acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Agentic Local Environment Alignment via Decision-Oriented Knowledge Learning

Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents often operate in environments whose useful regularities are absent from task instructions: where objects are likely to be found, and which action procedures lead to success. These regularities can be learned from interaction, but trajectories also contain transient states and incidental actions that should not be carried across instances. We call regularities shared across related instances of a target setting local environment knowledge and organize them according to the decisions they support. Search decisions use probabilistic object-location relations, while execution decisions use procedural rules. We instantiate this representation in Structured Knowledge Learning (SKL), which keeps the LLM backbone frozen and learns both components from interaction: relations are estimated by combining commonsense priors with observation statistics across training instances, while rules are induced by contrasting trajectories with different returns. Both knowledge components are supplied to a frozen LLM agent at inference time. Under a shared evaluation protocol on ALFWorld and ScienceWorld, SKL substantially improves reward over prompting- and reflection-based baselines with GPT-4o-mini and Gemini-2.0-flash. On ALFWorld, for example, SKL improves reward from 62.6 to 81.3 with GPT-4o-mini and from 61.2 to 88.0 with Gemini-2.0-flash. Ablations show complementary gains from relations and rules, while budget and cost analyses show that these gains persist with fewer interactions and lower test-time token consumption. The learned knowledge also transfers across backbones: on ALFWorld, knowledge acquired with either GPT-4o-mini or Gemini-2.0-flash improves Gemini-2.5-flash, and GPT-4o-mini with SKL achieves higher reward than Gemini-2.5-flash without SKL.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Learning from Interaction, Agent Planning, Large Language Model Agents

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_91XzOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SKL gives a frozen LLM agent environment knowledge learned from training interactions. It learns object-location weights by combining observed co-occurrences with commonsense priors, and procedural rules by comparing trajectories on the same task and keeping edits that improve training return. On ALFWorld and ScienceWorld, it improves average reward with GPT-4o-mini and Gemini-2.0-flash. On ALFWorld, the scores reach 81.31 and 88.03, compared with 62.63 and 61.17 for the strongest controlled baselines. Ablations support using both components. Passing the learned knowledge to Gemini-2.5-flash raises its ALFWorld score from 74.60 to 85.26 or 86.79, without target-side learning. The tests cover held-out instances of known task families. ScienceWorld scores measure partial completion, not full-task success.

Critical strengths
  1. The split between where to search and how to act is useful and easy to inspect. Location hints come from pooled observations, while rules come from comparing trajectories. On ALFWorld, the two components reach 55.84 and 62.04 on their own, and 81.31 together. That gives a concrete reason to use both in this setting.

  2. The gains show up on both environments with both main models. I also find the transfer result useful: Gemini-2.5-flash goes from 74.60 to 85.26 or 86.79 when given knowledge learned by the other models, with no target-side learning. This shows that another frozen model can use the same knowledge within these task families.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main comparison doesn't tell me how much SKL adds over existing ways to learn knowledge offline. Base, ReAct, and the single-reflection version of Reflexion don't build reusable knowledge from the training set. AutoGuide and ExpeL already learn guidance from past trajectories. The paper discusses them and clearly labels the cross-paper results as reference only, but there is no controlled comparison with a close offline learner. With about 90M tokens spent on the reported Cool learning run, that comparison matters: some of the gain may come from doing offline adaptation at all. I'd like to see what the proposed representation and learning procedure add under a comparable budget.

  2. I can't tell how stable the results are when the knowledge is learned again from scratch. The five test runs reuse one learned knowledge object, and the paper says this clearly. They don't cover changes in exploratory rollouts, rule edits, or training order. This matters because a candidate rule is checked with one rollout per training instance against a cached score. The added sampling settings also give quite different results. The authors rightly note that rollout count and temperatures change together, so that experiment doesn't isolate either factor. Repeating the full learning process would show whether the gains hold up across the knowledge objects it produces.

