acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SkillEvoReg: Regularizing Agent Skill Evolution Against Overfitting

Abstract

Language-model agents increasingly improve by converting execution experience into reusable external skills. Yet repeated skill updates form a learning process of their own: locally useful edits can accumulate into redundant or task-specific instructions, while new updates can disrupt behavior that previously worked. We study this problem as skill-evolution overfitting and introduce SkillEvoReg, a general regularization framework for skill evolution inspired by anti-overfitting techniques in neural-network training. SkillEvoReg combines training-time skill dropout, which perturbs update generation, and complexity-aware local regularization, which controls unnecessary structural growth, with causal counterexample validation (CCV), which provides targeted behavioral validation of candidate-specific regressions. We instantiate the framework across heterogeneous skill-evolution systems while retaining each system's native skill evolver and task evaluator. Across SkillOpt, SkillEvolBench, and ContinualSkillBench, SkillEvoReg consistently controls skill-state growth while preserving competitive downstream capability, improves several transfer and later-stage evolution outcomes, and identifies update-level regressions that structural metrics alone cannot reveal. These results suggest that explicit regularization is a useful complement to increasingly capable skill updaters.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
self-evolving agents, agent skills, skill evolution, overfitting, regularization, language-model agents

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_dAJKOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SkillEvoReg treats repeated skill updates as a learning process that can overfit, and adds three regularizers around an existing skill updater. Skill dropout hides part of the current skill while the updater generates an edit. Complexity-aware local regularization merges, rewrites, or deletes newly added content when the skill grows too much. Causal counterexample validation (CCV) builds a targeted variant of a training task and repairs the edit if the old skill succeeds on it while the new skill fails. The method is applied to SkillOpt, SkillEvolBench, and ContinualSkillBench, where it produces much smaller skills with comparable or better performance in most settings.

Critical strengths

S1. The paper identifies a real problem in repeated skill evolution: updates learned from a few recent trajectories accumulate and can hurt later behavior. The motivating study makes this concrete. On SpreadsheetBench, transfer accuracy peaks at epoch 4 and then falls while IID accuracy keeps rising and the skill grows to 23.6 times its initial length.

S2. The regularizers consistently make skills more compact. Skill size drops sharply in all three settings, for example from 6,060 to 2,341 tokens on SpreadsheetBench, while performance stays comparable or better in most settings.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The method is less general than claimed. The paper presents SkillEvoReg as a general framework that can wrap any native updater, but each integration is customized. The paper itself states that the three integrations do not share one implementation and differ in skill representation, complexity handling, CCV case construction, repair scope, and final candidate handling. What is shared is mainly three high-level principles. Applying them to a new system would require redesigning these components, which limits the value of SkillEvoReg as a general framework.

Questions for authors

Q1. In every setting, SkillEvoReg is compared only with the same native updater without regularization. Please compare with more baselines, for example the methods named in the related work that also guard against brittle skill updates, such as SkillAdam and Trace2Skill.

Q2. The regularizers add extra LLM calls and evaluations during training, such as local editing, attack generation, and running both the old and the new skill on each attacked case. Given the performance gains, is this extra cost worthwhile?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer dAJK (1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the sharp critique regarding framework generality, external baselines, and training-time computational cost. These points directly shaped our revision.

W1. What is shared across the three implementations vs. what is host-specific?

The reviewer is right that a single unmodified software wrapper cannot attach directly to every skill-evolution system without customization. In the revision (Section 4.4, Appendix B Table 12, and Appendix D), we replace any implication of a universal plug-and-play implementation with a more accurate characterization: a shared two-stage regularization design with host-specific implementations at the update boundary.

What is shared is the two-stage regularization design:

  1. Training-time skill dropout: Segmenting the incumbent into atoms, masking a subset during training rollouts and update generation, and reconciling only the learned delta Δtdrop\Delta_t^{\mathrm{drop}} with the complete incumbent (Algorithm 1).
  2. Complexity-aware local regularization: Measuring structural growth signals ctc_t, programmatically bounding edits to changed and related atoms Ωt\Omega_t, and consolidating via {NOOP, MERGE, REWRITE, DELETE} (Algorithm 2).

