acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Finite-Particle Convergence Rates for Conservative and Non-Conservative Drifting Models

Abstract

We analyze finite-particle drifting models for one-step generative modeling. For a conservative velocity given by the difference of the kernel-smoothed data and model scores, a joint-entropy identity yields continuous-time bounds for the smoothed Fisher discrepancy and the squared particle velocity. The finite-particle correction involves reciprocal kernel density estimates. We give local-occupancy conditions and exact expectation bounds, and show that these expectations diverge for full-support initial densities in a shrinking-bandwidth regime. Keeping the bandwidth dependence of the quadrature constants explicit yields a conditional root residual-velocity rate of under uniform regularity, with a corresponding rate under weaker quadrature growth conditions. We also analyze the original displacement field with the exact Laplace kernel. A companion kernel gives a weighted coercivity estimate that accommodates the unbounded empirical scale and the kernel's non-differentiability. Localization controls the particle velocity, while relative scale alignment absorbs the mismatch into dissipation. Both analyses quantify the size of an additional drift correction under explicit regularity and stability assumptions.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Drifting, One-step generation, Finite-particle rates, Conservative and non-conservative fields

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_d9MQOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2(+1)
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper analyzes finite-particle drifting models with conservative drifting (Gaussian kernel and score difference) and non-conservative drifting (Laplace kernel, conditional mean difference). For both cases, this paper studies a continuous-time model on particle movements, and derives time derivatives of the KL divergence between smoothed particle distribution and smoothed data distribution. Moreover, this paper provides the convergece rates of time-averaged velocity moments, especially with respect to the number of particles NN. At the end, numerical experiments are done to visualize the theories.

Critical strengths
  • The problem itself is meaningful, as understanding the finite-particle behavior is very useful for drifting models.
  • The convergence results for velocity bounds is clear, and the dependence on dimensions and the number of particles is well established.
Critical weaknesses
  • The story line is not clear. There are many technical points in the main content, but it is difficult to recognize which results are main contributions, and which are the intermediate steps. Moreover, the implications of theorems and propositions are not obvious, but the paper have few discussions for it. As a result, I have not understand why the results are actually related to practice. Suggestion: Please consider using several sentences to identify the purposes of the results before directly writing the formulas.

  • The paper does not directly show how the results are related to distributional convergence or generation quality, while this might be the main concern of drifting models.

  • The word "convergence rate" is a bit misleading. If I have understood it correctly, this refers to the convergence rate of time-averaged velocity moments in Theorem 3.2 and 5.2. However, the word itself makes me to expect a result showing the particle distribution approaches the target data distribution.

  • The notations are too complex and difficult to follow. Suggestion: Please consider summarizing the notations in a separate paragraph or section, possibly in the appendix.

Questions for authors
  • Can you summarize your main contributions more concretely? How is your theory related to the generation quality or distributional convergence? (See also weaknesses.)
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

response 1

Response to Reviewer d9MQ

Weakness 1 and Question 1 — Main contributions and their purpose

Question: What are the main contributions, which results are supporting steps, and why are they relevant?

Answer: The revised opening identifies two finite-particle mechanisms: the reciprocal-KDE self-interaction correction for conservative drifting, and data–model scale mismatch for Laplace drifting. Theorems 3.2 and 5.2 turn these mechanisms into residual bounds. The added empirical and Gaussian examples then verify all terms of the localized conservative argument in concrete regimes. Section 3 explains the initialization, self-interaction, and quadrature contributions before the examples; the supporting estimates and proofs are in the appendices. Exact frozen-target regression gives the particle Euler update, identifying the connection to training and its idealization.

References: Abstract and §1 (pp. 1–2); Theorem 3.1 (p. 3), Theorem 3.2 and Eq. (8) (p. 4); Theorem 5.2 (p. 7); Theorems J.3 and L.1 (pp. 51 and 57); Appendix I, Eq. (111) (p. 48).

Weakness 2 and Question 1 — Distributional convergence and generation quality

Question: What connects the results to distributional convergence or generation quality?

