- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes masked UOT for fusing CT and clinical features with partially missing tokens. Unavailable tokens are excluded from the transport support, and patient-specific marginal priors are generated through masked softmax. The method uses entropy-regularized UOT with KL marginal penalties, solved by generalized Sinkhorn iterations, for bidirectional feature transfer. The learned priors are also used for final pooling, with an optional patient-level symmetric InfoNCE loss. Experiments on institutional and LUNG1 cohorts evaluate binary classification of recorded alive/deceased status, rather than censored time-to-event survival prediction.
Critical strengths
-
The method is technically well developed.
-
The experiments cover several aspects of the method.
-
The limitations are clearly acknowledged.
Critical weaknesses
-
Under the same encoders, fusion structure, pooling, masks, and training budget, how does the method compare with masked balanced OT, unmasked UOT, uniform-marginal masked UOT, and learned pooling without UOT?
-
How were the 25%, 50%, and 75% availability levels in Figure 2 generated? In the institutional cohort, 35.8% of tumors are classified as “non-lung primary,” including sarcoma and melanoma. What are the exact inclusion criteria? Could the authors also report results for a lung-only subgroup?
-
Are labels in the institutional cohort defined at the patient level or the session level? If a patient has multiple sessions, does this patient contribute repeatedly to the session-level metrics? Please also report results aggregated at the patient level.
-
In LUNG1, does the positive class correspond to deceased patients? Given the prevalence of approximately 88.2%, how much does the reported Average Precision (AP) improve over the no-skill baseline? The AUC of MASKED-UOT on LUNG1 is only around 0.60, and contrastive learning appears to reduce performance with both backbones. Should contrastive learning be considered an essential component, or an optional module whose benefit depends on the configuration?
-
Could the authors provide mask-only, learned-prior-only, UOT-only, and no-transport ablations to separate the contributions of availability masking, learned pooling, and UOT marginal relaxation?
Questions for authors
1.Can the authors clarify the individual contributions of masking, learned priors, and UOT?
2.Are the results stable across different random masks?
3.Can the authors clarify the cohort inclusion criteria and provide patient-level and lung-only results?
4.How should the LUNG1 results and the role of contrastive learning be interpreted?
Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses for details.