- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors used Hodgkin-Huxley model as a test-bed to see if learned model that is able to predict observables can find the physically meaningful latent states. The motivation is clear and relevant, and the test case is a good one but the current presentation is hard to follow for me.
Critical strengths
- The Hodgkin-Huxley model is one of the most successful story in modeling that find the mechanism. So it is a great idea to see if our current data-driven approach can reproduce this success.
Critical weaknesses
- The presentation is hard to follow for me. It contains many forward references and unexplained notations. I struggled to understand the source of quite some equations
- I am unsure about the main models being tested and how they connect back to successfully track back HH.
Questions for authors
Questions
- What is in equation 3? The notations should be better explained.
- I don't get where eq.4 is from. I thought, from Fig. 2 's are learned and there is no a priori assumptions about the temporal dynamics. Then why there is a fixed updating equation for the learned latent?
- How much physical assumptions are put in the learned model?
Some requests
- I think eq.1-2 can be explained better for a human reader. The notations should be explained by their physical meanings then interpreted as e.g., command.
- The paragraph starting line 198 is confusing. Many of the words have specific meanings like gates/trajectories etc. but was not clear when the reader is here. This often happens when using AI tools iteratively as it sees the later part of the paper. But that is not the case for a reader yet.