acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

How Do Latent Actions Generalize? Probing Ordered Transfer Structure in Action-Free Representations

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Latent action models learn transition representations from visual data without robot-action annotations, providing a potential interface between large-scale visual experience and downstream policy learning. If latent actions are intended to support generalization, however, a key question is how transition information should be organized in the latent space. We study whether action-free latent representations develop an ordered refinement structure that is systematically related to cross-distribution generalization. To make this process observable, we introduce a weak nested-access bias that exposes progressively expanded prefixes of the same transition representation, without action supervision, predefined token semantics, or assumed high-level/low-level skill hierarchies. We then analyze how action-related, state-transition, and environment-specific information evolve across refinements and distribution shifts. Across LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, and MimicGen, we observe a consistent pattern: refinement increases in-distribution action recoverability, while environment-specific information also becomes more decodable and OOD performance does not improve monotonically. Under stronger distribution shifts, intermediate refinements can outperform the complete latent representation, with similar non-monotonic behavior in closed-loop control. These findings suggest that generalizable latent-action learning depends not only on how much transition information is learned, but also on how that information is organized during learning, offering a useful direction for designing more transferable latent-action objectives.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
latent action models, self-supervised representation learning, out-of-distribution generalization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_hTeYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper analyzes how nested training of latent action model affects their information in the representations and how downstream policy generalizes under distribution shift. They compare flat baseline with multi-prefix and retained-prefix setting where every or sampled prefix latent actions per sample contribute to training. From cross-task transfer analysis from LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus and MimicGen simulation environments, they present action recoverability, generalization performance and action supervision diagnostic showing that nested training enables generalizable latent actions.

Critical strengths
  • Interesting research question. Latent action models store sufficient information to predict the next state from the current state, expecting action-relative information being stored in the latent action. This paper asks how the information is stored and organized when nested training is applied on the latent action and explains whether that organization relates to generalization under distribution shift.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited Contribution. Nested or ordered training is already known to help in general representation [1, 2], visual tokenization [3] and (latent) action tokenization [4, 5]. They also show improvements downstream performance, data efficiency and generalization. Compared to prior methods, they show semantic hierarchy of low-to-higher level details in FlexTok and coarse-to-fine trajectories in OAT even without explicit bias except nested training as the methods elaborate. Even if nest training can also be applied to latent action (which is also shown in FlexLAM), this work's analysis are neither sufficient nor have a interesting latent action specific property explored as a standalone contribution.

  • Limited Analysis. Linear probing and R² analysis only comes from linear decodability, not the deeper structure or geometry of the latent representations or how policy uses them. Also, MoLA seems to not be a reasonable baseline to compare on this work, unless this work is built on base architectures of MoLA. The results also show disagreement between action R² and success rates (Table 2 vs 3), inconsistent behavior (Table 9), which are insufficiently discussed. Also, fundamental behaviors of latent action and nested training are missing, for example, link to latent action bottleneck or huge gap between two nested variants.

[1] Matryoshka Representation Learning, NeurIPS 2022

[2] Learning Ordered Representations with Nested Dropout, ICML 2014

[3] FlexTok: Resampling Images into 1D Token Sequences of Flexible Length, ICML 2025

[4] OAT: Ordered Action Tokenization, RSS 2026

[5] FlexLAM: Resolving the Bottleneck Trade-off in Latent Action Learning, Arxiv 2606.19408

Questions for authors
  • Semantics of Latent Action. Do your existing results show what information latent action tokens carry, like how high-to-low-level visual content in FlexTok or coarse-to-fine trajectories in OAT? Beyond existing analysis, what does this work show that is not expected from prior works?

  • Experimental Configurations. Can you clarify the downstream policy baseline, design and configurations how latent action is used?

Reviewer_2meYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how action-free latent action representations organize transition information. It also examines how this organization relates to generalization across distributions. The authors build on Matryoshka representation learning and nested dropout. Multi-Prefix trains several prefixes at the same time. Retained-Prefix randomly samples one prefix during training. The authors evaluate frozen representations with action probes and suite classification probes. They also test downstream closed-loop control.

Experiments on LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, and MimicGen show that in-distribution (ID) action recoverability generally improves with prefix length. However, out-of-distribution (OOD) performance does not always improve. Intermediate prefixes sometimes outperform the full representation under stronger distribution shifts. Closed-loop control shows a similar pattern.

The paper offers a useful perspective on latent action generalization through information organization. However, the current experiments do not fully support the main claims.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper asks a useful and relevant research question. Many studies on latent actions focus on learning objectives, action recoverability, or downstream task performance. This paper also examines how information is organized within a latent representation. It then studies how this organization relates to generalization across distributions. This is a useful research direction.

  2. The nested training methods provide a useful way to study latent representations. The authors build on Matryoshka representation learning and nested dropout. Their methods allow prefixes of different lengths to support future prediction. These prefixes make it easier to study what information becomes available as the representation gets longer. This approach is simple and may help guide the design of representations that generalize better.

  3. The experiments connect representation analysis with downstream control. The authors use action prediction and suite classification probes on frozen representations. They study representation transfer across several benchmarks and distribution shifts. They also evaluate closed-loop control. These experiments help assess whether the findings from representation analysis also matter for downstream control.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main claims need more direct evidence.

