- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes LoRIT, a training-free multi-agent reasoning framework that dynamically constructs communication topologies based on refinement relationships between agents. Specifically, multiple agents independently solve a given problem and evaluate whether each agent's reasoning can improve that of another agent. Based on these directional refinement relationships, the communication topology is dynamically constructed, and each agent iteratively updates its reasoning state by incorporating useful information from connected agents.
Critical strengths
- Refinement-specific communication: Instead of sharing reasoning among all agents indiscriminately, LoRIT identifies directional, recipient-specific refinement relationships, allowing agents to selectively incorporate useful information from others.
- Efficient topology construction: By leveraging Strongly Connected Components (SCCs) and Transitive Reduction (TR), LoRIT constructs a communication topology that preserves refinement reachability while removing redundant component-level connections.
- Dynamic reasoning–topology co-evolution: LoRIT dynamically reconstructs the communication topology as agents update their reasoning states, enabling adaptive collaboration based on evolving refinement relationships.
- Comprehensive empirical evaluation: LoRIT demonstrates consistent improvements across diverse reasoning and coding benchmarks, multiple backbone scales, and heterogeneous agent configurations. The ablation studies further validate the contributions of its topology construction components.
Critical weaknesses
- High Inference Cost: Although LoRIT achieves the highest accuracy across the evaluated benchmarks, Figures 7~9 show that its token consumption is substantially higher than that of several baselines, including G-Designer, TopoDIM, and MacNet. Its token cost is generally comparable to that of SelfOrg, rather than consistently lower than that of other multi-agent methods. Moreover, the fact that LoRIT lies on the Pareto frontier provides limited evidence of computational efficiency, as the highest-accuracy method is necessarily non-dominated regardless of its computational cost. These results raise concerns about whether the accuracy improvements justify the additional inference overhead.
- Limited Guarantees for Information Preservation under Transitive Reduction: Although SCC-based condensation and transitive reduction preserve graph reachability, they do not guarantee the preservation of reasoning information. For example, even if A → B → C exists, the information received by C through B may differ from that received directly from A, as intermediate agents may omit or distort useful reasoning. This concern is particularly relevant given the limited number of reasoning rounds (T=2) and dynamic topology re-induction, which may further restrict indirect information propagation. While the authors acknowledge this theoretical limitation and demonstrate the empirical benefits of transitive reduction in Appendix E.2, the extent to which removing transitive edges leads to information loss remains unclear. A more targeted analysis of information preservation along indirect refinement paths would strengthen the justification for this design choice.
Questions for authors
- Impact of Agent Role Diversity: The proposed framework uses eight agents with diverse roles, including General Assistant, Mathematician, Economist, Psychologist, Programmer, Lawyer and Historian, Biologist, and Physicist and Chemist. However, the relevance of certain roles, such as Lawyer and Historian, Biologist, and Physicist and Chemist, to mathematical reasoning and coding tasks is unclear. What motivates the use of such heterogeneous roles? Would a team consisting entirely of task-specific agents (e.g., eight Mathematician agents for mathematical reasoning) achieve comparable or better performance? An ablation study on agent role composition would help clarify the contribution of role diversity.
- Reasoning Diversity and Premature Consensus: The authors mention in the Introduction that premature consensus in multi-agent systems may suppress alternative solutions and propagate incorrect reasoning. However, it remains unclear whether LoRIT effectively mitigates this issue. Does LoRIT exhibit similar convergence behavior during iterative reasoning updates? An analysis of reasoning diversity, answer agreement, and incorrect consensus across collaboration rounds would help clarify whether refinement-specific communication preserves diverse reasoning trajectories.
- Comparison with Multi-Agent Debate: Although the paper compares LoRIT with several multi-agent baselines, it does not include direct comparisons with representative MAD methods, such as [1] and [2]. Comparisons in terms of accuracy, token consumption, and end-to-end inference latency under comparable computational budgets would strengthen the empirical evaluation.
[1] Improving Factuality and Reasoning in Language Models through Multiagent Debate, ICML 2024
[2] Encouraging Divergent Thinking in Large Language Models through Multi-Agent Debate, EMNLP 2024 - Sensitivity to the Number of Reasoning Rounds: The framework sets the maximum number of reasoning updates to (T=2), with early stopping based on topology stability. However, the paper does not report the average number of rounds actually performed or the frequency of early stopping. Could the authors provide these statistics and clarify the motivation for choosing (T=2)? Additionally, an ablation study varying the maximum number of rounds would help assess the impact on reasoning accuracy, inference cost, and convergence behavior.
