- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ReMIL-Agent for whole-slide image classification and diagnostic explanation. The framework first obtains an initial prediction from an existing MIL model, then verifies the morphological evidence supporting that prediction and revises it only when sufficient evidence supports an alternative diagnosis. It adopts a multi-agent cascade consisting of a Predictor, a knowledge-grounded Verifier, and a planner-guided Reviewer, and evaluates the framework on multiple WSI classification benchmarks.
Critical strengths
- Clear motivation and a coherent verification framework. The paper addresses the problem that additional visual exploration may not resolve unreliable morphological observations in agentic pathology systems. It introduces knowledge-grounded Defender–Critic verification, cross-scale consistency checks, and conservative prediction revision. These components form a coherent workflow centered on evidence reliability, while structured evidence records improve the traceability of the diagnostic process.
- Consistent performance improvements. Without retraining the underlying models, the framework improves both ABMIL and Flow-MIL on all six TCGA subtyping tasks and provides an additional improvement on CAMELYON16.
Critical weaknesses
- The evaluation does not fully establish the added value of the multi-agent design. The quantitative evaluation is limited to classification tasks, while evidence reliability, diagnostic report quality, and auditability are primarily illustrated through case studies. Although the component ablations provide useful evidence, it remains unclear whether the full multi-agent architecture is necessary compared with simpler evidence aggregation or prediction correction approaches. More direct evaluation of the claimed verification benefits would strengthen the contribution.
- The accuracy–efficiency evaluation is incomplete. The classification comparisons include MIL, MLLM, and agent-based methods, but the runtime comparison is limited to PathAgent on two datasets. Although stage-wise timings are provided, the paper does not present a comprehensive comparison of accuracy and computational cost against the original MIL predictors and simpler correction pipelines under matched conditions.
Questions for authors
Can the authors provide a broader accuracy–runtime comparison that includes the original MIL predictors and additional agent-based baselines? Please clarify whether offline feature extraction and preprocessing costs are included consistently in the reported timings.