- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors test LLMs' introspection capability. They quantize LLM weights and test if the LLMs can recognize their own quantization. The authors showed that LLMs cannot reliably identify their own quantization state in a single pass. Even when LLMs are trained to predict the quantization state (via LoRA), the prediction performance does not generalize to quantization states induced by untrained methods.
Critical strengths
The clear strength is the novelty of the problem formulation. The idea of 'tractably analyzing LLMs' introspection capability using weight quantization' is direct, simple, and intuitive. The choice was clever because, by using different train/test quantization methods, the authors could test the generalization capability of LLMs trained for introspection.
Critical weaknesses
Concern 1. Limited empirical breadth and questionable generalizability.
- The choice to use quantization to test introspection capability has some advantages (as I stated in the strengths section). But I am not sure how the findings may generalize to broader statements about LLMs' general introspection capability. That is, while quantized state prediction could be one of the rigorous approaches to study introspection, it may not be a 'representative' or 'practical' one. To me, this feels more like a synthetic study for proof-of-concept, so without a wider empirical breadth (e.g., testing a wider variety of LLM weight interventions), I remain unconvinced about the conclusion's generalization to more useful and practical cases.
Concern 2. Limited impact.
- Thus, assuming a conservative interpretation of the findings, I think the paper's conclusion has limited significance.
- Does it provide significant practical or theoretical insight about LLM introspection? Does it identify significant issues in the current research directions? Does it provide a significant new direction in LLM introspection research? In my understanding, the answers to all three questions seem to be negative.
Questions for authors
None
8 comments
Author Response (2/3) to Reviewer Xn49
Generalization beyond quantization
>W1
Without a wider empirical breadth (e.g., testing a wider variety of LLM weight interventions), I remain unconvinced about the conclusion's generalization to more useful and practical cases.
We agree that evaluating quantization alone cannot rule out the possibility that our findings are specific to quantization. To address this, we conducted additional experiments with Gaussian weight additive noise and model scaling (Appendix A).
1. Weight additive noise
Settings. We added Gaussian noise, matched in magnitude to 8-bit and 4-bit RTN quantization, to the model weights across three random seeds, creating six modified models in total.
Experiment. We applied the same self-report (Section 2.1) and linear probing (Section 3.2) protocols.
Results. For weight modifications other than quantization, the model does not spontaneously report the modification, while internal representations still change in a way that can be classified with high accuracy (Figure 10, 11). Furthermore, when we trained the linear probe on two noise seeds and evaluated it on the unseen third seed, classification accuracy remained at chance level.
Insights. The gap between detectability in internal representation and blindness of self-report is not limited to quantization and also appears under different weight perturbations.
As noted in the limitations (l.534, l.1591), extending the analysis to other computational substrate degradation, such as layer removal and LoRA adaptation, remains future work.
2. Model Scaling
Settings. To examine generalization to larger models, we added self-report experiments on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-14B, in addition to the existing Qwen3-8B and Qwen3-32B (Appendix E).
Results. Across the 4B to 32B range we evaluated, we did not observe a consistent improvement in the ability to recognize quantization as model size increases.
We believe these additional experiments make the scope and limitation of our findings clearer than in the original submission.
Author Response (3/3) to Reviewer Xn49
Practical and theoretical significance
>W2
assuming a conservative interpretation of the findings, I think the paper's conclusion has limited significance
Thank you for raising the question of practical and theoretical significance. We address the three questions in turn.
>W2.1
Does it provide significant practical or theoretical insight about LLM introspection?
Internal-state distance correlates with downstream task performance.
Our analysis suggests that the internal representations carry information beyond a simple classification boundary.
Finding. As detailed in Section 3.4 and Appendix C, cosine distance between the internal states of quantized and unquantized models tracks downstream performance degradation. The Spearman's rank correlation between this distance and the accuracy drop on MMLU-Pro exceeds 0.84 for all four evaluated models.
Insights. This indicates that the internal fingerprints of quantization reflect the severity of the computational degradation, not merely an implementation artifact. Theoretically, this points to a gap between what the model's internals encode and what the model can report about them, which is the central subject of our analysis.