Answer: The conservative analysis separately controls smoothed Fisher discrepancy. The added Corollary 3.3 uses an LSI to obtain smoothed KL and empirical Wasserstein bounds (with finite second moments), and Poincaré to obtain smoothed TV control. Both concrete examples also have terminal distributional guarantees. For the Gaussian example, root mean squared empirical W2W_2 is O((log⁡N)−3/20)O((\log N)^{-3/20}) at a uniformly sampled time and O((log⁡N)−A)O((\log N)^{-A}) at the terminal time for every fixed A>0A>0, with T=(log⁡N)3/10T=(\log N)^{3/10}.

References: §3.1, Corollary 3.3 (p. 5); Theorem J.3, Eqs. (123)–(124) (p. 51); Corollary L.4 (pp. 59–60); Appendix M (pp. 60–61); §7 (p. 10).

Weakness 3 — Meaning of “convergence rate”

Question: Does “convergence rate” refer to residual velocity rather than the particle distribution approaching the target?

Answer: For the original Theorems 3.2 and 5.2, it refers to time-averaged residual quantities. We changed the title to “Finite-Particle Residual Bounds for Conservative and Non-Conservative Drifting Models” and distinguish these bounds from the additional distributional results. Small velocity alone is insufficient: the manuscript gives a non-target stationary Gaussian configuration. The new distributional and terminal statements have their own hypotheses and proofs.

References: Title and abstract (p. 1); definitions in §2, Eq. (4) (p. 3); Theorems 3.2 and 5.2 (pp. 4 and 7); Corollary 3.3 (p. 5); “Stationarity and scope” (p. 60); Appendix M.3 (p. 61).

Weakness 4 — Notation

Question: Can the notation be collected and made easier to follow?

Answer: Section 2 collects the common quantities, and Appendix D.1 gives their detailed definitions. The main distinction is:

SymbolMeaning
μxN\mu_x^N, qxq_x, ρh\rho_hEmpirical particle measure, its KDE, and the smoothed target density
HNH_NKL of the joint particle law against the product target; this differs from KL(qx∥ρh)\mathrm{KL}(q_x\|\rho_h)
IN\mathsf I_NKDE-smoothed Fisher discrepancy
VN\mathsf V_NMean squared particle speed
RN\mathsf R_NMean reciprocal KDE at particle centers
SN\mathsf S_NCenter-averaged Stein divergence, used in the entropy identity

The Laplace-specific notation is introduced separately in §5.1–5.2; Appendix D.1 provides the detailed conservative notation reference.

References: §2, Eqs. (3)–(4) (p. 3); Appendix D.1, Eqs. (27)–(33) (pp. 16–17); §5.1–5.2, Eqs. (15)–(19) (pp. 6–7).

Thanks for the response. I find the presentation clearer after the revisions and have updated my score accordingly.

Reviewer_M2WGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary
  • Summary

This paper studies finite-particle convergence properties of conservative and non-conservative drifting models. For conservative drifting, the authors establish a joint-entropy identity that explicitly accounts for the self-interaction correction arising from finite-particle kernel density estimation. Based on this identity and quadrature estimates, they derive time-averaged bounds on the smoothed Fisher discrepancy and particle velocity, including a conditional root residual-velocity rate of (N^{-1/(d+4)}). The paper further investigates reciprocal-KDE estimates and demonstrates that their expectations diverge under full-support initialization in the shrinking-bandwidth regime. For non-conservative drifting with the Laplace kernel, the authors introduce a companion-kernel representation and derive weighted coercivity estimates that account for the position-dependent scale and its mismatch between the target and model distributions. Numerical experiments illustrate the importance of the self-interaction correction and the effectiveness of the relative scale-alignment bound.

Critical strengths
  • Strengths
  1. Relevant theoretical problem. Understanding finite-particle effects in drifting models is an interesting and timely research direction. The paper addresses a theoretical aspect that is not fully captured by existing population-level analyses.

  2. Careful treatment of finite-particle corrections. The joint-entropy identity in Theorem 3.1 explicitly identifies the reciprocal-KDE correction caused by particle self-interaction. This is a useful result, and the accompanying analysis of local occupancy and full-support initialization provides additional insight into its behavior.

