- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SkillEvoReg treats repeated skill updates as a learning process that can overfit, and adds three regularizers around an existing skill updater. Skill dropout hides part of the current skill while the updater generates an edit. Complexity-aware local regularization merges, rewrites, or deletes newly added content when the skill grows too much. Causal counterexample validation (CCV) builds a targeted variant of a training task and repairs the edit if the old skill succeeds on it while the new skill fails. The method is applied to SkillOpt, SkillEvolBench, and ContinualSkillBench, where it produces much smaller skills with comparable or better performance in most settings.
Critical strengths
S1. The paper identifies a real problem in repeated skill evolution: updates learned from a few recent trajectories accumulate and can hurt later behavior. The motivating study makes this concrete. On SpreadsheetBench, transfer accuracy peaks at epoch 4 and then falls while IID accuracy keeps rising and the skill grows to 23.6 times its initial length.
S2. The regularizers consistently make skills more compact. Skill size drops sharply in all three settings, for example from 6,060 to 2,341 tokens on SpreadsheetBench, while performance stays comparable or better in most settings.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The method is less general than claimed. The paper presents SkillEvoReg as a general framework that can wrap any native updater, but each integration is customized. The paper itself states that the three integrations do not share one implementation and differ in skill representation, complexity handling, CCV case construction, repair scope, and final candidate handling. What is shared is mainly three high-level principles. Applying them to a new system would require redesigning these components, which limits the value of SkillEvoReg as a general framework.
Questions for authors
Q1. In every setting, SkillEvoReg is compared only with the same native updater without regularization. Please compare with more baselines, for example the methods named in the related work that also guard against brittle skill updates, such as SkillAdam and Trace2Skill.
Q2. The regularizers add extra LLM calls and evaluations during training, such as local editing, attack generation, and running both the old and the new skill on each attacked case. Given the performance gains, is this extra cost worthwhile?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer dAJK (2/2)
Q2. Training-time computational overhead and whether the cost is worthwhile
We agree that training cost must be weighed against the gains—in fact, this consideration motivated removing CCV (Item 1 of our General Response), whose probe generation and paired evaluations incurred substantial token overhead for very few verified repairs.
For the two retained regularizers (summarized in Item 3 of our General Response), skill-atom masking and restoration are deterministic local text operations with no dedicated model calls or task-validation rollouts. Additional model calls occur when dropout reconciliation or complexity growth triggers candidate-local editing (with shared calls counted once). As reported in Appendix C.5, across five SkillOpt runs, the local editor recorded 43–86 calls per run, and its direct local-editing token cost amounted to 0.20–0.41% of recorded native training-step tokens:
| SkillOpt Run | Recorded Native Training-Step Tokens | Local Editor Calls | Local Editor Tokens | Direct Local-Editing Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spreadsheet (seed 101) | 183,712,997 | 43 | 386,603 | 0.21% |
| Spreadsheet (seed 202) | 204,106,808 | 43 | 408,923 | 0.20% |
| Spreadsheet (seed 303) | 178,227,135 | 45 | 388,238 | 0.22% |
| SearchQA (seed 101) | 440,878,838 | 86 | 891,779 | 0.20% |
| LiveMath (seed 101) | 111,324,861 | 44 | 451,904 | 0.41% |
On SkillOpt, the local editor accounts for only 0.20–0.41% of recorded native training-step tokens (with zero extra validation rollouts). Across those same SkillOpt benchmarks, the full two-component SkillEvoReg framework reduces three-seed SpreadsheetBench final skill tokens by 42.2% while improving mean delivery accuracy by +3.00 pp and terminal accuracy by +5.08 pp, and cuts final skill tokens on SearchQA and LiveMathBench by 76.9% and 76.2%. Separately at deployment time, the resulting compact skills reduce frozen-evaluation token usage by 29.5–56.1% on the three SkillOpt tasks (Appendix C.4).
Thank you for the detailed response and revisions. My remaining concern is that the remaining mechanism after removing CCV still lacks sufficient justification as a general framework, since both skill dropout and local complexity editing still depend heavily on benchmark-specific rules and interfaces, so I will maintain my current assessment.
Thank you for the follow-up. We agree that framework-specific adaptation is necessary, and we appreciate the reviewer's concern about generality.
A useful analogy is neural-network regularization: dropout and weight regularization are general methods, although their implementations vary across neural architectures (e.g., MLP, CNN, GNN), much as skill-evolution frameworks differ in their representations and update procedures.
Similarly, SkillEvoReg applies the same two regularization mechanisms across different skill-evolution frameworks, with adaptations mainly in skill representations and native update interfaces.
We view this as evidence of methodological generality, while recognizing that SkillEvoReg is not yet a plug-and-play solution for arbitrary systems.
Response to Reviewer dAJK (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the sharp critique regarding framework generality, external baselines, and training-time computational cost. These points directly shaped our revision.
W1. What is shared across the three implementations vs. what is host-specific?
The reviewer is right that a single unmodified software wrapper cannot attach directly to every skill-evolution system without customization. In the revision (Section 4.4, Appendix B Table 12, and Appendix D), we replace any implication of a universal plug-and-play implementation with a more accurate characterization: a shared two-stage regularization design with host-specific implementations at the update boundary.
What is shared is the two-stage regularization design:
{NOOP, MERGE, REWRITE, DELETE}(Algorithm 2).What is host-specific reflects genuine semantic differences across updaters (Appendix B Table 12 & Appendix D.3): SkillOpt operates over ranked document edits and incorporates complexity into its regularized paired-validation gate; SkillEvolBench operates over family-level library patches with growth-budgeted local edits and native commit; ContinualSkillBench operates over
CREATE-SKILL/MODIFY-SKILLdirectory snapshots with separate absolute and relative complexity thresholds.Q1. Comparison with stronger baselines (TextReg, SkillAdam, Trace2Skill)
We added empirical comparisons against TextReg (adapted) and two SkillAdam protocols across all three SkillOpt tasks (Section 5.2 Table 1, Appendix A.2 & A.3; see also Item 3 of our General Response):
On delivery accuracy, SkillEvoReg ranks first on all three tasks (58.50% / 81.14% / 35.02% on SpreadsheetBench / SearchQA / LiveMathBench), outperforming TextReg (51.50% / 79.43% / 34.56%) as well as native-protocol SkillAdam (45.00% / 80.25% / 27.88%) and adapted SkillAdam (44.00% / 80.86% / 26.73%). Notably, while TextReg and SkillAdam often produce shorter texts, SkillAdam drops sharply on SpreadsheetBench and LiveMathBench, and TextReg trails on SpreadsheetBench (−7.00 pp)—illustrating that minimizing length alone does not preserve downstream capability.
We also expanded our discussion of Trace2Skill in Related Work (Section 2 & Appendix G): Trace2Skill focuses on hierarchically consolidating trajectory lessons to construct reusable skills, which is complementary to regularizing repeated updates of an already persistent skill state.