- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces SAT-LLM, a conversion-aware fine-tuning framework for low-latency deployment of spiking large language models. The method combines Hadamard rotation, local spiking neuron behavior, and common-range clipping to adapt ANN fine-tuning to subsequent SNN conversion without interlayer temporal propagation. The authors provide a conditional convergence analysis and demonstrate on Qwen3 and Llama3 models that the method mitigates performance degradation associated with ANN-to-SNN conversion under limited timesteps.
Critical strengths
-
The work addresses the mismatch between ANN optimization and spiking deployment by incorporating adaptation to conversion into the fine-tuning stage.
-
The framework supports two conversion-aware fine-tuning modes and three deployment neuron types, demonstrating the potential for cross-neuron transfer across multiple models and tasks.
Critical weaknesses
-
The overall performance degradation arises both during conversion-aware fine-tuning and during subsequent SNN conversion and evaluation. Conversion-aware fine-tuning itself introduces substantial degradation. Even before conversion, the model performs approximately 10 percentage points below the original ANN baseline, substantially limiting the method’s attainable performance.
-
Tables 1–3 primarily compare the authors’ own Vanilla, Unaware, Phase-aware, and GIF-aware configurations, without direct quantitative comparisons against existing conversion methods discussed in the related work.
-
The paper does not evaluate performance across different timestep budgets.
-
The paper does not provide energy consumption estimates.
-
The paper lacks a component-wise ablation that disentangles the contributions of Hadamard rotation and conversion-aware fine-tuning to the overall performance.
-
No accompanying code is provided, increasing the burden of reproducing the results.
-
The convergence guarantee relies on the Polyak–Łojasiewicz condition, local smoothness, bounded downstream sensitivity, and bounded surrogate-gradient bias. However, the paper neither validates these assumptions nor estimates the relevant constants or the magnitude of the resulting error bound.
Questions for authors
-
Why is MTN-aware fine-tuning not considered, whereas GIF-aware and Phase-aware fine-tuning are supported?
-
The theoretical analysis bounds the discrepancy between the smooth proxy network and the network with locally realized spiking neurons. However, it does not bound the discrepancy between the original Hadamard-rotated ANN and the smooth proxy network, or between the locally realized spiking network and the fully temporal SNN used for deployment. How are these two additional sources of error characterized and controlled?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer odSC-Part 2
Response to Weaknesses 5
We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. To disentangle the contributions of Hadamard rotation and conversion-aware fine-tuning, we conducted additional 2×2 factorial ablation experiments on Qwen3-1.7B and Llama3-8B, independently enabling or disabling Hadamard rotation and Phase-aware/GIF-aware fine-tuning. Specifically, we introduced two additional configurations, Phase-aware w/o Rotation and GIF-aware w/o Rotation, and compared them against the existing Vanilla, Unaware, Phase-aware, and GIF-aware configurations.
The results are summarized below.
| Model | Training Mode | Fine-tuned ANN | Phase SNN | GIF SNN | MTN SNN |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-1.7B | Vanilla | 0.2411 | 0.0252 | 0.0259 | 0.0163 |
| Unaware | 0.2447 | 0.0983 | 0.0572 | 0.0401 | |
| Phase-aware w/o Rotation | 0.0931 | 0.0964 | 0.0266 | 0.0733 | |
| Phase-aware | 0.2095 | 0.2076 | 0.1383 | 0.1746 | |
| GIF-aware w/o Rotation | 0.1743 | 0.1234 | 0.0333 | 0.0606 | |
| GIF-aware | 0.2177 | 0.2229 | 0.2184 | 0.2118 | |
| Llama3-8B | Vanilla | 0.5851 | 0.4024 | 0.3705 | 0.4098 |
| Unaware | 0.5907 | 0.4393 | 0.3636 | 0.4075 | |
| Phase-aware w/o Rotation | 0.3850 | 0.3834 | 0.3861 | 0.3994 | |
| Phase-aware | 0.4998 | 0.4908 | 0.3698 | 0.4388 | |
| GIF-aware w/o Rotation | 0.4294 | 0.4417 | 0.4082 | 0.4502 | |
| GIF-aware | 0.4833 | 0.4881 | 0.4781 | 0.4867 |
Results are reported using average ROUGE scores for Qwen3-1.7B and average downstream benchmark accuracy for Llama3-8B.
The results provide three key observations:
1. Independent contribution of Hadamard rotation. Comparing Vanilla with Unaware shows that rotation alone substantially improves SNN performance on Qwen3-1.7B, while its benefits are more limited and neuron-dependent on Llama3-8B.
2. Independent contribution of conversion-aware fine-tuning. Even without rotation, conversion-aware fine-tuning can improve SNN performance, particularly for GIF-aware training, while Phase-aware training shows less consistent gains.
