- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies supervised gene regulatory network inference framework, specifically it proposes an approach called GeneBridge that conducts zero-shot unseen cell line GRN prediction. GeneBridge constructs a unified semantic gene graph with contextual gene representations, and trains a graph transformer on soft GRN labels across different cell types. Moreover, this paper proposes a new gene selection process relying on co-expression and attention from the fine-tuned GeneCompass. GeneBridge is evaluated on well-studied BEELINE datasets with leave-one-cell-type-out evaluation.
Critical strengths
This paper studies an important research question, GRN inference, in biology with potential applications in drug discovery. This paper is well written and the proposed method is tested on well-estabilished datasets for GRN inference BEELINE.
Critical weaknesses
My biggest concern is the central assumption of this work that supervised GRN inference method can be transferable to unseen cell types. In a recent study on BEELINE datasets [1], it was shown that supervised GRN inference methods mainly learn TF/TG's degree imbalance, and a simple logistic regression with one-hot gene embedding (without expression measurement) can match the performance of sophisticated supervised GRN methods.
Moreover, I'm not convinced by using co-expression and attention as part of gene selection. In practice, gene selection is driven by drug-discovery applications and HVGs are well motivated because they represent more "important" genes in the cell type. It makes more sense to make co-expression and attention as post-hoc filters after GRN inference rather than gene selection.
[1] InfoSEM: A Deep Generative Model with Informative Priors for Gene Regulatory Network Inference, ICML 2025
Questions for authors
-
Could the author show the performance of simply predicting the multi-CT joint soft-label without any training?
-
Could the author show the performance on unseen genes (see [1]) of unseen cell types, rather than seen genes of unseen cell types, which are known to be easily predicted by gene degree? Moreover, other supervised GRN inference methods should be included in the baseline (e.g., directly apply a GENELink trained on hESC on hHep).
[1] InfoSEM: A Deep Generative Model with Informative Priors for Gene Regulatory Network Inference, ICML 2025