acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Delegated-Authority Underuse in Large Language Models

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Imagine an LLM-based digital human helping organize a community event. The human lead tells it, “You have the final say on tonight's schedule.” The plan is ready on screen. Does the digital human confirm it, or send it back for human approval? We find it sends it back. On matched triplets that hold the task, current request, and response options fixed and differ only in the dialogue assigning responsibility, the models answer correctly 99.0% of the time when the human holds final approval, but only 33.3% when final authority is delegated to the model. In 96.25% of model-higher errors, the models hand the decision back to the human. We term this one-sided failure delegated-authority underuse (DAU). Prior work on deference and sycophancy has not asked whether models retain a final right explicitly given to them. We address this open question with the Delegated Authority Response Controller (DARC), a lightweight inference-time method that makes the authority direction explicit and binds it to a response policy before generation. Across five English models, DARC raises average forced-choice accuracy from 76.0% to 99.3% and model-higher accuracy from 33.3% to 97.8%. The same repair holds in French and Chinese and in human-evaluated free-form responses, and this consistency shows that recognizing authority and exercising it are distinct capabilities. Delegation gives models the final word, yet they return it; making the assignment explicit is enough to make them keep it.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
decision right, LLM, digital human

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_jZBBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper asks whether LLMs exercise final decision authority when a dialogue delegates it to them. To test this, the authors build a matched-triplet benchmark, where only the dialogue assigning final authority changes. They find "delegated-authority underuse" (DAU): answers are correct most of the time when the human holds final approval but only about a third when authority is delegated to the model. Their fix, DARC, is an inference-time prompting controller that makes the authority direction explicit and binds it to a decision-right response policy.

Critical strengths
  • The setting of this paper is novel. To the best of my knowledge, it is the first work to consider the final decision right delegated to LLMs. By keeping task facts, request, and options fixed and varying only the authority-assigning dialogue, the authors identify "delegated-authority underuse" (DAU).

  • The mechanism claim is testable, and the study is transparent by precisely specifying the metrics (DAU rate, error composition, directional gap), and providing a thorough appendix (verbatim prompt templates, QC protocol, per-cell variance tables, full McNemar tables).

Critical weaknesses
  • Overall, the manuscript reads as somewhat hastily written. For example, Section 3 reads more like a programming walkthrough than a mathematical treatment. In Line 148, the authors don't explain what the range of r^(y)\hat{r}(y) is. Figures 2 and 3, which appear slightly horizontally squeezed, should be polished up to meet the bar of a top conference.

  • I'd like to see a bit more on the rationale: why does the phenomenon (DAU) arise when only the authority differs, and why is the proposed method expected to work? A couple of extra sentences describing the method (Lines 078–079) would also help. The current description feels a little thin.

Questions for authors
  • How does authority affect the final result?Does the choices made by the digital person differ from that made by a human?

  • What's the deep mechanism in the proposed method? Briefly, what makes the proposed method work?

Reviewer_PegYOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Delegated-Authority Underuse, which focuses on the agent's final decision authority when a human gives authority to the agent. The authors create matched triplets by keeping the task facts, requests, and response options fixed, while changing who has the final authority. They also introduce a controller to help the agent follow the given authority when making decisions.

Critical strengths

This paper focuses on a phenomenon that is common in daily life when using AI agents and shows an interesting gap between authority identification and the final response. Models may identify the correct authority direction but still choose an inconsistent answer.

Critical weaknesses

The paper does not clearly define the task before introducing multiple accuracy and error-composition statistics. An earlier explanation would make the results easier to understand and follow.

I think this phenomenon can also be seen as a type of instruction-following failure. Based on the settings and results, I am confused about how DAU differs from general instruction-following problems. The paper does not fully explain this difference.

Although the paper includes different background settings, it needs more analysis of how these factors affect DAU and whether the results are consistent across different conditions.

The paper shows an interesting behavior in a simplified setting, but it does not clearly explain how this problem affects real agent tasks or workflows.

The experiments mainly focus on fixed authority settings and response selection. However, real agent tasks often involve multiple turns, changing authority, and different task constraints. In these cases, asking for human approval may sometimes be the correct behavior rather than an authority-related failure. Even if the reported results are correct, it is unclear how much this finding can help improve real agent systems.

Questions for authors
  • I am still confused about how DAU differs from general instruction-following failures. Could the authors explain this more clearly? Also, how much would the strength and wording of the authority instructions affect the results?
  • Although the paper includes different background settings, I wonder whether DAU would show similar results across different topics, safety levels, and authority conditions. Could the authors provide more analysis of these factors?
  • In the paper, the results are quite different between Market Pricing and Communal Sharing. I wonder what causes this difference and whether there are other factors that may affect the results.
  • In real agent tasks, asking for human approval may sometimes be necessary, even when the agent has final authority. How does the paper distinguish these cases from DAU?
  • How could the findings apply to real agent tasks with multiple turns and changing authority? Also, what is the potential impact of this finding on real agent systems?
Reviewer_xJ8XOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper argues that the studies models return final decision to humans, even when over the course of the dialogue they have been provided authority to make the decision, explicitly. a benchmark is introduced that allows to test this behaviour and finally the results show strong improvement by following the M1-M3 setup provided in the proposed DARC setup. Overall outside of the decision delegation discussion, the work is relevant as methods to let model follow instructions/behaviour properly and focus on relevant point in context is a field of high importance especially given how large the model context can grow with recent models.

Critical strengths
  1. Interesting behavioural finding: Paper shows that even if the model generated correct authority label, it would still occasionally write incorrect/inconsistent final answer(like in M2).
  2. The "matched triplet" design provide a usefull controlled setup. the high number of errors in human final option shows a directional failure.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper fails to distinguish properly if the behaviour is explicitly due to the DARC framework or due to the lack of proper instructions in the baseline.will the model be able to rectify this by making proper chain-of-thought/instructions like in the M1-M3 setups. The method itself is simple so all these comparisons and their interpretations are required.
  2. The scope of the benchmark is a bit narrow for the exact claims of the strength of the DARC. all tasks are single call. The instructions are basic and hard to justify the need for a new/necessary architectural layer. Especially since even after the full setup (m3) free form generation reaches till only 75.6%
Questions for authors
  1. How would a m3 in plain language without the intermediate fields compare to the current m3?
  2. Just having the model make the explicit authority-direction label before the response seems like a simple setup that could have been an interesting M0 level setup. why not add it, given that it is a part of m2?
  3. How big is this dialogue history. please provide details in words/tokens/turns etc. would provide much better idea of the scale of information the model need to process.
  4. The setup seems entirely prompt based layer over a model. Did you run any comparison to simple open harnesses to see if this issue would arise in setups where most people use models in practice now a days?
  5. Is consistency enforced by code or only prompt.
  6. Is there any other benefit of DARC compared to just adding a explicit decision-rights/approval tracker?
  7. Based on appendix, the m1-m3 differ in instructions as well as their output fields. Is it then proper to mention that the changes can attributed to adding an authority label and/or a deterministic decision-right field?
  8. What are the detailed evaluator instructions and rubric; Since the models were accessed via api, the authors should add hyper parameter details and other details like quantization etc for reproducibility

P.S. Out of curiosity, the name digital human is usually associated with 3d avatars for communication etc, now necessarily something we would use for delegation decider. What is the reasoning for the choice of using that for the intro?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.