- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper separates prediction error into slide-level and within-slide components and proposes Component-Guided Loss (CGL) to emphasize within-slide variation. CGL-Linear is evaluated on ten HEST-1K cohorts, and CGL is also added to several neural predictors.
Critical strengths
- The paper shows that aggregate correlation may conceal poor within-slide spatial recovery.
- The benchmark covers ten cohorts, three encoders, four gene panels, and several recent methods.
- CGL is inexpensive and architecture-independent.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main claims are overstated. CGL mainly adds weight to slide-centered residual error, making it close to target centering or component-wise loss reweighting. The experiments show improved within-slide reconstruction, but they do not establish a general optimization principle, a fundamentally new modeling approach, or broad conclusions about model complexity. The state-of-the-art claim should therefore be stated more cautiously.
-
Even the ordinary Linear baseline without CGL outperforms HEXST, STFlow, and BLEEP on several reported metrics. This raises concern that the frozen image representation or benchmark protocol contributes more than the proposed loss, or that some baselines are insufficiently reproduced or tuned. Reproduction details, convergence results, method-specific hyperparameter selection, and matched tuning budgets are needed before attributing the ranking to CGL.
-
The evaluation uses one fixed train, validation, and test split, with only two or three validation or test slides in several cohorts. Repeating neural training with different seeds measures optimization variability, not sensitivity to patient or slide selection. Patient-level K-fold cross-validation should be reported with fold-wise means and standard deviations to support the stability of the results.
-
The effect of the component weight is not sufficiently analyzed. Results across a wider range of weights should report both slide-level and within-slide losses, together with aggregate and local metrics. This would show whether better within-slide reconstruction sacrifices slide-level prediction and whether the selected value is stable across cohorts and gene-panel sizes.
-
The motivation for CGL needs clearer biological justification. ST data are inherently heterogeneous and highly variable. The sensitivity analysis in Eq. (3) motivates decomposing MSE and increasing the weight of within-slide expression errors by a factor of 1 + λ, but it does not establish why this weighting better captures biologically meaningful variation. Spatial variation within each gene is important, yet relationships among genes at the same location also matter. The proposed decomposition does not explicitly account for these dependencies. The paper should explain why this statistical reweighting is appropriate for ST prediction and provide evidence that it preserves meaningful gene relationships, beyond improving aggregate reconstruction metrics.
-
Equation numbering and formatting need to be standardized. The displayed equations in Section 4 lack numbers, and the main text and appendix do not follow a clear, consistent convention for numbering and presenting formulas. This makes the mathematical presentation difficult to follow and reference. A consistent numbering policy and uniform equation formatting would improve readability.
Questions for authors
No additional questions.