Critical weaknesses
  • Weaknesses
  1. The main convergence rates rely on strong assumptions whose validity for the underlying particle dynamics remains unclear. My primary concern is the applicability of the convergence guarantees. In particular, the rate (N^{-1/(d+4)}) derived in Section 3 requires uniform control of the reciprocal-KDE term and the quadrature constants over a growing time horizon (T=N).These conditions appear substantially stronger than standard kernel regularity assumptions, since they involve the entire evolving particle system and must remain controlled as both the particle number and bandwidth change. The paper acknowledges that the relevant quadrature constants may grow rapidly as (h\to 0). For example, derivative estimates at the kernel scale may yield (C_N(h)=O(h^{-4})), in which case the corresponding quadrature error does not vanish with decreasing bandwidth. However, the paper does not establish that the required uniform bounds hold for a concrete, nontrivial drifting system. Consequently, it is difficult to assess whether the stated convergence rates are attainable beyond the assumed regularity regime. I would find the theoretical contribution substantially more convincing if the authors could identify a meaningful setting in which all the required assumptions are rigorously verified and the resulting bound is shown to vanish.

  2. The full-support initialization result raises concerns about the applicability of the main rate to standard generative modeling settings. Proposition 4.2 shows that the expected reciprocal-KDE quantity diverges for bounded, continuous, strictly positive densities on (\mathbb{R}^d) when (h_N\to 0) and (Nh_N^d\to\infty). This includes Gaussian initialization, which is particularly relevant to generative modeling. This is an interesting theoretical observation. However, it also highlights a limitation of the simplified convergence rate, which relies on uniform control of the corresponding reciprocal-KDE expectation.Although the general finite-particle inequality remains valid with a growing reciprocal-KDE coefficient, the paper does not quantify this growth sufficiently to establish a concrete convergence rate under Gaussian initialization. As a result, the relationship between the proposed asymptotic theory and commonly used generative modeling setups remains unclear. An explicit characterization of the reciprocal-KDE growth for Gaussian or other full-support initializations would significantly strengthen the results.

  3. The theoretical guarantees concern time-averaged residual velocities rather than convergence of the generated distribution. The main results bound quantities such as

\mathbb{E}[V_N(X(t))],dt.$$ While these bounds characterize the residual dynamics, they do not directly establish convergence of the empirical or generated distribution to the target distribution. In particular, a small residual velocity does not by itself rule out stationary configurations that differ from the target distribution. Moreover, time-averaged bounds do not directly provide terminal-time convergence guarantees. The authors acknowledge this limitation, but I believe it substantially affects the significance of the results in the context of generative modeling. It would be helpful to clarify whether additional structural assumptions could connect the residual-velocity estimates to a distributional convergence guarantee, or whether non-target stationary configurations may arise.
Questions for authors
  • Other questions
  1. Verifiability of the convergence assumptions: Can the authors provide a nontrivial example of a target distribution, initialization, and kernel for which all assumptions required for the (N^{-1/(d+4)}) convergence rate can be rigorously verified, including uniform quadrature regularity and stability over (T=N)?
  2. Gaussian initialization: Given Proposition 4.2, can the authors derive an explicit growth bound for the reciprocal-KDE expectation under Gaussian initialization? Does the resulting finite-particle bound still imply a vanishing residual velocity for a suitable bandwidth schedule?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

response 1

Weakness 1 and Question 1 — Verifiable assumptions and an attainable rate on T=NT=N

Question: Is there a nontrivial target, initialization, and kernel for which the required trajectory and quadrature estimates hold uniformly as h→0h\to0 on T=NT=N?