What is host-specific reflects genuine semantic differences across updaters (Appendix B Table 12 & Appendix D.3): SkillOpt operates over ranked document edits and incorporates complexity into its regularized paired-validation gate; SkillEvolBench operates over family-level library patches with growth-budgeted local edits and native commit; ContinualSkillBench operates over CREATE-SKILL/MODIFY-SKILL directory snapshots with separate absolute and relative complexity thresholds.

Q1. Comparison with stronger baselines (TextReg, SkillAdam, Trace2Skill)

We added empirical comparisons against TextReg (adapted) and two SkillAdam protocols across all three SkillOpt tasks (Section 5.2 Table 1, Appendix A.2 & A.3; see also Item 3 of our General Response):

  • TextReg (adapted) retains TextReg's gradient purification, RuleBank, semantic regularization, and full-document optimizer using SkillOpt trajectories and paired validation acceptance.
  • SkillAdam (native protocol) runs SkillAdam's original training schedule, within-batch validation, stopping rule, and terminal delivery on the shared task host.
  • SkillAdam (adapted) preserves SkillAdam's candidate generation, momentum memory, and adaptive edit budget while aligning the training schedule, train/val split, paired validation gate, and epoch-end delivery selection with SkillOpt.

On delivery accuracy, SkillEvoReg ranks first on all three tasks (58.50% / 81.14% / 35.02% on SpreadsheetBench / SearchQA / LiveMathBench), outperforming TextReg (51.50% / 79.43% / 34.56%) as well as native-protocol SkillAdam (45.00% / 80.25% / 27.88%) and adapted SkillAdam (44.00% / 80.86% / 26.73%). Notably, while TextReg and SkillAdam often produce shorter texts, SkillAdam drops sharply on SpreadsheetBench and LiveMathBench, and TextReg trails on SpreadsheetBench (−7.00 pp)—illustrating that minimizing length alone does not preserve downstream capability.

We also expanded our discussion of Trace2Skill in Related Work (Section 2 & Appendix G): Trace2Skill focuses on hierarchically consolidating trajectory lessons to construct reusable skills, which is complementary to regularizing repeated updates of an already persistent skill state.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer dAJK (2/2)

Q2. Training-time computational overhead and whether the cost is worthwhile

We agree that training cost must be weighed against the gains—in fact, this consideration motivated removing CCV (Item 1 of our General Response), whose probe generation and paired evaluations incurred substantial token overhead for very few verified repairs.

For the two retained regularizers (summarized in Item 3 of our General Response), skill-atom masking and restoration are deterministic local text operations with no dedicated model calls or task-validation rollouts. Additional model calls occur when dropout reconciliation or complexity growth triggers candidate-local editing (with shared calls counted once). As reported in Appendix C.5, across five SkillOpt runs, the local editor recorded 43–86 calls per run, and its direct local-editing token cost amounted to 0.20–0.41% of recorded native training-step tokens:

SkillOpt RunRecorded Native Training-Step TokensLocal Editor CallsLocal Editor TokensDirect Local-Editing Ratio
Spreadsheet (seed 101)183,712,99743386,6030.21%
Spreadsheet (seed 202)204,106,80843408,9230.20%
Spreadsheet (seed 303)178,227,13545388,2380.22%
SearchQA (seed 101)440,878,83886891,7790.20%
LiveMath (seed 101)111,324,86144451,9040.41%

On SkillOpt, the local editor accounts for only 0.20–0.41% of recorded native training-step tokens (with zero extra validation rollouts). Across those same SkillOpt benchmarks, the full two-component SkillEvoReg framework reduces three-seed SpreadsheetBench final skill tokens by 42.2% while improving mean delivery accuracy by +3.00 pp and terminal accuracy by +5.08 pp, and cuts final skill tokens on SearchQA and LiveMathBench by 76.9% and 76.2%. Separately at deployment time, the resulting compact skills reduce frozen-evaluation token usage by 29.5–56.1% on the three SkillOpt tasks (Appendix C.4).