- Understanding Performance Gains with Weakly Connected Refinement Graphs: Table 3 shows that Qwen3-0.6B produces relatively sparse refinement graphs, with low refinement density and nearly eight SCCs on average. Nevertheless, Table 2 reports substantial performance improvements over single-agent reasoning. What primarily explains these gains when the identified refinement connectivity is limited?
8 comments
Response to Reviewer Pmtr's concerns in weakness part
W1. Response to the concern on inference cost
Thank you for raising this concern. We agree that LoRIT's higher accuracy is accompanied by larger token consumption than several baselines. We see substantial scope for reducing this overhead through engineering optimization while retaining the original refinement-based coordination framework. Specifically, we introduce lazy evaluation of pairwise refinement judgments, which reduces assessment calls once the execution topology is fully determined.
Exact lazy evaluation of refinement judgments. Both the original and optimized implementations use eight agents and retain the same refinement criterion, communication rules, and readout procedure. For a fixed reasoning-state snapshot, let denote the relations already judged positive and the unqueried relations. We construct
\qquad \mathcal{D}^{+}=(\mathcal{V},P\cup U),$$ which treat all unqueried relations as negative and positive, respectively. Let $\Phi(\mathcal{D})$ denote the original LoRIT execution-graph construction: retain the original intra-SCC edges and expand each edge of the transitively reduced condensation graph into all-to-all inter-component connections. Lazy evaluation stops when $$\boxed{\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{-})=\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{+})},$$ where equality means identical directed edge sets. At this point, the remaining judgments cannot change the execution graph. Checking this condition requires only graph operations. **Proposition (Exactness of lazy evaluation).** Every completion $\mathcal{D}=(\mathcal{V},E)$ satisfying $P\subseteq E\subseteq P\cup U$ induces the same execution graph if and only if $\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{-})=\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{+})$. **Proof.** Necessity follows because $\mathcal{D}^{-}$ and $\mathcal{D}^{+}$ are both valid completions. For sufficiency, suppose $\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{-})=\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{+})$. The execution-graph construction preserves reachability, so $\mathcal{D}^{-}$ and $\mathcal{D}^{+}$ have identical reachability relations. Every completion satisfies $$\operatorname{Reach}(\mathcal{D}^{-}) \subseteq \operatorname{Reach}(\mathcal{D}) \subseteq \operatorname{Reach}(\mathcal{D}^{+}).$$ Thus, all completions have the same reachability relation, SCC partition, and quotient partial order. Their component-level cover edges and corresponding all-to-all expansions are therefore identical. Moreover, no unqueried edge can lie within one of these SCCs. Such an edge would be retained in $\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{+})$ but absent from $\Phi(\mathcal{D}^{-})$, contradicting their equality. The original intra-SCC edges are therefore also fixed. Both parts of the execution graph are consequently identical for every completion. **This criterion preserves each agent's incoming peer set and the source-component readout pool.** With shared initialization, fixed corresponding judgment outcomes, and identical state ordering and random draws for corresponding generation calls, the lazy and exhaustive implementations follow the same reasoning trajectory and terminate at the same round.W1. Response to the concern on inference cost — Experimental results
We evaluate the optimized implementation with Qwen3-8B on GSM-Hard and GPQA. The optimized version is independently rerun with fresh reasoning samples. Table R12 reports accuracy and total token consumption across all inference stages.
Table R12: Accuracy and inference cost with Qwen3-8B on GSM-Hard and GPQA. T/A denotes Tokens (K) divided by accuracy expressed as a percentage; lower is better.
