- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates how to reduce unnecessary computation and redundant steps in large language model reasoning while maintaining reasoning accuracy. The authors point out that existing GRPO-based reinforcement learning methods typically assign the same advantage to all tokens within a reasoning trajectory, making it difficult to distinguish essential reasoning steps that contribute to the final answer from redundant ones. Moreover, existing fine-grained optimization methods often focus on the local contributions of individual tokens or steps, without explicitly modeling semantic dependencies among reasoning steps.
To address these challenges, the authors propose RECAP (Redundancy-aware Credit Assignment via Propagation), a step-level credit assignment method built upon GRPO. Specifically, the authors first use an LLM to construct a semantic dependency graph among reasoning steps and compute each step's Structural Responsibility by propagating credit backward from the final-answer node. They then measure Step Efficacy through changes in the gold answer's log-likelihood before and after incorporating each reasoning step. Finally, the two signals are combined to construct step-specific weights that redistribute the original GRPO advantages, thereby reinforcing important reasoning steps while downweighting redundant ones.
Experiments are conducted on Qwen2.5-Math-7B and DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B across four mathematical reasoning benchmarks: GSM8K, MATH-500, AIME 2024, and AIME 2025. The method is compared against GRPO, length-penalty approaches, and other reasoning-efficiency optimization methods. On Qwen2.5-Math-7B, RECAP improves pass@1 by 2.0–3.7 percentage points while reducing reasoning tokens by 8%–31% compared with GRPO. On DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B, RECAP also achieves a competitive accuracy–efficiency trade-off. Additionally, component ablations, semantic dependency annotation quality evaluations, and reasoning trajectory analyses examine the contributions of different components and show that RECAP reduces redundant steps and unproductive reasoning branches in generated trajectories.
Critical strengths
-
To address the difficulty of distinguishing essential reasoning steps from redundant ones in existing GRPO methods, this paper proposes a step-level credit assignment approach based on semantic dependencies. By combining Structural Responsibility and Step Efficacy, the method enables fine-grained reweighting of the original GRPO advantages. The overall approach is clear and provides an alternative to direct length penalties for improving reasoning efficiency.
-
The paper conducts experiments on two 7B models with different reasoning characteristics across four mathematical reasoning benchmarks, comparing RECAP against several relevant methods, including GRPO, DDCA, LEASH, BINGO, and ThoughtFold. On Qwen2.5-Math-7B, RECAP improves reasoning accuracy while reducing the number of generated tokens. On DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B, it also demonstrates a competitive accuracy–efficiency trade-off. These results provide substantial empirical evidence for the practical effectiveness of the proposed method.
-
The experiments include separate ablations of Structural Responsibility and Step Efficacy, as well as random and shuffled structural-weight experiments to further examine the influence of semantic dependency information on training effectiveness. In addition, the paper analyzes dependency annotation quality, the number of reasoning operations, and unproductive reasoning branches, while also reporting additional training overhead. These analyses provide further evidence supporting the effectiveness of the method and offer insights into the potential sources of its reasoning-efficiency improvements.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper estimates the contributions of individual reasoning steps using semantic dependencies among steps and changes in the gold answer's log-likelihood. However, these two signals do not necessarily accurately reflect the actual contribution of each step to the final answer. For example, a step may be heavily relied upon by subsequent reasoning without positively contributing to the correct solution, and an increase in the gold answer's likelihood does not necessarily indicate that the step is mathematically correct or necessary. Although the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through random and shuffled structural-weight experiments, these results primarily show that the proposed advantage reweighting strategy can improve training outcomes, rather than sufficiently establishing the reliability of its credit assignment.
-
According to Table 2, introducing Step Efficacy improves pass@1 only from 81.32% to 81.90% and reduces the average number of generated tokens from 370 to 352, while pass@8 slightly decreases. Given that Step Efficacy is a key component designed to distinguish structural dependencies from contributions toward the correct answer, these relatively modest gains do not sufficiently establish its necessity. Moreover, the current component ablations are mainly conducted on Qwen2.5-Math-7B, without corresponding validation on the second backbone.
-
The authors analyze the number of reasoning operations and dead-end reasoning to show that RECAP reduces redundant content in generated trajectories. However, shorter reasoning trajectories may naturally contain fewer unproductive steps and exhibit simpler dependency structures. The current experiments lack structural comparisons under matched reasoning lengths or computational budgets. Therefore, it remains unclear to what extent the observed improvements result from more accurate step-level credit assignment rather than simply shortening the overall reasoning trajectories.
Questions for authors
I'm open to raise my score if the authors could adequately address the following concerns. Given the substantial engineering effort involved in the experiments, I believe that a few lightweight additional experiments and clarifications would be sufficient.
