- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies sparse Bayesian multiple testing using generalized relative belief procedures. It extends ABOS results from specific priors to a broad scale family. The family includes light-tailed, heavy-tailed, symmetric, and asymmetric priors. A unified threshold analysis explains why these priors can achieve ABOS under suitable scaling. The paper also establishes empirical Bayes guarantees when sparsity is unknown. The results cover univariate and fixed-dimensional multivariate normal means models under weighted losses.
Critical strengths
A key strength is the unified ABOS theory for a broad prior family. The threshold expansion shows that, under appropriate scaling, prior shape enters only through , explaining why heavy tails are unnecessary. This elevates earlier examples into a general principle, with uniform control over directions in the multivariate setting further supporting acceptance.
Critical weaknesses
1.The mathematical arguments are clearly organized, but the overall narrative could be more focused. The limited intuitive explanation of the underlying mechanism makes the development harder to follow, and the presentation becomes repetitive across settings. In particular, ABOS is formally defined four times (Definitions 3.3, 3.15, 4.4, and 4.12). A unified definition, with the corresponding oracle benchmark specified for each setting, would make the exposition more concise.
2.The title and introduction emphasize that simple priors can achieve ABOS, but this central observation was already established by Liang et al. (2026) for normal and uniform priors. Although the paper acknowledges this prior work, its framing does not sufficiently distinguish the present contribution. The authors should foreground the generality of the prior family and the new empirical Bayes guarantees, and explain more clearly what these results establish beyond the earlier examples.
Questions for authors
1.Which results require substantially new arguments beyond Liang et al. (2026)? Please highlight the main technical challenges introduced by the general prior family and the multivariate empirical Bayes procedure.
2.Could you explain more intuitively why the prior shape enters the asymptotic threshold only through (h(0)), and how the prescribed scale choices make this approximation valid?