Table 1: Spearman's rank correlation between internal-state distance and task performance
| Model | MMLU-Pro | BBH-ZeroShot |
|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-8B | 0.84 | 0.14 |
| Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct | 0.94 | 0.78 |
| Gemma-3-27B-IT | 1.00 | 0.94 |
| Qwen3-32B | 0.89 | 0.60 |
>W2.2
Does it identify significant issues in the current research directions?
Our results raise three questions that we believe are important for the field.
-
Gap of awareness between activation and weights intervention: Models can detect transient, inference-time activation interventions in prior work [1], yet they fail to notice persistent, global modifications to their weights. As noted at limitation (l.536, l.1582-1587), we did not evaluate models above 32B parameters. However, the failure appears already in Gemma-3-27B-IT [1]. Understanding why it occurs is an open problem.
-
Difficulty in verbalization: Internal states can differ between model variants while the model's self-report remains unchanged. Similar gaps between internal knowledge and verbal report have been observed in other settings, such as unfaithful chain-of-thought explanations [1] and latent knowledge that linear probes can recover but the model does not state [2]. Why LLMs struggle to verbalize their internal states remains an open question.
-
Limitation of label mapping: Our shared LoRA experiments in Section 5 show that training a model to read out fingerprints with label supervision maps specific fingerprints to labels without acquiring the concept of quantization. This limitation implies that label-based introspection training is insufficient, and that methods which encourage the model to reason about its own state may be needed.
W2.3
Does it provide a significant new direction in LLM introspection research?
-
Proposed a new axis of introspection: We propose awareness of computational substrate degradation as a new axis of introspection, complementary to self-knowledge, awareness of evaluation context, and detection of intervention to internal states. This axis naturally extends to questions such as whether a model can recognize its own layer removal or LoRA adaptation.
-
Alignment faking in quantization: As noted at discussion (l.504-511), prior work has studied alignment faking, in which a model behaves differently when it think it is being evaluated [3]. Our findings raise a related but more speculative question: whether a model's behavior depends on its computational state, for example, whether it behaves differently only when quantized. We do not have evidence for such an effect, but we believe it deserves investigation as models and deployment practices evolve.
Reference:
[1] Turpin et al., "Language Models Don't Always Say What They Think: Unfaithful Explanations in Chain-of-Thought Prompting", NeurIPS2023.
[2] Burns et al., "Discovering Latent Knowledge in Language Models Without Supervision", ICLR2023.
[3] Greenblatt et al., "Alignment faking in large language models".
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer’s insightful feedback. Please let us know if our responses resolve your concerns or if additional clarification is required.
Author Response (1/3) to Reviewer Xn49
Thank you for your constructive feedback. Please let us know if our responses in the following address your concerns.
We thank the reviewer for raising these important questions about the generalizability and significance of our work.
We revised the paper based on the reviewers' concerns, and the major edit was highlighted with coloring red. In particular, please see Section 3.4 and Appendix A, C, E.
Generalizability toward general introspection capability
>W.1
Thank you for this sharp observation
1. Clarification about the position of this research
First, we want to clarify that this study does not claim to represent LLMs' general introspection capability through awareness of quantization. Rather, it systematically investigates a new axis of introspection that has not been examined in prior work: whether a model can recognize persistent changes to its own computational substrate.
Prior work on LLM introspection has mainly studied:
The axis we study differs from these: whether a model can notice when persistent changes have been made to its weights, analogous to brain damage. Detecting transient activation interventions at inference time does not imply that a model can detect persistent, global modifications to its weights. Thus, transient activation interventions and persistent weight interventions should be considered seperately.
2. Clarification of the choice of quantization
We also want to clarify that we chose quantization not merely because it is and artificial perturbation. Our reasons are as follows:
Following your suggestion, we clarified the reasons for choosing quantization in the revision (l.72-74 and Appendix A).
Reference:
[1] Kadavath et al., "Language Models (Mostly) Know What They Know".
[2] Shenoy et al., "Introspection Adapters: Training LLMs to Report Their Learned Behaviors", ICML2026.
[3] Needham et al., "Large Language Models Often Know When They Are Being Evaluated".
[4] Lindsey et al., "Emergent Introspective Awareness in Large Language Models".
[5] Ajibode et al., "Towards semantic versioning of open pre-trained language model releases on hugging face", Empirical Software Engineering.