Questions for authors
  1. Evidence needed: Have you compared SKL with a close offline learner, such as AutoGuide or ExpeL, using the same backbone and training tasks, a similar offline interaction/token budget, and knowledge frozen at test time? I'd need this to separate the method's benefit from the benefit of offline adaptation itself.

  2. Evidence needed: What happens when you repeat the whole knowledge-learning process with independent exploratory rollouts and different training orders? Please report how held-out results vary across newly learned knowledge objects, separately from repeated execution with one fixed object. This is the missing check on the learning procedure's reliability.

Reviewer_T8QLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the problem of improving LLM agents by learning environment-specific knowledge from interaction while keeping the underlying model frozen. The proposed method has two components: object-location relations to guide search and natural-language rules to guide task execution. Experiments show improvements over baseline solutions.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a interesting problem. Learning reusable knowledge about an environment is a useful way to improve agents whose model parameters cannot be updated.

  2. The experimental results are good. For example, on ALFWorld, the proposed solution improves average reward over the strongest controlled baseline from 62.63 to 81.31 with GPT-4o-mini and from 61.17 to 88.03 with Gemini-2.0-flash.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The comparison against existing work can be enhanced. Among the existing work, AutoGuide already extracts guidelines by contrasting same-task trajectories with different returns and identifying their divergence. ExpeL compares same-task successes and failures and maintains an editable set of insights. GEPA uses reflection and performance evaluation to optimize prompts. The paper cites these methods, but none is included in the experiments.

  2. The ablations do not really isolate the proposed mechanisms. The component ablation removes relations or rules during both learning and inference, thus changing the collected trajectories and learned artifacts as well as the final context. In addition, the procedural rules themselves contain search advice, so the results do not establish a clean separation between search and execution. The Failure-only comparison also removes exploratory rollouts together with the higher-return reference, confounding the benefit of contrastive reflection with the benefit of additional experience. Comparisons using the same trajectory pool would be more informative. For the relation component, a ranked location list without numerical weights would help determine whether the probabilities contribute beyond identifying useful search locations.

  3. The reported repetitions do not assess the reliability of knowledge learning. The five evaluations reuse one learned knowledge object, as the paper explicitly acknowledges. As a result, they measure execution variability but exclude variation arising from training-instance selection, training order, exploratory trajectories, and rule generation. This is particularly relevant because candidate rules are evaluated once over the training set and compared with a cached best score. Noisy evaluations can affect which rules are accepted. Several independent runs of the complete learning procedure are needed to assess whether SKL reliably produces useful knowledge.

  4. Some method and reporting details need reconciliation. The main method defines normalized relation weights obtained by combining counts and commonsense priors, whereas the ScienceWorld example supplies unnormalized integer weights. The paper should explain exactly how these values are constructed and whether the same fusion procedure is used. In addition, Figure 3(c) is described as showing performance after each accepted update, but its curves contain long plateaus, which are inconsistent with the strict improvement criterion in Algorithm 1 if the plotted values are the cached acceptance scores. The axis or caption should be corrected. The efficiency analysis would also be stronger with complete learning-cost measurements across task categories, since the approximately 90M-token offline cost is documented for one ALFWorld-Cool run.

Questions for authors

See weaknesses

Reviewer_yWfROpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents Structured Knowledge Learning (SKL), a method that improves a frozen LLM agent with knowledge about the environment it operates in, learned from training instances. SKL splits this knowledge in probabilistic object-location relations and procedural rules. For learning the object -ocation relations, the it observe the objects and locations across various trajectories and the counts are smoothed using LLM's commons sense priors on locations. For learning procedural knowledge, it pairs a greedy rollout with a higher-reward exploratory rollout, and three LLM modules diagnose where the two diverge, propose rule edits, and rewrite the rule block, which is kept only if it raises the average return on the training set. During inference, both components are added to the frozen agent's prompt. The authors show that SKL improves average reward over base, ReAct, and Reflexion agents on ALFWorld and ScienceWorld with two backbones while using fewer test-time tokens, and that the learned knowledge transfers to a stronger backbone.

