- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper frames the problem of self-improving agents as selecting a subset of candidate modifications under a cost budget and a variance constraint, formulated as a quadratic mean–variance knapsack problem. Because all live LLM-agent experiments failed or were excluded after a post-lock code audit, the submission reads like an automated pre-registration audit report and is presented by the authors solely as a 'synthetic failure analysis of measurement assumptions' on a 12-variable Gaussian generator.
Critical strengths
I could not found any strenghts apart the voluntiees of the author to public a negative result not hiding neither creating false results on their research.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is essentially unreadable. I tried to follow it, but starting from the introduction the motivation itself is not clear, stated minimally, because the results and content itself of the paper as not validate motivation that could explain them. A part from the poor formalization of the problem, i found not acceptable the structure of the experimental part, as a list of ai generated comments, that implicitly pointed out to files, present in the supplementary material, that underlines some auto-audit to the methodology that actually failed.
Questions for authors
I have no question, I invite the author to complete their work before submitting again.