The paper compares action recoverability, suite-specific information, and control performance across prefixes. However, these results do not directly show which ways of organizing information lead to better generalization. The experiments also do not clearly separate the effects of information organization, representation capacity, and the training process.

  1. The experiments have limited coverage, and the stability of the results is unclear.

The external baseline comparison is limited to MoLA. The experiments use one visual backbone and one latent action model training seed. The closed-loop control results also use one training seed. These limits make it hard to tell whether the differences between prefixes are consistent across runs. The non-monotonic trends may also depend on the training seed. The authors should use multiple training seeds and report the variation in performance. These additional runs would help establish whether the main findings are stable.

  1. The ID-to-OOD retention metric $ ρk\rho_k $ does not by itself establish better OOD generalization.

The paper uses $ ρk\rho_k$ to compare the relative transfer performance of different prefixes. The metric is based on the ratio of OOD to ID action prediction $ R2R^2$ . It measures relative performance retention rather than absolute OOD action recoverability. Its value depends on both ID and OOD performance. A higher value does not always mean better generalization.

The following hypothetical example illustrates this limitation. The example uses the OOD-to-ID �3��3� ratio for simplicity.

RepresentationID R2R^2OOD R2R^2Relative retention
A0.020.01995%
B0.400.3280%

Representation A has higher retention, but its action prediction performance is low on both ID and OOD data. Representation B has lower retention but much better absolute OOD performance. Therefore, higher relative retention alone does not show that a representation preserves more useful action information. It also does not establish better OOD generalization.

  1. The presentation needs improvement.

Figure 1 appears blurry when enlarged, particularly the labels and diagram elements. Exporting the text, arrows, and boxes as vector graphics would improve readability. Some passages repeat similar points and could be condensed to make the presentation more concise.

Questions for authors
  1. Multi-Prefix and Retained-Prefix objectives and padding. Equation (7) uses zero padding for Multi-Prefix. Equation (8) seems to use a different padding method for Retained-Prefix. How does each method fill the unused suffix positions? Do both methods use the same padding method? Do the main results still hold when both methods use the same method?

  2. Details of the closed-loop control policy. Could the authors describe the policy architecture and explain how the latent representation is used as input? How does policy training use robot-action labels? Could the authors also report the number of training steps, data size, and compute budget for each setting?

  3. Comparison between models with and without action labels in Figure 2. Why does the model trained with 0% action labels outperform some models trained with action labels at certain prefix lengths? The appendix states that these models use different training settings. Could the authors repeat the comparison with the same architecture, optimizer, training budget, and other key settings? If some settings cannot be matched, could the authors explain how these differences may affect the results? This would help separate the effect of action supervision from the effect of the training setup.

  4. Direct evidence of generalization. Could the authors provide more direct evidence for the link between information organization and OOD generalization? Could they also use multiple random seeds to test whether the advantage of intermediate prefixes is stable?

Reviewer_F3UeOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents a study concerning the future observation predictiveness of latent actions at various refinement levels. Specifically, they consider latent action representations consisting of a sequence of vectors and define more refined representations to be those consisting of a longer series of latent vectors. The authors present a study on whether and how changes to the latent action learning pipeline encouraging observation predictiveness from less refined latent vectors affect observation predictiveness on ID and OOD data. The authors provide some results using this pipeline for closed loop action prediction. A key observation is that additional tokens can lead to more recoverability in-distribution while sometimes leading to worse OOD recoverability.

Critical strengths
  • There are some interesting results about which representations transfer the most readily to OOD settings
Critical weaknesses

I think overall the paper is hard to follow and lacks a strong motivation.

  • The core contribution is a study on whether we can extract some kind of ordered refinement on latent action representations and how this leads to transfer to OOD settings. However they never really motivate this in downstream improvements to action prediction.
  • Furthermore, the implicit argument is that the latent action prediction pretraining learns a good action label-free representation that enables transfer, but the authors don't compare to other methods for learning an action lable-free representation such as through a WAM. They briefly discuss methods such as WAMs and VLAs ("both ultimately depend on representations that preserve action-relevant transition structure while avoiding over-reliance on incidental properties of the training distribution.") but don't make a clear argument about why their pipeline wouldn't have the same limitations.
  • A key motivation for action-free pretraining is a setting such as human to robot transfer where there is a clear motivation from an abundance of action-free human data. There is no experiment showing whether this recipe readily leads to transfer across such a gap.

Writing quality

  • The writing omits some important details
  • The authors repeatedly (even in the abstract!) refer to results for LIBERO-Plus and MimicGen which are only ever presented in the appendix. Any result important enough to mention in the abstract should be in the main paper. Also Table 7 seems to be pretty important to their claims but the authors never explicitly mention its units. I am guessing that whereas the results in the main paper use R2×100R^2 \times 100 this table is presenting R2R^2 but I am not sure.
  • The authors omit many important details about their closed loop evaluations to the point where it is difficult for me to draw any conclusions from them. How, architecturally, do they predict latent actions. What data do they train on and for how long? Why no evaluations for the flat latent action backbone with P1?
  • What data do they use for libero plus evaluations? Is this testing robustness to OOD variation in actions or visual inputs?
Questions for authors
  • Can you please clarify the motivation for the work
  • Can you please clarify the missing experimental details

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.