Critical strengths
  1. I found the knowledge-type breakdown interesting: environment knowledge is split by the decision it supports, with probabilistic object-location relations for where to search and procedural rules for how to act.
  2. The learned knowledge transfers across backbones: knowledge learned with GPT-4o-mini or Gemini-2.0-flash also improves the stronger Gemini-2.5-flash on every ALFWorld task type, which hints towards generalization of the idea.
Critical weaknesses

While I find the idea interesting, I believe this paper is currently not ready to be published. A few reasons:

  1. The evaluation covers only two templated text benchmarks, with older backbone LLMs. ALFWorld and ScienceWorld are both text simulators with fixed observation templates, and the paper's relation learner depends on them: it extracts object-location pairs with a deterministic parser that "matches predefined textual patterns". These are at best toy datasets, and it is unclear whether SKL carries over to web, app, or tool-use environments without such templates. The backbone LLMs are also older (GPT-4o-mini and Gemini-2.0-flash; Qwen3-8B appears in a single run on one task type), so it is unclear whether the gains hold for current models.
  2. Weak baselines, with no comparison to methods that learn from experience. SKL is the only method in Tables 1 and 2 that learns from the training instances while the comparators are a base agent, ReAct, and Reflexion. Methods that learn reusable knowledge from experience, such as ExpeL, AutoManual, and ACE, which the paper cites, or CLIN [1] on ScienceWorld, are the natural baselines. While Fig. 2 studies some baselines on AlfWorld they aren't state of the art. It is also unclear how SKL compare to these techniques in cost and time complexity.
  3. Both learners have close precedents that the paper does not discuss. The rule learner's modules are prompted as the "feedback model", the "gradient model", and the "optimizer" of "an optimization system", and they exchange a "RESPONSE_GRADIENT" and a "VARIABLE_GRADIENT". This is the vocabulary of TextGrad [2], and the critique-then-edit loop is that of ProTeGi [3]. Using an LLM's commonsense as a prior belief for search, the basis of the relation learner, also appears in LLM-MCTS [4]. None of these works is cited, so it is unclear what SKL adds beyond the decision split.
  4. The writing is repetitive and harder to follow than the method needs. The method is simple: count where objects are seen and smooth the counts with the LLM's prior, and refine a rule block from pairs of better and worse trajectories. Yet the same two-component description is restated in nearly the same words in the abstract, introduction, related work, and Section 3.2 (pp. 1–4), and Section 3.1 states an objective, choosing the context that maximizes expected return, that any memory or prompt-optimization method would fit. Meanwhile, relevant baselines, cost comparions with them and throrugh ablations are missing.

References [1] B. P. Majumder et al. CLIN: A Continually Learning Language Agent for Rapid Task Adaptation and Generalization. COLM 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10134 [2] M. Yuksekgonul et al. Optimizing generative AI by backpropagating language model feedback (TextGrad). Nature, 2025. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-08661-4 [3] R. Pryzant et al. Automatic Prompt Optimization with "Gradient Descent" and Beam Search (ProTeGi). EMNLP 2023. https://aclanthology.org/2023.emnlp-main.494/ [4] Z. Zhao et al. Large Language Models as Commonsense Knowledge for Large-Scale Task Planning (LLM-MCTS). NeurIPS 2023. https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14078

Questions for authors

lCarifications that could change my assessment

Q1. How would SKL carry over to web, app, or tool-use environments without fixed observation templates, where the relation learner's parser has no predefined textual patterns to match? Do the gains hold when a current backbone LLM both learns and uses the knowledge?

Q2. How does SKL compare to recent methods that learn from experience, such as ExpeL, AutoManual, ACE, or CLIN, n run on the same training instances and backbones as SKL?

Q3. How do SKL's learning cost and time compare with those of these methods on the same training instances? What is the wall-clock learning time, and how do cost and time scale with the number of training instances and rollouts?

Q4. Why are the seven exploratory rollouts sampled at different temperatures (0.1 to 0.7) rather than at a single temperature?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.