acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

When Predictions Become Inputs: Hidden Feedback Errors in Latent World Models

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In autoregressive latent world models, a prediction describes a task state and becomes input to the next prediction. We show that these roles can diverge: changing feedback improves future prediction while its current nonlinear task readout stays fixed. Our oracle diagnostic guides a predicted token toward its observed encoding, preserving the readout, original ReLU activation region, earlier history and future actions. Free rollout tests usefulness; norm-matched donor guidance tests source sensitivity. Across Transformer and GRU PushT models, stronger readouts and matched coordinate training retain terminal block-position MSE reductions of 9.3% and 8.8% for coordinate-teacher and physical-label objectives. On 256 fresh recipients, corrections preserving two pose readouts retain reductions of 6.4% and 6.7% under a reserved evaluator. Benefits also survive joint pose and qualified velocity constraints. Recursive Transformer training lowers free- rollout MSE by 23.1% and 30.9% under the preserved readout. Prospective tests do not confirm incremental prediction of training response or improved action selection; native DINO-WM PushT and PointMaze do not confirm correction over free rollout. These findings establish feedback insufficiency relative to specified task measurements and separate it from diagnostic value and decision quality.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Latent World Models, Predictive Representations, Recursive Prediction, Representation Learning, Robot Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_m3hJOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies whether a latent prediction can be adequate for a specified current-state readout yet inadequate as input to future prediction. It introduces an oracle intervention that moves a predicted token toward its observed encoding while preserving selected nonlinear readouts and their ReLU activation regions. Matched donor interventions control displacement magnitude. PushT experiments find useful corrections under multiple pose and velocity constraints, including evaluation with a reserved readout. Recursive training improves rollout prediction, while separate experiments do not establish benefits for native-model correction, prediction of training response, or action selection.

Critical strengths
  • The intervention is carefully controlled: nonlinear readout preservation, fixed actions and history, matched displacement norms, donor comparisons, and reserved evaluation collectively support the claim that useful feedback differences can remain invisible to specified readouts.
  • The study distinguishes prediction improvement from diagnostic and decision utility, reporting unresolved results alongside positive findings. The recipient-level statistical analysis and candidate-cost decomposition make this distinction informative and credible.
Critical weaknesses
  • The interpretation remains strongly measurement-dependent. Preserving the original pose readout still changes the independent evaluator's insertion-time pose estimate by approximately 30 pixels RMS (Section 4.1). Additional constraints strengthen the result, but do not establish how much benefit reflects residual pose information missed by the constrained readouts.
  • External and practical significance remains limited: neither native DINO-WM task confirms improvement over free rollout, and the prospective diagnosis and action-selection tests remain unresolved. Thus, the strongest evidence supports a controlled phenomenon in the study-trained models rather than an established tool for improving deployed world models.
Questions for authors
  1. In the fresh gA+gC-constrained experiment, what are the insertion-time changes in decoded pose and pose error under reserved evaluator gD? Does endpoint improvement remain substantial among recipients with negligible gD pose changes? This would clarify how much of the benefit may still reflect residual pose correction.

  2. Beyond qualification on observed encodings, how accurate are the pose and velocity readouts on predicted and corrected latent states? Can you show whether endpoint improvements persist where the reserved evaluator is reliable, since readout preservation is harder to interpret when the readout extrapolates poorly?

  3. How sensitive are the gains to world-model training pools, readout refits, and donor resampling? The reported recipient bootstrap conditions on fitted models and donor assignments; effects by training pool and uncertainty across these additional sources would clarify the robustness of the main and reserved-evaluator results.

  4. In the native PushT and PointMaze experiments, how does a full observed-encoding reset compare with free rollout and the constrained correction, with paired uncertainty? If even the full reset offers little improvement, the null results may reflect limited correctable error rather than failure of the constrained intervention.

Reviewer_AHiiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper discusses the effect of single-step prediction error on long-horizon trajectory prediction in world models. To aid their analysis they project the prediction error (or residual) to find a value “d” that is the minimal residual one can add to the predicted state to ensure the read-out function (or decoder) outputs the correct robot state. However, “d” can not be computed online and only serves as a tool for interpreting/characterizing model performance.