Thank you for the detailed response and revisions. My remaining concern is that the remaining mechanism after removing CCV still lacks sufficient justification as a general framework, since both skill dropout and local complexity editing still depend heavily on benchmark-specific rules and interfaces, so I will maintain my current assessment.

Thank you for the follow-up. We agree that framework-specific adaptation is necessary, and we appreciate the reviewer's concern about generality.

A useful analogy is neural-network regularization: dropout and weight regularization are general methods, although their implementations vary across neural architectures (e.g., MLP, CNN, GNN), much as skill-evolution frameworks differ in their representations and update procedures.

Similarly, SkillEvoReg applies the same two regularization mechanisms across different skill-evolution frameworks, with adaptations mainly in skill representations and native update interfaces.

We view this as evidence of methodological generality, while recognizing that SkillEvoReg is not yet a plug-and-play solution for arbitrary systems.

Reviewer_nhnsOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

An LLM agent can improve by updating its skills; however, such updates may overfit to examples. This paper draws inspiration for overfitting mitigation in deep learning and finds three ways in which similar concepts can be designed for skill learning. Experimental results show that they improve skill learning and ablations that each method is complementary to the others.

Critical strengths

Skill learning is an emerging area and the paper is thus topical. The idea of formulating the generalization of skill learning as avoiding overfitting is clever, especially because it allows finding analogies to existing methods.

Critical weaknesses

There are no critical weaknesses. The method could always be tested on more benchmarks and models, but I believe the current paper offers a solid proof of concept.

Questions for authors

I did not quite get section 5.5.2. I was expecting an ablation study where CCV is taken out, but instead it describes the mechanism qualitatively. That's fine, but maybe it could be accompanied by an actual ablation study, i.e. how much would the performance deteriorate if it was taken out?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer nhns

We thank the reviewer for recognizing the value of formulating skill evolution through the lens of overfitting and for asking what happens when CCV is removed.

Q. What happens if CCV is removed?

To answer directly: in all main SkillOpt runs (SpreadsheetBench, SearchQA, LiveMathBench) and all five ContinualSkillBench domains, CCV ran checks but never changed the persistent skill state or altered any acceptance decision. Because those trajectories already reflect the two retained regularizers, their reported numbers stay the same when CCV is removed without re-running every benchmark. Our decision to remove CCV (see Item 1 of our General Response) is grounded in two findings from auditing those runs:

  1. High computational cost for very few persistent repairs: Because every intervention must pass source qualification, executable probe generation, and paired incumbent/candidate checks, CCV incurred heavy token and rollout overhead while producing very few persistent repairs, without systematic re-testing on the triggering probes to confirm recovery.
  2. Unreliable generated test cases and unclear failure causes: In a SpreadsheetBench diagnostic, an input transformation left three invalid reference answer cells (caught before scoring). In an archived SkillEvolBench repair case, the intended environmental change did not occur and the candidate failure involved an unrelated execution error. Paired comparison alone does not guarantee test validity or cleanly tie a failure to the intended rule—and repairing against flawed probes risks polluting the persistent skill.

We therefore removed CCV from SkillEvoReg and focused the paper on training-time skill dropout and complexity-aware local regularization:

  • SpreadsheetBench component analysis (Section 5.5 Table 4): Across the four configurations (two frozen test evaluations each), Native reaches 47.00% (31.7K chars), Complexity-only 53.75% (13.1K), Dropout-only 57.25% (19.5K), and Combined 59.25% (11.7K), with the combination achieving the best result among these configurations in both accuracy and compactness.
  • SkillEvolBench (Section 5.3 Table 2): SkillEvolBench was the main benchmark where CCV previously modified the persistent library, so we updated it with a run without CCV. Without CCV, Deployment generalization (T4–T6) reaches 34.44% (above both unregularized 2-pass at 29.44% and 1-pass at 31.67%), Replay (T1–T3, 39.44%) stays close to 1-pass (40.00%), and second-pass token growth drops by 41.2% relative to unregularized 2-pass.

I think my concern has been addressed (although the response is pretty hard to understand). I agree with the other reviewers' concerns, but still stay positive about the paper.