Answer: Theorem J.3 supplies such an example through a proved local quadrature extension. Take a fixed empirical target with separated modes, a Gaussian kernel, and iid smooth clusters of radius h3/100h^3/100 displaced by a vector of length 1/81/8. The proof verifies regularity and, throughout [0,N][0,N],

|\mathsf I_N-\mathsf S_N|+|\mathsf V_N-\mathsf I_N|\le Ch^2,\qquad H_N(0)/N\le Ch^{-2}+C\log(1/h)+C.$$ Thus $h=N^{-1/4}$ gives root residual $O(N^{-1/4})$, improving the earlier dimension-dependent specialization. The earlier bandwidth $N^{-1/(d+4)}$ is also covered. The initial Wasserstein error is at least $1/8-h^3/100$, and the initial root mean squared speed is at least $1/(16h^2)$, so the example is nonstationary. The qualification is explicit: local Hessians with integrated Gaussian tails replace the original global-Hessian sufficient condition. The example uses narrow clusters near displaced known modes; it is not a general initialization theorem. **References:** §3 (p. 4); Proposition J.1 and Lemma J.2 (p. 50); Theorem J.3, Eqs. (119)–(124), and “Bandwidth range” (p. 51); proof (pp. 51–53); Remark J.4, explaining the global-Hessian obstruction (p. 52). ## Weakness 2 and Question 2 — Explicit Gaussian reciprocal growth and vanishing residual **Question:** Under Gaussian initialization, how fast does the reciprocal-KDE expectation grow, and can the complete finite-particle bound still vanish? **Answer:** For iid $\mathcal N(0,s_0I_d)$ initialization, write $b=h/\sqrt{s_0}$. Theorem K.3 gives explicit constants for $$\mathbb E\mathsf R_N(X(0)) \asymp_d s_0^{d/2}, \min\{[\log(Nb^d)]^{d/2},\,b^{-d}\} \qquad 0<b\le1,\quad Nb^d\ge e.$$ In particular, $h\asymp N^{-\alpha}$, $0<\alpha<1/d$, gives $\Theta((\log N)^{d/2})$ growth. The theorem also gives the finite-$N$ upper bound $(2\pi)^{d/2}(s_0+h^2)^dh^{-d}$. Proposition K.4 provides all-time reciprocal control for a Gaussian target. For fixed positive-variance Gaussian data and iid Gaussian initialization, the complete residual theorem uses $$h=(\log N)^{-1/16},\qquad T=(\log N)^{3/10}, \qquad \left(\frac1T\int_0^T\mathbb E\mathsf V_N\,dt\right)^{1/2} =O((\log N)^{-3/20}).$$ It verifies reciprocal control, quadrature, tracking, entropy regularity, and exceptional configurations under the unconditioned iid law. This answers the question on a growing logarithmic horizon; Gaussian polynomial horizons, including $T=N$, remain open. **References:** §4 (p. 6); Lemma K.2 and Theorem K.3, Eqs. (135)–(138) (pp. 54–55); Proposition K.4, Eq. (140) (p. 55); Theorem L.1, Eqs. (145)–(148) (p. 57); Lemmas L.2–L.3 (pp. 57–58), completion of the proof (pp. 58–59). ## Weakness 3 — Distributional error, non-target stationary states, and terminal time **Question:** Can small residual velocity coexist with a wrong distribution, and what additional arguments give distributional or terminal guarantees? **Answer:** Yes. For Gaussian data $\nu=\mathcal N(0,s_\nu I_d)$, the collapsed configuration $x_i=0$ has $\mathsf V_N=0$ but $W_2^2(\mu_x^N,\nu)=ds_\nu>0$ and positive Fisher discrepancy. Consequently, distributional conclusions use the separately proved Fisher estimate. Corollary 3.3 converts it to smoothed KL and empirical $W_2$ bounds under an LSI (with finite second moments for $W_2$), or smoothed TV under Poincaré, at a uniformly sampled time. Both concrete examples also admit terminal bounds through additional dynamics: cluster invariance for the empirical target and Gaussian tracking for the Gaussian target. In the latter regime, terminal expected Fisher/KL and root mean squared empirical $W_2$ errors are $O((\log N)^{-A})$ for every fixed $A>0$ on the stated logarithmic horizon. **References:** Corollary 3.3 and “Stationarity and terminal time” (p. 5); Theorem J.3, Eqs. (123)–(124) (p. 51); Corollary L.4 (pp. 59–60); “Stationarity and scope” (p. 60); Appendix M.3 (p. 61); §7 (p. 10).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

official author comment

Dear Reviewer M2WG,

Really sorry to bother you, but given that we are a few hours away from the discussion deadline we wanted to reach out and ask if you could please let us know whether these additions and clarifications address your concerns? Thank you for your time!