Critical strengths

I believe the projection problem described in Eq. 2 appears to be an interesting problem. Specifically, the authors use the solution “d* = Solution of Eq. 2” to correct the prediction after 5 world models steps. They then measure the position error after 25 steps to determine if the error with the intervention at step 5 was better than the performance without any intervention. They then validate this empirically by demonstrating a statistically significant reduction in the prediction error using the intervention.

Critical weaknesses
  • While the authors are able to support their analysis (a strength of the paper listed above), their conclusion seems to lack novelty. It is a well established fact in prior literature that prediction errors aggregate in autoregressive models and thus reducing their errors via a correction like “d” would reduce the error.
    • Additionally, “d” can only be computed post-hoc, which means it can not be used as a feedback component during execution. This further limits the scope of the paper.
    • The applicability of this analysis also seems quite limited. The paper starts off by constructing two latent values that correspond to the same real-world state. However, this seems like an issue unlikely to be encountered in practice, where we constantly re-encode the current state to select our next action.
    • The readout function, g, could also be quite sensitive to its input. Thus, a small error in the latent space could become a large readout error. There is limited analysis on the quality of “g” and could be a confounding artifact in the authors’ analysis.
  • Importantly, the manuscript is not written in a way that is human friendly for reading. There are a lot of instances in the manuscript where the authors make a statement, but fail to explain it, thereby providing a limited scope into the intuition behind their analysis.
Questions for authors

Clarifications on the weaknesses discussed above would be helpful.

Reviewer_x5w6OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates hidden feedback errors in autoregressive latent world models, where two latent representations with identical task-state readouts can lead to different future predictions. The authors propose an oracle-guided diagnostic that modifies latent tokens while preserving their decoded task states. Experiments primarily on PushT using Transformer and GRU predictors show that these interventions can reduce long-horizon prediction errors. However, the improvements do not consistently transfer to native DINO-WM models or downstream action selection.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper raises an interesting question about whether accurate task-state predictions are sufficient for reliable recursive world-model rollouts.
  2. The authors conduct extensive controlled experiments, including different architectures, readout constraints, and training objectives.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed diagnostic relies on oracle information from future observations, which is unavailable during actual deployment. While the experiments demonstrate that modifying latent feedback can improve prediction, the paper does not provide a practical method to identify or correct these errors online. More importantly, the authors acknowledge that the proposed diagnostic does not demonstrate improvements in downstream action selection.
  2. Most experiments are conducted on PushT with relatively simple dynamics. The results on native DINO-WM PushT and PointMaze do not confirm improvements over free rollout, raising concerns about whether the findings generalize to more realistic world models. The paper would benefit from experiments on more challenging robotic manipulation tasks or larger-scale visual world models.
  3. The paper is unnecessarily complicated and difficult to follow. The writing introduces numerous experimental conditions, constraints, and statistical comparisons without clearly explaining their practical significance. The figures are also overly stylized and difficult to interpret, making it challenging to understand the main findings. Despite the extensive experiments, the paper lacks a clear takeaway regarding how the proposed analysis could improve existing world models.
  4. The observation that latent prediction errors can accumulate and affect future predictions is closely related to established issues in autoregressive modeling and representation learning. Although the proposed controlled intervention provides a different perspective, it is unclear whether the findings lead to fundamentally new insights or actionable improvements beyond existing approaches to mitigating error accumulation.
Questions for authors
  1. Since the proposed diagnostic requires access to ground-truth future observations, how could it be applied to improve world models during actual deployment?
  2. The experiments on native DINO-WM models do not confirm the improvements observed in the controlled PushT experiments. What explains this discrepancy, and how generalizable are the conclusions?
  3. What is the practical significance of identifying hidden feedback errors if the proposed diagnostic does not improve downstream planning or action selection?
  4. How does the proposed analysis differ fundamentally from existing studies of latent representation errors, exposure bias, and error accumulation in autoregressive world models?
  5. Could the authors simplify the experimental presentation and provide more intuitive visualizations or qualitative examples demonstrating the hidden feedback errors and their effects on predicted trajectories?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.