- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CAGE, a two-stage framework for generating inline citations in long-form question answering. A Cognitive Attribution Map Induction Model (CMI) first constructs support subgraphs linking answer units to retrieved documents. A Structured Citation Reasoning Model (SCR) then generates an answer with citations guided by these assignments. The authors use LLM-generated and validated supervision to train the two components. Experiments on ASQA, ELI5, and ExpertQA report improvements in aggregate TRUST scores, particularly citation groundedness. Model-scale analyses, structural ablations, and experiments with proprietary generators provide further evidence of the framework's effectiveness and applicability across model backbones.
Critical strengths
S1. Strong empirical performance. The framework achieves competitive aggregate results across several datasets and model scales, with substantial improvements in citation groundedness. The structural ablations also provide evidence that explicit support assignments contribute beyond document selection and textual descriptions. These findings give the proposed implementation practical value.
S2. Useful modular design. The attribution module can guide different downstream generators, including proprietary models, without fine-tuning those generators. This separation makes the method applicable when the downstream model cannot be retrained and shows that the benefit is not restricted to one model family..
Critical weaknesses
W1. Limited substantive novelty. Using a graph to organize answer units and their supporting evidence is a fairly common modeling idea. Here, the graph primarily makes answer–document assignments explicit within a two-stage generation pipeline. I acknowledge that the baseline comparisons and structural ablations demonstrate the effectiveness of this design. However, they do not clearly establish what substantive modeling advance the graph provides beyond making these relationships explicit. In particular, removing support edges changes the information available to the generator, so the ablation does not isolate the graph representation from the support assignments it encodes. The same-backbone experiments are useful, but the main results also involve a 9B attribution model and supervision synthesized by GPT-5.5. These factors may contribute to the performance gains, particularly for smaller downstream generators, and the current analysis does not sufficiently separate their effects from the contribution of the graph representation itself.
W2. Insufficient analysis of answer quality and the scope of EBO. Citation groundedness improves, but Table 2 also shows lower answer-calibration scores (EMACF1) for some generators. TRUST includes correctness and refusal behavior, yet the paper does not sufficiently explain whether these declines reflect changes in answering decisions or reduced coverage of relevant information. This leaves the claim of improved grounding without compromising response quality insufficiently supported. Figure 5 also illustrates a possible coverage limitation: D5 explicitly mentions both Rob Hall and Scott Fischer, but the induced answer units and final response omit Rob Hall.In addition, Appendix A.3 checks atomic facts against all top-5 retrieved documents jointly, whereas EBO is introduced as a claim exceeding what its cited documents justify. This evaluation measures support within the retrieved evidence pool and does not directly test support within each claim's actual citations. Although the main citation-groundedness metric provides evidence on citation quality, the additional EBO analysis does not fully substantiate the more specific interpretation. Excluding refusals and empty responses also leaves possible effects of response selection and factual coverage unresolved.
Questions for authors
Q1. Clarification of the technical contribution. Beyond making answer–evidence relationships explicit, what substantive modeling capability does the graph introduce? Which existing comparison most directly distinguishes the value of the graph representation from the support assignments it encodes? How can its contribution to the observed gains be distinguished from the capacity of the CMI model and the quality of the GPT-5.5-generated supervision? Q2. Clarification of the answer-quality trade-off. How do the authors explain the lower EMACF1 scores in Table 2 despite improved citation groundedness? Could the existing evaluation be broken down by answering behavior and coverage of relevant information to clarify whether either contributes to the decline?