- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents a minor modification of QCNet (Query-centric trajectory prediction, 2023) and HiVT (HiVT: Hierarchical vector transformer for multi-agent motion prediction, 2022) for trajectory prediction. It subsamples and aggregates the previous frames using a fixed stride. As a results, the approach is, as expected, faster than QCNet and HiVT. The approach is evaluated on Argoverse 1 for HiVT and Argoverse 2 for QCNet.
Critical strengths
Although it is not a critical strength, it needs to be mentioned that the approach is evaluated on Argoverse 1 for HiVT and Argoverse 2 for QCNet. The Appendix contains several ablation studies like impact of stride.
Critical weaknesses
Lack of novelty:
The paper presents a minor modification of QCNet (Query-centric trajectory prediction, 2023) and HiVT (HiVT: Hierarchical vector transformer for multi-agent motion prediction, 2022) for trajectory prediction. Subsampling observational data is an implementation detail and a common approach to reduce inference time. The approach also does it differently for QCNet and HiVT, but the difference is only regarding the interactions that are considered. Overall, the paper does not contain a major contribution..
Insufficient experimental evaluation:
The approach is compared only to its baselines from 2022 and 2023. The paper does not include any comparison to state-of-the-art methods. For each baseline, even a different dataset has been used. The results do not demonstrate the generalization across datasets and methods.
Poor presentation:
The paper is poorly structured and written. The introduction summarizes the results instead of clearly discussing the contribution. Figure 1(b) is not understandable since normalized change variance is not explained. The term is also only used in the figure and caption but not in the text. Figure 2 does not add anything to the paper. The approach is very simple but not well described. Section 3 starts with unimportant details. The rest provides a description what has been done, but without providing any intuition or motivation. The theoretical discussion does not add anything to the paper. The connection of Proposition 2 to the results are not well described.
Questions for authors
The AI use statement declares that generative AI tools assisted with language polishing. The poorly structured paper, emphasis on unimportant details, and meaningless figures, however, indicate that the paper and figures have have been generated in large part by AI tools.
Provide alpha, beta, lambda (Proposition 2) for the networks HiVT and QCNet.
General Response: Core Mechanism, Strong Baselines, and Multi-Benchmark Evaluations
We thank all reviewers for their constructive feedback. Below, we clarify our core motivation, present new empirical results from the revised manuscript, and address concerns regarding strong baselines, reuse strategies, multi-backbone generality, and domain robustness.
1. Core Motivation and Mechanism
2. Fine-Tuning on Official Converged Checkpoint (Argoverse 2 Full 24,988 Scenes, RTX 4090 D)
See Appendix A.13 (Table 11, Page 23) in the revised manuscript:
3. Generalization Across Backbones and Datasets
4. Safety-Critical Scenarios (Official Checkpoint, Appendix A.14, Table 12)
5. Computational Scope and Camera-Ready Plan
Due to tight rebuttal time and compute constraints, we prioritized representative multi-backbone and OOD evaluations. We will provide full-split extended curves in the camera-ready version.