- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This article studies the correlation accuracy and computational energy consumption in multi-target tracking. Based on the CAMELTrack correlation framework, a three value sparse activation and prediction driven correlation mechanism is introduced to reduce computational overhead and maintain cross frame identity continuity. The author conducted experiments on MOT17, DanceTrack, and SportsMOT, compared them with the self constructed LIF-SNN baseline and existing full precision methods, and reported tracking performance, activation sparsity rate, and energy consumption. The current manuscript still lacks sufficient explanation on the specific implementation of SNN baseline configuration, predictive correlation mechanism, and energy consumption statistical caliber. Some theoretical derivations and experimental tables also have consistency issues that need clarification or correction. Supplementing with baseline conditions, independent module ablation, and original evaluation results will help to more accurately assess the contributions of each design and the applicability of the conclusions.
Critical strengths
-
This method generates sparse features in one forward propagation, reducing the dependence on multi time step pulse accumulation, and is suitable for frame by frame online tracking tasks.
-
According to the results reported in the article, compared with SNNs with the same architecture, this method improves HOTA by approximately 29.3, 22.5, and 19.8 percentage points on the three datasets, respectively, while also having lower energy consumption.
-
Triple activation uses \ (\ {-1,0,+1 } ) to represent features, while introducing zero values to reduce computation and preserving the positive and negative information of the features.
-
The association process combines historical features and current observations to enable the model to still utilize existing identity information for subsequent matching in the event of occlusion or missed detections.
Critical weaknesses
1.The author mentioned in the abstract that the intra frame temporal dynamics of SNN do not match the transient spatial discrimination and continuous state estimation required by MOT. But I think the latter refers to inter frame dynamics, and if the intra frame autoregression speed of SNN is fast enough, this does not constitute a problem. How does the author view this.
2.I am skeptical about the author's statement in the abstract that time information is integrated into the characteristic information of internal pulses, as the actual representation of pulse information is still based on pulse firing rate.
3.There are very obvious prompt word injections at the beginning of each paragraph in the Introduction (traces of automatic compilation using plugin LaTeX, possibly due to warnings and certain errors), indicating that this article may have been completely generated by AI or directly polished by AI, which is completely inconsistent with ICLR rules. I cannot understand why such an article can enter the review process.
4.In the Introduction of this article, it is mentioned that "when an object is occluded, its events stop, the potential leaks away, eliminating the very features needed to re identify the object upon reappearance". For robustness reasons, I believe this is a balanced process. However, this article lacks quantitative experiments to demonstrate that in MOT tasks or on selected datasets, this has a negative impact on the performance of SNN, rather than a positive impact on the robustness improvement of SNN networks caused by membrane potential attenuation factors.
5.In my opinion, the author's several introductions are completely general and do not mention any practical issues. However, considering that this is generated by AI, I think this can be understood.
6.Regarding the four contributions proposed by the author, the first one I believe lacks any insightful analysis, visualization, or other contributing problem analysis; The second one is not proposed in this article, and I can confirm that there have been numerous studies on Ternary Spike [1] [2]. For innovation point 3, many works that have been proposed to introduce MAMBA have done so, and there are also many works in single object tracking that can be summarized without loss by this sentence, such as SeqTrack [3], AQATrack [4], and ARTrack [5] series of works. As of the Introduction, I cannot get any actual design of this article, which I think is unreasonable.
7.The method proposed in this article does not seem to significantly improve the performance of the model, as shown in Table 1. In terms of the four indicators of DetA, IDF1, and MOTA, the method proposed in this article is far inferior to the older work MOTIP. In Table 2, the method proposed in this article did not show any performance improvement in various indicators. In addition, there were some formatting issues in Tables 1 and 2, such as the need to retain decimals with the same number of digits.
8.On DanceTrack, ASPC’s HOTA score of 61.24 is lower than both MOTIP’s 67.5 and DiffMOT’s 62.3, yet the text states that it “trails only MOTIP.” The conclusion that ASPC “matches or surpasses the strongest full-precision methods across all three datasets” should also be qualified.
[1]Guo Y, Chen Y, Liu X, et al. Ternary spike: Learning ternary spikes for spiking neural networks[C]//Proceedings of the AAAI conference on artificial intelligence. 2024, 38(11): 12244-12252. [2]Wang S, Zhang D, Belatreche A, et al. Ternary spike-based neuromorphic signal processing system[J]. Neural Networks, 2025, 187: 107333. [3]Chen X, Peng H, Wang D, et al. Seqtrack: Sequence to sequence learning for visual object tracking[C]//2023 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2023: 14572-14581. [4]Xie J, Zhong B, Mo Z, et al. Autoregressive queries for adaptive tracking with spatio-temporal transformers[C]//2024 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2024: 19300-19309. [5]Wei X, Bai Y, Zheng Y, et al. Autoregressive visual tracking[C]//2023 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2023: 9697-9706.
