1.The architectural contribution and scientific insight are not sufficiently established. In Table 3, the non-regional baseline B0 already achieves 93.90% Top-1, compared with 95.70% for the complete model. Regional tokenization and MoE contribute only 0.15 and 0.05 percentage points, respectively, in the progressive ablation. Although Appendix D.2 provides stronger evidence for regional FiLM, the necessity of several added components remains unclear, particularly without seed variability and computational costs for each variant. Intermediate visual alignment is adopted from prior work, so its benefits should be distinguished from the novel architectural contribution.
Furthermore, the calibration interventions establish that the trained model uses participant-specific parameters, but do not establish why the particular topographic partition is important. Comparisons with size-matched random partitions would help distinguish meaningful spatial structure from generic grouping or regularization. This limits both the demonstrated methodological novelty and the scientific explanation of the gains.
2.The comparisons do not sufficiently isolate the source of the performance improvements. As acknowledged in Section 4.1, ReShare uses joint training across participants, whereas most reference results in Table 1 come from independently trained participant-specific models. The headline gaps therefore combine differences in training-data coverage with differences in architecture and training objectives. The jointly trained controls are useful, but retain different visual targets, input processing, and optimization configurations.
Consequently, the comparisons demonstrate the effectiveness of the overall system more convincingly than the advantage of the proposed regional design itself. Stronger controls with matched supervision, input information, and training budgets are needed to support the architectural claims.