviewer_ej9KOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Active Neural Matter (ANM), a framework for separately measuring source perturbations, candidate retained states, and endpoint readouts over a finite observation window. In the forward direction, it separates propagation from readout sensitivity. In the inverse direction, it examines which information a representation must preserve for specified sources, readouts, and observation windows. The theoretical treatment uses the first-order factorization criterion

KO,T=HTKz,T⟺ker⁡Kz,T⊆ker⁡KO,T,K_{O,T}=H_TK_{z,T} \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \ker K_{z,T}\subseteq\ker K_{O,T},

and distinguishes exact state matching, approximate matching, and differential response tests. It also introduces nested readouts for continued workability and a stricter exactness criterion. The empirical studies include comparisons with analytic predictions for delayed consensus, distinct order measures in a polar flock, model readouts following propagation through an externally constructed graph, replacement of program outputs, request–return joins in a delayed-tool workflow, and a development study of evidence selection. These studies provide calibration results, counterexamples to candidate representations, and examples of local correction. They do not establish general retained-state sufficiency or the effectiveness of representation refinement and intervention selection on unseen tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework connects conclusions about representations to explicit measurement conditions. The paper distinguishes cases in which identical candidate states yield different outputs, approximate matches violate sensitivity-plus-error bounds, and the experimental design provides no informative comparison. It also addresses delayed histories, the vacuity of the kernel test under full column rank, and the repetitions required for stochastic readouts. These distinctions help prevent overinterpreting a workflow graph, or simultaneous changes in inputs and outputs, as evidence of state sufficiency. They provide concrete constraints on experimental interpretation rather than merely a shared vocabulary. (pp. 3–4, 23–25)
  2. The paper transparently reports the roles of both positive and negative evidence. For delayed consensus, the paper reports agreement with analytic predictions across 13 delays and 100 seeds per delay, with relative amplitude error at most 2.51×10−32.51\times10^{-3} and absolute phase error at most 0.74∘0.74^\circ. The AI studies explicitly retain failures of the linearity criterion, the unmet calibration threshold, incomplete repairs, and the absence of improvement from the primary intervention-selection policy. The careful separation of constructed examples, calibration, model measurements, and diagnostic outcomes is scientifically valuable. (pp. 32, 44–47, 52–56)
Critical weaknesses
  1. The substantive advance obtained by integrating existing concepts is not sufficiently clear. Equations (1)–(2) follow from first-order variations of state transitions and the chain rule, while Equation (3) is a linear-map factorization condition. The nested readouts and their basic boundary relations follow from their definitions and additional assumptions. The authors themselves position the contribution as a specification of measurements and tests rather than a new principle of abstraction. (pp. 3–4, 15, 28–31) Integrating established principles can be valuable. However, it remains unclear whether this integration provides a new experimental design, additional identifiability, an actionable representation-refinement procedure, or a previously overlooked empirical finding. Beyond showing that physical systems and AI workflows can be described using the same formal structure, the paper needs a more decisive demonstration of how this formalization changes a scientific or methodological decision. This is a central concern regarding the significance of the contribution for ICLR.
  2. Independent validation of the central use case—testing and refining representations—is insufficient. The examples in which identical worksheets yield different outputs, or a raw sensor is changed while the graph is held fixed, are valid counterexamples to the proposed representations. However, the paper does not sufficiently demonstrate the full process of detecting a representational deficiency, refining the representation, and validating that refinement on comparisons not used to construct it. In the fresh-model readout experiment, endpoint responses are detected in 9 of 12 directions, but only 2 directions pass the slope-agreement check when the perturbation step is halved. The state-contrast matrix also has full column rank, so this experiment provides no nontrivial state-null directions. It is a useful demonstration of response measurement, but weak evidence for an informative assessment of representation sufficiency. (pp. 7, 35–36) The delayed-tool join restores the required response on one known failure case. However, calibration achieved 21/24 correct outputs, below the prespecified 22/24 threshold, and the subsequent results are exploratory tests on the same tasks. Ordinary diagnosis selects the same intervention, and a fixed join also succeeds. (pp. 52–54) In the prospective program study with fixed rules, complete repair succeeds on 0/2 faulty programs. In the 89-task development study, the primary response-based policy has the same accuracy as direct reading, 74.72%, while increasing the mean number of calls from 1.00 to 7.56. (pp. 39, 55) Reporting these negative results is a strength. Nevertheless, the results do not provide sufficient validation of the framework’s central role in guiding representation testing and refinement to support acceptance.
Questions for authors
  1. Clarification of the contribution What is the single most important additional result obtained by integrating response analysis, observability, and diagnosis within ANM? Is it a new mathematical guarantee, an operational testing procedure, an improvement in experimental design, or a new empirical finding? Explaining the difference from the closest existing approach under the same access conditions and information would directly affect my assessment of the contribution.
  2. Representation refinement and its validation Do any of the reported results demonstrate detecting a deficiency in a candidate representation, refining that representation while keeping the consumer and interface fixed, and validating the refinement on source directions or histories not used to construct it? If so, please specify the state-matching error, the permitted endpoint difference, any required sensitivity bound, the unit of repetition, and the positive control. I would like to distinguish improved presentation on a known case from validation of a revised retained representation. These questions seek clarification of existing claims and evidence. For a future revision, completing the sequence “detect a deficiency → refine the representation → validate on unused comparisons” within one workflow would address the main concern more directly than adding many heterogeneous examples.
Reviewer_YEw8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

It's hard to summarize this one as I do not really understand the point of it. The core idea seems to be something like:

  • A system receives some inputs.
  • It stores or propagates information about those inputs.
  • It produces an output.
  • To determine whether the stored representation is sufficient, check whether two inputs that produce the same stored state can nevertheless produce different outputs.
  • If they can, the representation is missing relevant information.

Which is fine but not novel or revelatory, and then the paper cloaks this with a bunch of generic dynamical systems theory. Moreover, the relation to AI systems specifically does not appear obvious since the framework is so general. It is unclear to me what specific hypothesis that the paper is trying to test or novel contribution it is making.

Critical strengths

Unclear honestly

Critical weaknesses

Unclear what nontrivial insight, empirical fact, or theoretical derivation there is in here.

Questions for authors

What is one non-obvious, falsifiable prediction or practically useful conclusion that follows from ANM, that we could not have reached just as easily using existing concepts—and where is the experiment that demonstrates it?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.