| Method | GSM-Hard Acc. | GSM-Hard Tokens (K) | GSM-Hard T/A | GPQA Acc. | GPQA Tokens (K) | GPQA T/A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G-Designer | 65.47 | 10.2 | 0.156 | 45.96 | 14.8 | 0.322 |
| TopoDIM | 59.59 | 9.7 | 0.163 | 39.39 | 17.6 | 0.447 |
| MacNet | 66.07 | 17.9 | 0.271 | 43.94 | 28.4 | 0.646 |
| SelfOrg | 66.81 | 26.7 | 0.400 | 50.51 | 42.2 | 0.835 |
| LoRIT (, exhaustive judgments) | 72.30 | 25.3 | 0.350 | 55.56 | 41.9 | 0.754 |
| LoRIT (, lazy judgments) | 71.86 | 19.1 | 0.266 | 56.06 | 30.5 | 0.544 |
The results show that lazy judgments reduce total token consumption by 24.5% on GSM-Hard and 27.2% on GPQA, with accuracy remaining within 0.50 percentage points of the exhaustive implementation. The optimized version achieves 71.86% and 56.06% accuracy, respectively, exceeding all four compared baselines. Its T/A values of 0.266 and 0.544 lie between those of G-Designer/TopoDIM and MacNet/SelfOrg, placing it in the intermediate range of the baseline token-to-accuracy ratios. Compared with SelfOrg, it improves accuracy by 5.05 and 5.55 percentage points while using 28.5% and 27.7% fewer tokens. These results demonstrate that implementation optimization can substantially reduce inference overhead while retaining LoRIT's accuracy advantage.
Core contribution and further optimization.
More broadly, LoRIT's central contribution is a self-organizing framework in which communication is induced by recipient-specific opportunities for reasoning refinement. Local judgments identify how one agent's reasoning can improve another's, organize cyclic refinement within components and directed communication between components, and adapt the topology as reasoning states evolve. The lazy implementation demonstrates that this refinement-based coordination can be realized with substantially lower token consumption while maintaining high accuracy. We will continue to optimize refinement assessment and inference execution to further improve LoRIT's accuracy–cost trade-off.
Response to Reviewer Pmtr's questions
Thank you so much for recognizing our novelty and the breadth of our evaluation. We especially appreciate your insightful comments. We added the following suggested ablations and analyses to address your concerns and enhance our manuscript. The corresponding revisions are highlighted in red in the revised manuscript.
Q1. Impact of agent role diversity
Revision location: Appendix E.2, p. 26.
The default role pool is intended to provide varied initial reasoning perspectives across all our mathematical (e.g. GSM8K, GSM-Hard), scientific (e.g., GPQA), knowledge (e.g., MMLU), and coding benchmarks. Using a common role-prompt pool also standardizes the prompts available to the compared multi-agent methods. Here we further compare three eight-agent configurations:
We use each role pool across all four benchmarks. Within each backbone, all other settings remain fixed; initial responses are generated separately.
Table R6: Role-composition ablation of LoRIT.
Mathematical specialists improve accuracy in all nine mathematical settings, gaining 0.50–2.64 percentage points on GSM8K, 1.28–2.97 on GSM-Hard, and 3.33–4.44 on AIME over Mixed-domain. However, the same mathematical pool reduces GPQA accuracy by 3.03–3.54 points. Role specialization benefits task-aligned benchmarks, while the mixed-domain pool offers broader applicability, achieving the highest GPQA accuracy at every backbone scale.
Q2. Reasoning diversity and premature consensus
To address this concern, we examine both answer convergence and the frequency with which agents converge to a shared incorrect answer. We analyze eight-agent LoRIT runs on GSM-Hard and GPQA with Qwen3-1.7B, 8B, and 30B-A3B using the reasoning backbone as the refinement judge. We inspect all eight states at initialization (t=0) and after each update (t=1,2), including states excluded from final readout. For early-stopped problems, we carry the last states forward so all rounds cover the same questions.
All metrics use the same saved states within this diagnostic batch:
Table R7: Answer diversity and consensus across refinement rounds. Each entry lists t=0/1/2.
Table R7 shows that LoRIT exhibits answer-level convergence, accompanied by reduced incorrect unanimity. Distinct answers decrease from 1.58–2.91 initially to 1.13–1.73 finally, while agreement rises from 60.0–86.9% to 81.6–96.9%. Wrong unanimity falls from 17.5–33.8% to 2.7–10.1%, a reduction of 12.0–23.7 percentage points. Meanwhile, some answer-level diversity remains: the final mean number of distinct answers exceeds one in every setting, reaching 1.63 on GSM-Hard and 1.73 on GPQA with Qwen3-1.7B. Thus, convergence is accompanied by fewer shared incorrect answers and residual disagreement. To examine the underlying reasoning process, the following case study traces a useful alternative interpretation in initially incorrect states through recipient revision and final readout.