Thank you for your feedback and continued support. We appreciate your comment on clarity and will further improve the presentation in the final version.

Reviewer_T23xOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

SkillEvoReg aims to prevent overfitting as language-model agents improve their reusable skills without changing model weights. It combines temporary skill dropout, complexity-aware editing, and counterexample validation to make skill updates more reliable. Across three skill-learning benchmarks, the authors report smaller skill libraries, generally competitive performance, and improvements on some tasks, although results are mixed.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a relevant problem in agents that improve through persistent external skills. It clearly distinguishes structural accumulation, excessive specialization, and update-induced regression, showing why skill size alone cannot characterize the quality of evolution. The longitudinal SpreadsheetBench analysis provides concrete motivation for studying how repeated updates affect transfer, and the framework offers a coherent way to intervene during update generation, structural consolidation, and behavioral validation.

The method contains several thoughtful design choices. Dropout restores masked content before commitment, while local regularization permits useful additions and enforces editable regions programmatically. CCV compares the incumbent and candidate on the same targeted perturbation after both qualify on the original task. This comparison helps distinguish candidate-specific deterioration from an example that is simply difficult, and provides a useful behavioral check beyond structural complexity.

The evaluation covers single-document optimization, revision of an established skill library, and continual skill creation and modification. Across these settings, SkillEvoReg consistently produces more compact persistent states while often preserving or improving downstream performance. The SpreadsheetBench ablation supports complementary effects from dropout and complexity regularization. The paper also reports negative results and residual instability, making its practical benefits and remaining limitations easier to assess.

Critical weaknesses

I am not sure how reliable the reported gains are. The main results come from one skill-evolution run per condition, and evaluating the same learned skills twice does not capture variation across learning runs. This matters because two continuations from the same epoch-six checkpoint finish at 59.25% and 50.00%. Several gains are small, while final LiveMath and context-shift performance get worse. More independent runs would make it easier to judge whether the improvements are consistent.

CCV’s contribution is also hard to judge. It makes no changes to the persistent skills in the main SpreadsheetBench ablation. Across the experiments, the paper reports 12 regression signals and nine repairs, but does not show how much those repairs improve downstream performance. Algorithm 3 also returns the repaired skill without explicitly checking whether the repair worked. An ablation without CCV, along with comparisons against ordinary replay and untargeted test variations, would help establish whether the extra steps are worthwhile.

The related-work discussion misses two closely related papers. DLPO [1] already explores textual dropout and regularization, while TextReg [2] addresses prompt growth and overly specific rules that hurt generalization. SkillEvoReg makes different design choices—for example, it temporarily hides instructions, whereas DLPO leaves selected sentences unchanged during updates—but these differences need a clearer comparison. I also could not find the base model’s name or key settings such as the dropout rate, complexity budgets, and exact acceptance rule, which makes the results difficult to reproduce.

References

[1] Dengyun Peng, Yuhang Zhou, Qiguang Chen, JinHao Liu, Jingjing Chen, Libo Qin, and Wanxiang Che. 2025. DLPO: Towards a Robust, Efficient, and Generalizable Prompt Optimization Framework from a Deep-Learning Perspective. Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2025, pp. 8311–8334.

[2] Lucheng Fu, Ye Yu, Yiyang Wang, Yiqiao Jin, Haibo Jin, B. Aditya Prakash, and Haohan Wang. 2026. TextReg: Mitigating Prompt Distributional Overfitting via Regularized Text-Space Optimization. arXiv:2605.21318v1, 20 May 2026.

Questions for authors

If there are not other issues that I haven't identified and the authors convincingly address this issue I am open to increase my score

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer T23x (1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment, particularly for distinguishing execution-time evaluation variation from training-run variability across independent skill-evolution trajectories.

