- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces that there is a significant limitations among existing VLM-based pipelines for VAD where not all the video clip share the same importance contributed to the VAD task.
This paper proposes a fundamental challenge: **How can we enable VLMs to adaptively allocate computation across video segments, allowing more careful examination when needed?""
In solving this problem, this paper proposes ARIA, an adaptive reasoning framework that enhances VLMs for VAD. For segments that warrant additional examination, ARIA determines whether the uncertainty is better addressed by acquiring more visual evidence or by introducing a complementary model perspective.
Extensive experiments on UCF-Crime and XD-Violence show that ARIA improves detection and explanation quality while reducing inference cost.
Critical strengths
-
The idea is neat and reasonable. The aim of this paper proposes a key insight in VAD research area. The performance over the UCF-crime and XD-violence indicates part of the remarkable effectiveness of the proposed method.
-
The Ablation of adaptive reasoning components evaluate the effectivenss of the idea.
Critical weaknesses
-
A lot of baselines are missing such as [1] and [2] limiting the effectiveness of this paper. The number of frames per segment is not specificly organized and number of frames is not tested during the the ablation.
-
This paper indicating that the utlization of detailed frames may contributes to the better performance over VAD. However, there is a section required for systematically evaluate this phenomenon. It is possible to have a naive experiment on it?
-
The evaluated benchmarks should not just limited in UCF-crime and XD-violence.
[1]Zou S, Tian X, Wesemann L, et al. Unlocking vision-language models for video anomaly detection via fine-grained prompting[C]//2026 IEEE/CVF Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision (WACV). IEEE, 2026: 4223-4233. [2]Huang C, Wang B, Wang W, et al. Vad-r1: Towards video anomaly reasoning via perception-to-cognition chain-of-thought[J]. Advances in neural information processing systems, 2026, 38: 118486-118518.
Questions for authors
See above.
6 comments
Comment 2: How does the number of input frames affect VAD performance?
Answer: We added a controlled experiment on how the number of input frames affects video anomaly detection. The Base VLM, prompts, UCF-Crime test set, and evaluation procedure are kept unchanged, and only the number of uniformly sampled frames per segment varies. ARIA's adaptive routing and additional reasoning actions are not used.
Table 11. Effect of the number of input frames on UCF-Crime.
| Frames | AUC (%) ↑ | Segment Acc. (%) ↑ | Latency ↓ | Visual tokens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 81.27 | 73.7 | 2.45 | 512 |
| 4 | 83.73 | 79.7 | 2.76 | 1,024 |
| 8 | 85.64 | 82.2 | 3.56 | 2,048 |
| 16 | 86.44 | 80.1 | 5.23 | 4,096 |
| 32 | 85.81 | 79.2 | 9.34 | 8,192 |
Visual tokens are calculated at 256 tokens per frame. Latency is measured per segment in this fixed-frame experiment and does not directly represent the end-to-end latency of full ARIA.
AUC rises by 5.17 points from 2 to 16 frames and then drops at 32 frames, while segment accuracy peaks at 8 frames. Moving from 4 to 16 frames improves AUC by 2.71 points, but it quadruples the visual tokens and nearly doubles the latency. At 32 frames, the cost keeps growing without a further AUC gain.
Denser visual sampling can therefore improve VAD performance within a certain range, but these results do not support increasing the frame count indiscriminately for all segments. ARIA starts with fewer frames for low-cost initial inference, and then applies LOOK-MORE or COOPERATE to selected segments based on the expected correction benefit. We will report this result in the final version.
Comment 3: Can ARIA be evaluated on additional benchmarks?
Answer: Thank you for this suggestion. We added experiments on MSAD to further evaluate cross-dataset generalization. The router trained on the UCF-Crime training set is used directly, with the routing threshold kept at τ = 0.20 and no further training or MSAD-specific adaptation.
The Base VLM with 4-frame initial inference achieves 86.11% AUC on MSAD. ARIA achieves 91.49% and 91.38% in two runs, which is 5.38 and 5.27 points above the Base VLM. ARIA can therefore improve detection performance on a new dataset without retraining the router.
The revised manuscript will include the comparisons with ASK-HINT and Vad-R1, the frame configurations and both frame ablations with their computational budgets, and the MSAD experimental settings and results.
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you again for your valuable feedback. We have provided detailed responses and additional experimental results to address your concerns.
We would appreciate it if you could let us know whether our responses have addressed your main concerns, or if there are any remaining questions. We would be happy to provide further clarification during the discussion period.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Thank you for the valuable review. Our responses are addressed below.
Comment 1: Can the authors add missing baselines and evaluate the impact of different frame counts?
Answer: Thank you for this suggestion. We added comparisons with ASK-HINT [1] and Vad-R1 [2], clarified the number of frames used by each inference action, and evaluated how frame allocation affects detection performance and inference cost.
(1) Comparisons with ASK-HINT and Vad-R1.
For ASK-HINT [1], we could not find official code and therefore use the result reported in its paper, 87.42% AUC on UCF-Crime with InternVL2.5-8B. ARIA achieves 88.32%, which is 0.90 points higher. The two methods use their own models and inference configurations, so this is a comparison under their respective settings and not a matched-budget comparison.
Vad-R1 [2] focuses on Video Anomaly Reasoning. It uses Perception-to-Cognition Chain-of-Thought for structured anomaly reasoning and combines SFT with AVA-GRPO reinforcement learning. ARIA keeps both VLMs frozen and trains only a lightweight router.
Table 9. Comparison on Vad-Reasoning.
Compared with its Base VLM, ARIA improves accuracy by 7.5 points and F1 by 7.4 points, and both scores exceed all listed baselines except Vad-R1. All three description metrics also improve over InternVL3-8B. For temporal localization, ARIA's [email protected] is 1.3 points above InternVL3-8B. Vad-R1 outperforms ARIA on seven of the eight metrics. This gap would be understandable because Vad-R1 uses SFT and reinforcement learning, whereas ARIA trains only lightweight routing components. Despite that, ARIA achieves a higher ROUGE-2 (0.206 vs. 0.194).
(2) Frame settings and ablation.
In the original configuration, Base samples 4 frames per segment, LOOK-MORE reruns the Base VLM with 8 frames on selected segments, and COOPERATE also uses 8 frames. We evaluate three Base/LOOK-MORE combinations (4/8, 4/16, and 8/16 frames) with COOPERATE excluded, both at a fixed routing threshold of τ = 0.20 and under a comparable budget of about 716k tokens per video.
Table 10. Ablation of Base/LOOK-MORE frame allocation.
At the fixed threshold, moving from 4/8 to 8/16 raises AUC by 0.71 points at about 48% higher token cost. When 4/16 and 8/16 are limited to about 716k tokens per video, both fall below 4/8. Using more frames per call therefore does not necessarily improve detection under a limited budget, and 4/8 gives a better balance between the visual input per call and the number of segments that can receive additional reasoning.
[1]Zou S, Tian X, Wesemann L, et al. Unlocking vision-language models for video anomaly detection via fine-grained prompting[C]//2026 IEEE/CVF Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision (WACV). IEEE, 2026: 4223-4233. [2]Huang C, Wang B, Wang W, et al. Vad-r1: Towards video anomaly reasoning via perception-to-cognition chain-of-thought[J]. Advances in neural information processing systems, 2026, 38: 118486-118518.