3. Complementary effects of rotation and conversion-aware fine-tuning. Combining both components generally yields better performance. Notably, rotation improves all three SNN variants under GIF-aware training across both models, demonstrating their complementary benefits.
These results demonstrate that conversion-aware fine-tuning contributes beyond Hadamard rotation alone, while their combination generally provides stronger and more reliable SNN performance.
Response to Weaknesses 6
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance of reproducibility. We have uploaded the implementation code as Supplementary Material through the Rebuttal Revision. If the paper is accepted, we will also publicly release the code on GitHub to facilitate reproducibility and further research.
Response to Weaknesses 7
We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. We acknowledge that the assumptions are relatively strong. However, these are standard technical assumptions widely adopted in theoretical analyses of non-convex optimization and LLM fine-tuning to establish conditional convergence guarantees.
For example, MeZO uses smoothness for its per-step descent analysis and further assumes the PL inequality and bounded gradient covariance to establish global convergence [1]. SubZero similarly analyzes LLM fine-tuning under a lower-bounded, non-convex -smooth objective [2]. DPZero assumes Lipschitz sample losses and a smooth average loss, and additionally provides convergence guarantees under the PL condition [3]. Moreover, Liu et al. [4] provide structural support for PL-type geometry, showing that a local PL condition holds with high probability over a neighborhood in sufficiently overparameterized regimes and using this perspective to analyze LLM adaptation.
Our theoretical contribution is not to establish that these assumptions universally hold, but to characterize how Phase/GIF surrogate approximation errors affect the convergence behavior of conversion-aware fine-tuning under explicitly stated conditions. Specifically, Lemmas 5.1–5.2 quantify the local approximation errors, while Theorems 5.3–5.4 connect these errors to the global objective gap and convergence bound.
[1] Malladi, Sadhika, et al. "Fine-tuning language models with just forward passes." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 36 (2023): 53038-53075.
[2] Yu, Ziming, et al. "Zeroth-order fine-tuning of llms in random subspaces." arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.08989 (2024).
[3] Zhang, Liang, et al. "Dpzero: Private fine-tuning of language models without backpropagation." arXiv preprint arXiv:2310.09639 (2023).
[4] Liu, Xu-Hui, et al. "On the optimization landscape of low rank adaptation methods for large language models." The Thirteenth International Conference on Learning Representations. 2025.
Response to Reviewer odSC-Part 3
Response to Question 1
The key distinction lies in the temporal dependencies of different spiking neurons and whether their dynamics can be locally realized during ANN fine-tuning. Specifically:
-
Phase/GIF Support Local Realization. Phase neurons employ preload-and-discharge dynamics, allowing their temporal behavior to be unfolded and aggregated locally from a static activation. GIF neurons admit an equivalent static quantization representation. Thus, both can be incorporated into ANN fine-tuning without propagating temporal signals across layers.
-
MTN Requires Interlayer Temporal Inputs. Unlike Phase/GIF, MTN employs charge-and-fire dynamics, where the membrane potential depends on both the previous membrane state and the current temporal input:
Therefore, MTN requires timestep-wise inputs from upstream operators and cannot be directly realized using the same site-local static formulation as Phase/GIF.
-
Compatibility with SAT-LLM. A central design principle of SAT-LLM is to maintain static interlayer propagation during ANN fine-tuning, avoiding the computational overhead of full-temporal execution. Supporting MTN-aware fine-tuning would require introducing interlayer temporal propagation and substantially increasing training complexity. Therefore, MTN is supported during full-temporal SNN deployment rather than conversion-aware ANN fine-tuning.
Thus, the exclusion of MTN-aware fine-tuning stems from its incompatibility with the current fine-tuning framework, rather than an omission of MTN neuronal dynamics.
Response to Question 2
We would like to clarify that these two discrepancies play different roles in SAT-LLM and should be distinguished from the hard-to-proxy approximation analyzed in Section 5.
1. Discrepancy between the original Hadamard-rotated ANN and the smooth proxy network.
Our convergence analysis focuses on conversion-aware fine-tuning, where the actual forward pass employs locally realized spiking neurons. Since the spiking operations are non-differentiable, we introduce a smooth proxy network to analyze the optimization behavior under surrogate gradients. Therefore, bounding the discrepancy between the locally realized spiking network and its smooth proxy is essential to establishing the conditional convergence guarantee.
In contrast, the original Hadamard-rotated ANN serves as the initialization for conversion-aware fine-tuning and corresponds to the spiking-unaware baseline (Unaware). It is inherently differentiable and does not require a smooth proxy. Thus, its discrepancy from the smooth proxy network is not part of the hard-to-proxy approximation relationship considered in our theoretical analysis.