W1. Reliability across independent learning runs; LiveMath terminal drop

We agree that evaluating one frozen skill twice measures execution-time variance rather than training-run variability (also summarized in Item 2 of our General Response). We therefore added two independent eight-epoch SpreadsheetBench learning runs (seeds 202 and 303) alongside seed 101, bringing the comparison to three independent learning trajectories per condition, each evaluated twice on the frozen test set at both its delivery (validation-selected) and final (epoch-8) checkpoints (Appendix A.4):

MetricNative SkillOpt (3-seed mean ±\pm SD)SkillEvoReg (3-seed mean ±\pm SD)
Delivery Test (%) ↑\uparrow53.17±1.9453.17 \pm 1.9456.17±2.0456.17 \pm 2.04 (+3.00 pp)
Final Test (%) ↑\uparrow50.58±3.6350.58 \pm 3.6355.67±3.1755.67 \pm 3.17 (+5.08 pp)
Final Skill Tokens ↓\downarrow5,502±5145,502 \pm 5143,180±7543,180 \pm 754 (−42.2%)
Final Complexity CC ↓\downarrow102.77±12.38102.77 \pm 12.3867.24±10.1367.24 \pm 10.13 (−34.6%)

SkillEvoReg outperforms the corresponding native baseline on every individual seed in delivery accuracy (+3.75 / +3.75 / +1.50 pp), terminal accuracy (+12.25 / +0.25 / +2.75 pp), token count, and structural complexity, while reducing average late-stage degradation (Final − Delivery) from −2.58 pp to −0.50 pp.

We also separate delivery from final checkpoints across all SkillOpt tasks (Table 1 vs. Appendix A.2) and provide an item-level audit of LiveMath's terminal trade-off in Appendix C.1: 18 of the 21 net lost correct question-repeat instances occur on the 92/217 test items whose correct answer text is the meta-option ("One of the remaining options is correct, but a stronger result can be proven"), rather than uniform degradation across questions.

W2. What does CCV contribute, and is it worth the extra work?

The reviewer's concern prompted us to re-evaluate CCV's practical yield, cost, and reliability (see Item 1 of our General Response for the three-part rationale and our response to R2 for details). Because probes must pass strict qualification and paired evaluation before triggering repair, CCV produced very few persistent repairs across evaluated trajectories while adding heavy computation (orders of magnitude above local editing), and lacked downstream verification that the resulting repairs remained effective. We also found concrete probe-validity and attribution failures, as well as partial coverage by dropout and complexity. Based on this evidence, we removed CCV from the proposed framework.

For the two retained regularizers, the SpreadsheetBench component analysis (Section 5.5 Table 4; two frozen test evaluations each) gives 47.00% for native evolution, 53.75% for complexity only, 57.25% for dropout only, and 59.25% for their combination, with final skill sizes of 31.7K, 13.1K, 19.5K, and 11.7K characters. The combination achieved the best result among these configurations in both accuracy and compactness. Because the historical native run retained Slow Update/Meta Skill, we present this as a component comparison rather than a strict single-factor ablation.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer T23x (2/2)

W3. DLPO, TextReg, and reproducibility details

  • Conceptual & empirical comparisons (Section 2, Section 5.2, Appendix A.3 & G): We expanded Related Work to contrast SkillEvoReg with DLPO and TextReg. DLPO preserves selected sentences during prompt edits, whereas our skill dropout masks skill atoms during training rollouts and update generation and reconciles only the learned delta onto the complete incumbent. TextReg combines gradient purification, RuleBank, and semantic regularization. Empirically, we added TextReg (adapted) across all three SkillOpt tasks (Table 1): its delivery scores are 51.50% / 79.43% / 34.56% on SpreadsheetBench / SearchQA / LiveMathBench, compared with 58.50% / 81.14% / 35.02% for SkillEvoReg (which also leads both SkillAdam variants on every task).
  • Reproducibility & key hyperparameters:
    • Base model & inference: All archived experiments use GPT-5.4-mini with medium reasoning effort.
    • Splits & schedules: SkillOpt runs 8 epochs with 100/100/200 (SpreadsheetBench), 400/200/1400 (SearchQA), and 100/80/217 (LiveMathBench) train/val/test splits and batch sizes 20/40/20 (5/10/5 steps/epoch).
    • Dropout rate: SkillOpt uses a linear schedule warming up from 0% to 5% across epochs (max 4 atoms per scope); SkillEvolBench and ContinualSkillBench use fixed 5% masking.
    • Complexity metric & acceptance rules: C(S)C(S) is defined in Appendix A.2 (Eq. 7), and host-specific triggers and commit/acceptance rules are detailed in Appendix B (Table 12) and Appendix D.3 (SkillOpt triggers candidate-local editing on complexity growth and incorporates complexity into its regularized paired-validation gate; SkillEvolBench uses growth budgets for bounded local edits with native commit; ContinualSkillBench sets separate thresholds for CREATE-SKILL and MODIFY-SKILL).

