- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
According to this paper, their contribution seems to be about improving the steering literature and the identification of a geometric score. However, the contributions are very obscure and hard to understand and summarize.
Critical strengths
N/A
Critical weaknesses
I have significant concerns about the overall presentation, clarity, significance and completeness of this manuscript. Several sections appear insufficiently proofread, which substantially affects the readability and makes it difficult to properly assess the scientific contributions.
First, the abstract is poorly structured and lacks clarity. In particular, I find the emphasis on numerical results somewhat unusual, especially given that the broader context and motivation are not clearly established. An abstract should provide a concise and self-contained overview of the work, including the context, the problem being addressed, the main challenges, and the proposed approach. Unfortunately, the current abstract does not adequately fulfill these objectives. Similar issues arise in the outline of contributions, which remain difficult to identify and understand. A reader should be able to clearly identify the research question, its motivation, and the authors' proposed contributions, but this is not achieved in the current manuscript.
Second, the submission appears to be incomplete, as the appendix is missing despite being explicitly referenced throughout the paper. For instance, the authors write:
"This tokenization split affects three of the ten models (both Llama-2 variants and Mistral, Appendix B.1; Table 6) and survives major tokenizer-library updates, confirming it as a durable property rather than a temporary artifact (Appendix A.1)." The absence of the referenced appendix makes it impossible to verify these claims and assess the supporting evidence. This is a major concerning issue for a submission at ICLR 2027.
Third, the related works, as written, lack clarity. Previous approaches are not sufficiently introduced, contextualized, or referenced, making it difficult to understand how the proposed work relates to the existing literature and what distinguishes its contributions from prior research.
Furthermore, the mathematical definitions are unclear and seem incomplete.
More generally, the manuscript lacks a clear and coherent narrative. The different sections do not seem to follow a well-defined line of reasoning, and it is often difficult to understand how the arguments connect or where the authors intend to lead the reader. This significantly limits the accessibility of the paper and the reader's ability to evaluate its scientific relevance.
Finally, the manuscript gives the impression of having been written very fast or with substantial assistance from AI-generated content. I want to emphasize that I am not suggesting that this was necessarily the case, but rather that this is the impression perceived as a reader, particularly given the lack of clarity, coherence, and careful proofreading throughout the paper. A clear example is the conclusion which is very hard to understand:
"The control the steering literature uses against answer-order bias protects the mean but gives no persample guarantee. Measured as directions rather than as behavioral variance, the standard construction imposes two near-orthogonal surface axes; therefore, the field’s rank-one correction removes only half of this structure: the other half remains decodable at ceiling on every model and costs 0.037 of anti-steerability on Llama-2-7B, while without any correction a standard cluster-then-route primitive recovers the letter on all 48,320 clusterings. How far these axes reach the deployed vector is governed by representational resolution. The resulting geometry is a valuable signal but not a reliable objective, and selective steering is the method that distinction licenses."
Overall, I strongly recommend rejection. In its current form, I believe the manuscript falls substantially below the standards expected for publication at a major machine learning conference such as ICLR. The issues outlined above are not only editorial: the lack of clarity, incomplete supplementary material, and insufficient positioning with respect to prior work make it particularly difficult to properly assess the validity, significance, and novelty of the proposed contributions.
Questions for authors
N/A