best
Authors

Reviewer_zUTLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how a finite set of generated samples moves during drifting-model training. It compares two update rules: a conservative rule based on smoothed density gradients and a rule based on Laplace-weighted displacements. For the first, it identifies an extra term caused by each sample influencing its own update. For the second, it shows how differences in local scale between the data and generated samples affect the bounds. Low-dimensional simulations seem to these findings. Under strong regularity and stability assumptions, the theory bounds the average remaining motion of the samples over time. It does not establish that the trained generator’s distribution converges to the data distribution.

Critical strengths

A key strength is the identification of distinct finite-particle obstructions in the two dynamics: reciprocal-KDE self-interaction for conservative drifting and scale mismatch for Laplace drifting. The analysis makes these mechanisms explicit, and low-dimensional numerical experiments seem to support their relevance.

Critical weaknesses

The presentation leaves the paper’s main message and significance unclear. The writing is very difficult to follow, and the paper introduces substantial technical machinery without adequately explaining the problem, the quantities being bounded, or why the results matter for generative modeling. As a result, it is difficult to understand what the paper ultimately establishes and to appreciate its contribution, even when individual derivations can be followed.

The assumptions are insufficiently connected to concrete settings. Although the paper discusses several sufficient conditions and obstructions, it does not clearly demonstrate a representative regime where the assumptions jointly hold and yield the advertised rate. In particular, uniform control over a growing time horizon is demanding, and the paper itself shows that common full-support initializations obstruct one required uniform bound.

The guarantees have a limited connection to successful learning. The results control time-averaged residual motion, rather than terminal-time convergence or closeness to the data distribution. Their relevance to practical neural-network training is further limited by the idealization of exact regression and continuous-time dynamics.

The experiments validate mechanisms more than convergence claims. The low-dimensional diagnostics support the self-interaction correction and scale-alignment bounds, but do not establish the predicted asymptotic rate or show that the assumptions remain informative in realistic generative-model settings.

Questions for authors
  • Could you explain the role and strength of the main assumptions in more concrete terms? Which are standard technical conditions, and which impose substantive restrictions on the particle dynamics?

  • Can you give a representative example where these assumptions hold jointly and the resulting bounds are informative? The sufficient conditions and obstructions discussed separately make it difficult to assess the overall scope of the results.

  • Although you explicitly state that log-concavity, log-Sobolev, and Poincaré assumptions are not required, the relationship between your assumptions and these familiar conditions remains unclear. If the data distribution satisfied such conditions, would they help verify your hypotheses or strengthen the conclusions—for example, by connecting the smoothed Fisher discrepancy to a distributional convergence guarantee? Please clarify whether such implications follow from the present analysis or require additional arguments.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

response 1

Weakness 1 — Main message and presentation

Question: What does the paper establish, and why do the technical results matter for generative modeling?

Answer: The revised title and abstract identify the central object as finite-particle residual motion. The conservative analysis isolates the reciprocal-KDE self-interaction correction; the Laplace analysis isolates the effect of data–model scale mismatch. The introduction explains these contributions, and Section 3 interprets the bound as initialization cost plus self-interaction plus quadrature error. The added examples show when all these terms can be controlled together, and the new distributional corollary states what further conclusions follow.

References: Title and abstract (p. 1); §1 (pp. 1–2); Theorems 3.1–3.2 and Eq. (8) (pp. 3–4); Theorem 5.2 (p. 7); Corollary 3.3 (p. 5).

Weakness 2 and Question 2 — A jointly verified, informative regime

Question: Can the assumptions be verified together for a concrete system, including control over a growing horizon?

Answer: Yes, through a proved local quadrature extension. For a fixed separated empirical target, a Gaussian kernel, and iid smooth narrow clusters displaced a fixed distance from the target modes, Theorem J.3 verifies flow regularity, entropy, reciprocal control, and local quadrature throughout T=NT=N. Choosing h=N−1/4h=N^{-1/4} gives root residual O(N−1/4)O(N^{-1/4}) and a terminal empirical Wasserstein bound. This example uses known target modes. A separate theorem treats fixed positive-variance Gaussian data and iid Gaussian initialization, with a vanishing residual on T=(log⁡N)3/10T=(\log N)^{3/10}; the Gaussian T=NT=N case remains open.