For now, I am maintaining my score.

One of the central concerns remains. Most of the results do not include uncertainty estimates, and the estimates provided are insufficient to justify the claimed improvements. With respect to related work, the summary at the end indicates where the modifications were made. However, the authors could help the reviewer by highlighting all newly added text in blue directly in the paper.

The SpreadsheetBench ablation also leaves some uncertainty about what drives the gains. Since the native baseline retained Slow Update and Meta Skill, the comparison changes more than the two proposed regularizers.

We thank the reviewer for the follow-up and for clarifying the remaining concerns.

1. Experimental reliability and uncertainty estimates

We agree that independent learning runs are important. Across all three benchmarks, we take three steps to reduce stochasticity:

  • Repeated frozen testing: every skill state is evaluated twice on the frozen test set and averaged.
  • Repeated validation: in SkillOpt, both incumbent and candidate are evaluated twice on the full validation set before each update.
  • Three independent learning runs on SpreadsheetBench: SkillEvoReg outperforms native SkillOpt on all three seeds, raising mean delivery accuracy from 53.17% to 56.17% (+3.00 pp), final accuracy from 50.58% to 55.67% (+5.08 pp), and cutting final skill tokens by 42.2%.

Independent evolution runs are costly. The three native SpreadsheetBench runs alone took ~566M training-step tokens and >53,000 model calls. Notably, the original SkillOpt, SkillEvolBench, and ContinualSkillBench papers do not report multi-seed skill-evolution uncertainty estimates or repeated frozen testing.

We also want to clarify our core claim. Our primary goal is to control persistent skill growth without hurting downstream capability, not to claim large accuracy gains on every benchmark. Across every benchmark and run, the reductions in skill size and complexity are large and consistent—42.2% fewer final skill tokens on 3-seed SpreadsheetBench, 76.9% on SearchQA, 76.2% on LiveMathBench, and 41.2% less second-pass token growth on SkillEvolBench—along with 29.5%–56.1% lower deployment inference token usage. These effect sizes are far larger than run-to-run variance. On downstream accuracy, SkillEvoReg matches or improves upon native evolution across all runs (and improves on all three SpreadsheetBench seeds), and we interpret accuracy gains conservatively given the limited number of seeds.

2. Matched SpreadsheetBench ablation

Thank you for catching this mismatch. Our main comparison (Table 1) keeps Slow Update and Meta Skill on in native SkillOpt to stay faithful to the original framework, whereas our regularized runs turn them off to avoid conflicting post-step edits.

To isolate the two regularizers cleanly, we ran a matched unregularized baseline (Slow Update off, Meta Skill off, no regularization; two frozen test evaluations) and updated Table 4 in the revised PDF:

Variant (Slow Update & Meta Skill off)Final Test (%)Final Skill Size (chars)
Unregularized (matched baseline)59.0027.0K
Complexity-only53.7513.1K
Dropout-only57.2519.5K
SkillEvoReg (Full)59.2511.7K

(For reference, native SkillOpt with Slow Update and Meta Skill on gets 47.00% and 31.7K chars.) This matched comparison gives a clear picture:

  • Disabling Slow Update and Meta Skill accounts for much of the terminal accuracy recovery over original native SkillOpt on seed 101, but without regularization the skill still bloats to 27.0K chars.
  • Under the exact same update setup, SkillEvoReg (Full) cuts final skill size by 56.7% (27.0K → 11.7K) while keeping comparable final accuracy (59.25% vs. 59.00%).
  • Both regularizers are needed together: Complexity-only cuts size (13.1K) at the cost of accuracy (53.75%); Dropout-only preserves more accuracy (57.25%) but stays larger (19.5K); combining them recovers accuracy (59.25%) while reaching the smallest skill size (11.7K).