2. Discrepancy between the locally realized spiking network and the fully temporal SNN.
As detailed in Appendix C, the fully temporal SNN employs specially designed LLM temporal operations that preserve the accumulated outputs of their corresponding static operations. Specifically, linear operations exploit linearity, attention and MLP multiplications use exact algebraic decompositions, and Softmax, RMSNorm, and SiLU are implemented through accumulated inputs and temporal output differencing.
Under exact arithmetic and consistent initialization, the sum of the temporal outputs is mathematically identical to the corresponding static operator output. Therefore, these temporal operator realizations do not introduce additional theoretical approximation errors. In practical implementations, minor numerical discrepancies may arise from finite floating-point precision, accumulation order, and rounding.
In summary, our theoretical analysis focuses on the surrogate approximation error that directly affects conversion-aware optimization, while the temporal operations in Appendix C preserve mathematical equivalence rather than introducing an additional source of approximation error.
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. These additions address several of my questions. However, my main concerns regarding practical value, accuracy degradation, and novelty remain unresolved, and I will maintain my original score.
The practical benefit remains insufficiently established without an energy estimate. My concern does not require a new hardware architecture or direct measurements on dedicated neuromorphic hardware. Even without such hardware, an assumption-explicit energy estimate would help assess whether the accuracy loss is justified by a meaningful deployment benefit.
The substantial accuracy degradation during conversion-aware fine-tuning remains a central limitation. Nevertheless, describing the degradation as a deliberate trade-off does not establish that its magnitude is necessary or adequately mitigated. In the authors’ Llama3-8B example, ANN accuracy decreases from 0.5907 to 0.4833 remaining a substantial gap to the ANN baseline.
The additional ablations clarify effectiveness more than novelty. They support the contributions of both Hadamard rotation and conversion-aware fine-tuning, as well as the benefits of combining them. However, this does not by itself resolve the concern, also raised by Reviewer 71mB, that the framework largely integrates existing techniques. Hadamard rotation is adopted from prior ANN work, and incorporating deployment constraints into fine-tuning is an established general strategy. The remaining question is what methodological advance the proposed local spiking formulation and training procedure provide beyond this combination.
Overall, I acknowledge the improvements made during the rebuttal, but the evidence remains insufficient to resolve these concerns. I therefore maintain my original rating.
Response to Reviewer odSC-Part 1
We acknowledge that conversion-aware fine-tuning introduces some degradation in ANN performance. However, the primary objective of SAT-LLM is to improve the performance of the final deployed SNN, rather than maximize the accuracy of the fine-tuned ANN. Specifically:
Please refer to our response to Reviewer 71mB, Question 5, where we clarify the distinction between conversion-aware fine-tuning and existing SNN conversion methods, and describe our additional comparative experiments using an existing conversion method.
We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. To investigate the impact of different timestep budgets, we conducted additional experiments on Qwen3-1.7B (Phase-aware) and Llama3-8B (Phase-aware), evaluating three configurations: Phase T = 3, 4, 5, with the corresponding MTN (T, K) = (3, 5), (4, 6), (5, 7). The configuration with T = 4 corresponds to the default setting used in our original experiments.
The results are summarized below.
Results are reported using average ROUGE scores for Qwen3-1.7B and average downstream benchmark accuracy for Llama3-8B.
The results show that increasing the timestep budget generally improves Phase and MTN SNN performance, while GIF SNN performance exhibits relatively limited and non-monotonic changes. However, larger timestep budgets also require more temporal computation, introducing a trade-off between performance and deployment latency. Since our work targets low-latency spiking deployment, we adopt Phase T = 4 and MTN (T, K) = (4, 6) as a practical balance between performance and temporal computation cost.
We thank the reviewer for this valuable comment. We would like to clarify that the primary contribution of SAT-LLM lies in conversion-aware fine-tuning, which aims to improve the performance of converted SNNs under limited timestep budgets, rather than proposing a new energy-efficient hardware architecture.
We acknowledge that energy consumption is an important consideration for practical SNN deployment. However, dedicated neuromorphic chips for deploying billion-parameter spiking LLMs are not yet available, making direct hardware-level energy measurements infeasible at present. We recognize this limitation and will include energy evaluation as an important direction for future work.
Specifically, we plan to adopt a component-wise hardware-level energy evaluation framework, accounting for computation (MAC/AC), memory accesses (DRAM/SRAM), communication, neuron-state updates, control overhead, and static energy. We will also consider different weight-residency conditions to assess the impact of memory movement. When suitable neuromorphic hardware becomes available, we will conduct actual energy measurements to evaluate the practical energy efficiency of SAT-LLM.