References: §3 (p. 4); Proposition J.1 and Lemma J.2 (p. 50); Theorem J.3 (p. 51), proof (pp. 51–53); Theorem L.1 (p. 57), concentration and tracking in Lemmas L.2–L.3 (pp. 57–58).

Weakness 3 — Distributional convergence, terminal time, and neural training

Question: How do residual-motion bounds connect to closeness to the data distribution and practical training?

Answer: The separately proved Fisher bound gives smoothed KL and empirical W2W_2 bounds under an additional log-Sobolev inequality, with finite second moments for W2W_2. The empirical example also has terminal convergence from cluster invariance. For the Gaussian example, tracking gives terminal expected Fisher/KL and root mean squared empirical W2W_2 errors of O((log⁡N)−A)O((\log N)^{-A}) for every fixed A>0A>0, on its proved logarithmic horizon.

References: Corollary 3.3 and “Stationarity and terminal time” (p. 5); Theorem J.3, Eqs. (123)–(124) (p. 51); Theorem L.1, Eq. (148) (p. 57); Corollary L.4 (pp. 59–60); Appendix I (pp. 47–49); §7 (p. 10).

Weakness 4 — Experiments test mechanisms rather than convergence rates

Question: Do the experiments establish the asymptotic rate or applicability to realistic generative-model settings?

Answer: We emphasize that our contributions in this paper are primarily providing a theoretical understanding of the practically used drifting models. Hence, we test the reciprocal self-interaction correction and Laplace scale-alignment mechanism. The revised experimental discussion states these aims explicitly.

References: §6.1 (pp. 8–9), Figure 2 (p. 9); §6.2 (pp. 9–10), Figure 3 (p. 10); §7 (p. 10).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

response 2

Question 1 — Which assumptions are technical or substantive?

Question: Which assumptions are standard analytic requirements, and which restrict the evolving particle system?

Answer: Smoothness, well-posed density transport, integrability, and justified differentiation/integration by parts are analytic prerequisites that must be checked for the actual flow. Reciprocal-KDE control, quadrature accuracy, and uniformity as N,h,TN,h,T vary are substantive restrictions on the particle cloud. Laplace drifting additionally needs scale alignment and tail control. Appendix A now explains each condition's role and distinguishes finite-horizon finiteness from the quantitative control needed for a vanishing rate.

References: Assumption 2.1 and the following discussion (p. 3); Appendix A, Table 1 (p. 13); Assumption 5.1 and Theorem 5.2 (p. 7).

Question 3 — Log-concavity, log-Sobolev, and Poincaré inequalities

Question: Can familiar assumptions on the data imply distributional convergence, and does this require additional arguments?

Answer: We added those arguments. An LSI converts a proved Fisher bound into smoothed KL and empirical W2W_2 bounds; a Poincaré inequality gives smoothed total-variation control. Gaussian smoothing inherits these constants, and strong log-concavity with curvature m>0m>0 supplies an LSI with CLS,h≤m−1+h2C_{\mathrm{LS},h}\le m^{-1}+h^2. Ordinary log-concavity alone need not imply an LSI.

References: §3.1, Corollary 3.3 (p. 5); Appendix M.1 (pp. 60–61), Eq. (157); Appendix M.2 (p. 61), Eq. (158).

Thank you for the detailed responses and the substantial work undertaken during the rebuttal. The added examples and distributional guarantees address some of my substantive concerns.

However, presentation remains a major concern. The paper does not provide sufficient pedagogical guidance or equip the reader with the intuition and context needed to appreciate its results. Understanding how the assumptions, residual-motion bounds, and additional distributional guarantees fit together still requires substantial reconstruction across the appendices. This makes the scope and significance of the contribution difficult to assess, beyond the technical difficulty inherent in the subject.

Despite the improvements made during the rebuttal, I therefore maintain my previous score.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.