W1. One model, one scale, one domain. All results are on Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507, LoRA rank 32, math only. The two questions that matter most for judging generality are not addressed: does the gap shrink at larger scale (8B/14B), where the base model already aggregates reasonably well? Does it hold for other model families? The limitations section discusses verifiable rewards but says nothing about scale or model family.
W2. No ablation separating the two training components. The paper's central claim is that jointly training search and aggregation is what matters, but there is no control that trains only the aggregator over an untrained search policy (a PaCoRe-style variant — the cited closest work). Without it, we cannot tell how much of the gain comes from set-RL training of search traces versus from training aggregation alone. There is also no sensitivity analysis for N1=8, n=4, K=4, N2=4, even though these directly determine sample complexity and the variance of the marginal advantages.
W3. "Compute matched" is only token-matched. Each aggregation trace is generated over a ~16k-token concatenated context, so its per-token cost (prefill + attention) is far higher than a GRPO generation token. Wall-clock, memory, and FLOPs are never reported, and the intro's claim that sample complexity is "comparable to standard RL" understates the real training cost. Separately, GRPO traces are capped at 8192 tokens while SPIRAL search traces get 4096 — a per-trace sequential depth difference that is a confound in itself and is not discussed.
W4. Prop. 3.1 does not cover the implemented estimator. The proof assumes K sets sampled from ordered n-tuples; the implementation samples unordered sets, implicitly assuming f_spiral is symmetric — an assumption the authors themselves note fails due to ordering bias (App. D). Randomizing candidate order in the aggregation prompt is a cheap fix; at minimum the gap should be stated in the main text rather than left in the appendix.
W5. Statistics. AIME 2025/2026 have 30 problems each; no error bars, no seeds, and the headline numbers are "up to" point-wise maxima. The abstract's "15% higher" does not match the 13.5% reported in Sec. 4 and annotated in Fig. 6b.
Minor: (a) the length-penalty advantage hack (Eq. 9) is not ablated, and it is not stated whether GRPO gets the same treatment; (b) it is unclear whether the Fig. 6b token budget counts the input tokens the aggregator consumes when reading candidates — if not, aggregation-based methods get a systematically flattering cost curve; (c) the aggregation behavior is driven by a heavily engineered prompt (B.2), which sits awkwardly with the "no hand-designed scaffold" framing; (d) Fig. 5 is judge-dependent, and the base model in fact shows more strategy clusters than SPIRAL under all three judges, so the diversity claim should be stated more cautiously (pass@k remains the stronger evidence); (e) typos: duplicated "compute pipeline" in the Fig. 2 caption, "higher notably higher" in Sec. 4, and the limitations paragraph jumps from "First" to "Third".
If the authors can provide the aggregation-only ablation (W2) and honest cost accounting (W3), I would be willing to raise my score.
I appreciate the reply from the author; I will maintain the current score.