- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tackles multi-output Gaussian processes in high-dimensional outputs. The idea presented in the paper hinges on representing each output as a linear-Gaussian decoding of a low-dimensional latent state drawn from a GP prior over the inputs. The authors demonstrate their method in toy examples as well as in biomedical optics and climate modelling for exoplanets.
Critical strengths
The most substantive strength of the paper is the rather simple idea combined with an interesting example study in exoplanet climate modelling. The supplement also contained further analysis and results about this, which I found interesting. To be frank, the paper might even be better received if it would be framed as an application paper in modelling the exoplanet data. However, then ICLR would probably not be the most impactful/sensible venue for such a study.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is nice overall, but considering the multitude of models already proposed in this space, I'm not fully convinced that the methodology alone in the paper makes it meet the bar for acceptance.
Questions for authors
-
In addition to the simulation study and the demonstrations, did you also run this on low-dimensional example cases from other multi-output GP papers to gain some insights?
-
The joint optimization problem is probably quite non-convex. In the experiments, did you have issues with the optimisation and hyperparameter sensitivity?
3 comments
Thank you for your reply. Your plan for the intended changes to the manuscript appears like a good plan.
Thank you - we'd be be very happy if you think this might raise the papers informativeness score.
Response to Reviewer EgsM
Thank you for the careful review and honesty on framing.
On novelty/framing.
It's true that this space holds many models; however, we do think our conception provides interesting points of novelty, although we agree it's less so in providing a new model class. In light of your comments (and another reviewer), we think that our framing didn't make our contributions clear enough and invited reading it as mainly a new model class.
We intend to reorder the introduction so that we first note how this model arises as a simplifying special case (albeit with modifications) of existing models and state our contributions more clearly (as below), before elaborating in Section 2.
We kept the paper centred on the methodology because the same construction applies to other emulation problems (although yes a lot of the practical work was domain (exoclimate) oriented).
On questions.