We retain the original native SkillOpt in Table 1 for the main comparison and use this matched comparison in Table 4.

3. Highlighting newly added text in blue

Thank you for the suggestion. We have uploaded an updated PDF with the key newly added text highlighted in blue directly in the manuscript—including the expanded Related Work (DLPO, TextReg, Trace2Skill), refined problem formulation, new baseline and multi-seed analyses, and newly added Appendix sections. We also kept the concise Summary of Revisions at the end of the main text for quick navigation.

We appreciate your careful review and constructive feedback.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We thank all three reviewers for their thoughtful and constructive feedback. We have uploaded a revised manuscript (with a blue Summary of Revisions at the end of the main text) that aligns the problem formulation around structural accumulation and semantic specialization, streamlines the framework around training-time skill dropout and complexity-aware local regularization, and substantially strengthens the empirical evidence.

Our revision centers on three updates:

  1. We removed CCV (a difficult, empirically driven decision): Following the reviewers' questions on Causal Counterexample Validation (CCV), we conducted extensive follow-up experiments and a comprehensive audit of the archived runs before deciding to remove CCV. Three empirical findings drove this decision:
    • Strict triggering conditions at prohibitive token cost: Because a probe must pass source qualification, executable generation, and paired incumbent/candidate validation, CCV yields very few persistent repairs across evaluated trajectories while incurring heavy token and rollout overhead (orders of magnitude larger than local editing).
    • Unreliable correctness of generated counterexamples: More critically, automatically perturbed tasks cannot reliably guarantee reference-answer validity after input modification (e.g., invalid gold cells in SpreadsheetBench) or clean causal attribution. This flaw is fatal for a persistent skill regularizer: repairing against a flawed counterexample or misattributed failure risks writing spurious instructions back and further polluting the persistent skill.
    • Redundancy and coverage by Dropout and Complexity: In follow-up checks, CCV triggered somewhat more often when run alone (though still infrequently), whereas its trigger frequency dropped further once dropout and complexity regularization were active—because those two stages already suppress many brittle, over-specialized edits before behavioral probing is invoked.
    • Balancing reliability, skill safety, and cost-effectiveness, we decided to remove CCV and focus SkillEvoReg on training-time skill dropout and complexity-aware local regularization. Logically, behavioral regressions rarely arise in isolation: they stem either from candidate updates co-adapting to narrow existing instructions or from new rules colliding with and overriding previously working guidance. By intervening upstream at both points—perturbing skill context during update generation so brittle, context-dependent edits are less likely to form, and consolidating candidate changes against related historical atoms before commitment to resolve conflicts and generalize narrow rules—these two mechanisms directly prevent many of the regressions CCV was designed to catch post hoc, at a fraction of the cost. Note that in the main SkillOpt and ContinualSkillBench runs, CCV checks made zero persistent changes to the skill state or acceptance outcomes, so those trajectories already reflect the two retained regularizers and did not need to be re-run.
  2. Learning-run stability and objective (Appendix A.4): SkillEvoReg is designed to control persistent skill-state growth and preserve generalization across repeated updates, with downstream accuracy gains as an additional benefit. Adding two independent SpreadsheetBench learning seeds (202 and 303) to seed 101 yields three-seed averages of 56.17% vs. 53.17% delivery accuracy (+3.00 pp), 55.67% vs. 50.58% terminal accuracy (+5.08 pp), and 42.2% fewer final skill tokens, outperforming the native baseline on all three seeds.
  3. External baselines & direct local-editing cost (Section 5.2 Table 1, Appendix A.3 & C.5): We added comparisons against TextReg (adapted) and two SkillAdam protocols (native-protocol and SkillOpt-aligned) across SpreadsheetBench, SearchQA, and LiveMathBench. SkillEvoReg achieves the highest delivery accuracy on every task (58.50% / 81.14% / 35.02%) while maintaining compact skills. Across five SkillOpt runs, local editing incurs only 43–86 editor calls (0.20–0.41% of recorded native training-step tokens).

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.