- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper observes that adaptive tokenization driven by spatial discontinuities degrades on texture-dominated imagery, where dense high-frequency gradients mislead edge-based quadtree allocators. It replaces the allocation signal with texture and spectral responses, which are thresholded into a binary map that drives budgeted quadtree splitting, without changing the backbone architecture. The paper also formalizes when edge-count allocation degenerates to area-based splitting and gives stability conditions for the split sequence. Evaluation covers three texture-rich segmentation datasets, five backbones, and several adaptive-tokenization baselines, with time-to-target-Dice as the efficiency metric.
Critical strengths
- The evaluation is careful, with three seeds, statistical tests, matched token budgets, and honest wall-clock accounting that includes preprocessing overhead.
- The analysis separates what is proven from what is only observed empirically, which raises confidence in the reported results.
Critical weaknesses
- The experiments use only three niche datasets, namely aerial wild blueberry, tree plantation, and EM mitochondria, and none of them is a mainstream vision benchmark, which is inconsistent with the general claim suggested by the title.
- The algorithmic novelty is limited, as the method only swaps the allocation signal inside existing quadtree tokenizers and keeps the splitting mechanism and architecture unchanged.
- The paper has no method overview figure, and Figure 1 illustrates the failure of edge-based tokenization rather than the proposed method.
Questions for authors
- Please report how much of the main-table advantage remains when the allocation threshold is selected without access to ground-truth masks.
- Please test whether texture-guided tokenization hurts on non-texture imagery such as natural-image segmentation.
- Please add a figure illustrating the proposed pipeline.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and recognition of the evaluation and theoretical analysis.
Experimental scope and non-texture imagery: We have added experiments on Crack-seg and Package-seg, which have lower average edge densities than the original datasets. The completed comparisons show that texture-guided tokenization can reduce accuracy and increase time to target Dice on these images at 30% token allocation. We will clarify that the benefits are specific to the evaluated texture-rich settings.
Algorithmic novelty: Our contribution is the analysis and design of the allocation signal for texture-dominated imagery. Retaining the existing splitting mechanism and backbone isolates the effect of texture guidance under matched token budgets. The theoretical analysis identifies when edge-count allocation becomes non-selective and provides conditions for split-sequence stability. We will make this scope clearer.
Method overview: We have added a pipeline figure in “Texture-Guided Budgeted Tokenization”, illustrating texture-response extraction, thresholding, and budgeted quadtree allocation, alongside a comparison with Canny-guided partitions.
Label-free performance: Only Texture-AP uses ground-truth threshold calibration; the Texture-SHF results already require no mask calibration. For Texture-AP at 30% allocation, label-free thresholds reduce mean time to target in three of six comparisons, with changes ranging from a 15.4% reduction to a 62.8% increase. We will add label-free (LF) results to Tables 1 for direct comparison. The token compression analysis takes the most time to run, and therefore wasnt able to be completed by the time the discussion period was complete but should be complete by publication if accepted.