Questions for authors
-
Why is there a necessary conflict between the intra frame time step of SNN and the cross frame state estimation of MOT? What pulse encoding is used in the text, and how does time information specifically participate in the expression of identity features?
-
Is there any quantitative experiment indicating that membrane potential attenuation can impair identity recovery after occlusion? Can the impact on information retention and noise suppression be distinguished by adjusting the leakage coefficient and occlusion duration?
-
What is the specific innovation of this article compared to existing methods for representing ternary pulses and modeling historical states? Can the contributions of each design be demonstrated through independent ablation?
-
Has the SNN baseline undergone independent tuning? Can the time steps, leakage coefficient, threshold, and training configuration be made public, and compared for accuracy, latency, and energy consumption after reasonable optimization?
-
After Lemma 1 fixes two norms\ Why is it still described as a minimization problem when H (m) is already a constant? How does the author explain the issue that the equal amplitude positive component corresponds to the maximum value, and that the threshold \ (E ) only represents the gradient sign boundary?
-
According to the standard definition of HOTA, multiple groups of HOTA in the SportsMOT table have exceeded the upper limits given by the corresponding DetA and AssA. What is the reason for this? Can you provide the original evaluation output and verify the data sources and transcription accuracy of baselines such as MOTIP?
-
Why does the main text say that ASPC's HOTA on DanceTrack is "only behind MOTIP" when it is lower than both MOTIP and DiffMOT? Are the existing results sufficient to support the conclusion of 'matching or surpassing the strongest full precision method on three datasets'?
7 comments
Baseline Verification, Component Ablation, and AI-Use Clarification
1.AI assistance was used solely for language polishing and figure-caption drafting, as stated in the AI-use statement. The methods, derivations, experiments, code, and all reported data are the authors’ own work. The raw energy logs and TrackEval outputs will be provided in the supplementary material. In the revised manuscript, we will rewrite formulaic passages in our own words, shorten long sentences, unify terminology, and expand the per-section AI-use statement. We would be happy to provide the code and measurement logs to the AC for verification.
2.We agree that cross-paper differences in detectors and protocols must be made explicit. To verify the quoted numbers, we reproduced MOTIP under our own pipeline; the reproduced values are close to those reported in the original paper. In the revision, every quoted number will be labeled with its corresponding detector and data split, and the reproduction results will be included in the supplementary material.
3.We agree that PAC is a main contribution and must be isolated. We completed the component ablation on DanceTrack; the original CAMELTrack baseline corresponds to the fixed-threshold configuration without ternary gating. The two new runs isolate PAC and TSAN respectively: Component ablation on the DanceTrack validation split (25 sequences, 225,148 GT boxes), with identical detections, splits and evaluation script. The two component runs use the same state cache and were trained separately; the full ASPC row is the main-table run, included for reference. Configuration HOTA↑ AssA↑ DetA↑ MOTA↑ IDF1↑ TSAN-only 61.69 47.88 79.84 88.89 62.23 PAC-only 62.31 52.29 74.91 82.12 65.46 Full ASPC 61.24 47.31 79.63 87.09 62.19
TSAN-only reaches HOTA 61.69 / MOTA 88.89 / IDF1 62.23 at the ternary-activation cost reported in Table 4. PAC-only yields the strongest association-side metrics: AssA 52.29 (+4.41 over TSAN-only), IDF1 65.46 (+3.23), and 500 identity switches versus 3270 for TSAN-only (6.5× fewer), which is the identity-continuity benefit PAC is designed to provide. TSAN-only remains stronger on detection-side metrics (DetA 79.84 vs 74.91, MOTA 88.89 vs 82.12). The two modules act on different failure axes: TSAN improves the representational/computational side, PAC improves association and identity preservation.
4.We have unified all energy measurements to a CPU-measured protocol, with the idle baseline subtracted, and our model and all compared methods are measured under the same protocol. The per-frame energy values under this unified protocol will be provided later in the main text, and the relevant tables will be updated accordingly.
Flag For Ethics Review
Dear Reviewer, could you please briefly clarify the ethical concern that led you to flag the paper for ethics review?
Dear authors, the AC has reminded us reviewers to respond to your rebuttal. If there is anything you would like to clarify or discuss, please leave a comment here, and I will respond as soon as possible.