-
Could the authors further validate whether Structural Responsibility and Step Efficacy genuinely reflect the contributions of individual reasoning steps to the final answer? For example, could a small-scale counterfactual experiment be conducted by removing or perturbing selected reasoning steps and measuring the resulting changes in subsequent reasoning accuracy or the gold answer's likelihood? Examining the correlation between the assigned credit and the actual contribution of each step would help establish whether RECAP achieves reliable credit assignment rather than merely providing an effective advantage reweighting strategy.
-
According to Table 2, the additional performance gains from Step Efficacy are relatively modest. Could the authors further clarify whether these improvements are stable and statistically significant? For example, providing corresponding component ablations on DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B or reporting the variability of the existing experimental results would help establish the independent contribution and necessity of Step Efficacy across different models.
-
Could the authors further investigate whether the changes in reasoning trajectory length influence the dead-end reasoning analysis? For example, comparing RECAP with other methods under matched generated-token counts, numbers of reasoning steps, and answer correctness could help determine whether RECAP achieves lower dead-end step ratios or more effective dependency structures independently of trajectory length. Such an analysis would provide stronger evidence that RECAP genuinely improves the effectiveness of reasoning steps rather than simply generating shorter reasoning trajectories.
6 comments
Rebuttal by authors (Part 2)
W1 & Q1 - (2) Step Efficacy tracks answer-directed contribution, including among structurally important steps
Step Efficacy further distinguishes answer-reaching steps by their impact on answer accuracy (Table R10). We consider steps with positive Structural Responsibility (resp>0), divide them into two groups based on Step Efficacy (Δ > 0 vs. Δ <= 0), and compare the accuracy drops caused by numerical corruption. Both groups have downstream dependencies and similar length and numerical content, yet corrupting steps with Δ > 0 causes a substantially larger accuracy drop than corrupting steps with Δ ≤ 0 (30.4 vs. 17.1 pp), a difference of 13.2 pp (95% CI [11.3, 15.1]). Thus, Step Efficacy helps distinguish steps with different answer-directed contributions even when they are structurally important, supporting its complementary role in RECAP's credit assignment.
Table R10. Step Efficacy distinguishes answer-reaching steps with different counterfactual Impacts on answer accuracy.
| Step Efficacy | # Steps | Avg. length | Avg. numerical count | Accuracy drop (pp) | 95% CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (Δ>0) | 3,044 | 127 | 14.9 | 30.4 | [28.3, 32.6] |
| (Δ<=0) | 2,947 | 120 | 13.2 | 17.1 | [15.3, 18.9] |
Step Efficacy is positively associated with downstream answer accuracy. Among answer-advancing steps () in correct rollouts, higher original Step Efficacy corresponds to larger accuracy drops after numerical corruption. As shown in Table R11, steps in the highest-efficacy group experience a 63.0 pp accuracy drop, compared with 45.0 and 34.6 points in the middle- and lowest-efficacy groups, despite similar initial accuracy (82–90%). Moreover, original Step Efficacy is positively correlated with the subsequent accuracy drop (Spearman's ρ = 0.30, 95% CI [0.25, 0.34]). Corruption lowers Δ in all terciles, but Δ remains positive for the highest tercile (1.69) even though accuracy drops by 63 points, consistent with the reviewer's observation that answer likelihood alone does not fully reflect correctness. RECAP therefore uses Step Efficacy to calibrate structural credit rather than as a standalone measure of correctness.
In conclusion, these results provide independent counterfactual evidence that Step Efficacy reflects meaningful information about a step's influence on the final answer.
Table R11. Step efficacy and downstream accuracy before and after numeral corruption (answer-advancing steps, , in correct rollouts; grouped into terciles of original ).
| Original | # Steps | : before → after | Accuracy: before → after (change) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 649 | 0.06 → −0.38 | 89.8% → 55.2% (−34.6) |
| Middle | 648 | 0.65 → 0.39 | 82.3% → 37.4% (−45.0) |
| High | 647 | 2.94 → 1.69 | 89.5% → 26.5% (−63.0) |
Rebuttal by authors (Part 3)
W1 & Q1 - (3) RECAP's credit signals identify steps with greater influence on answer accuracy.
Within each rollout, we corrupt the highest- and lowest-scored step under each criterion (Table R12).
As shown in Table R12, for all three RECAP signals (structure responsibility, step efficacy, and their combination), corrupting the highest-scored step causes a significantly larger drop in accuracy (drop of 8.9–10.9 pp) than corrupting the lowest-scored step. In contrast, random selection shows no difference (+0.1 points), and position-based selection shows the opposite pattern, with earlier steps being slightly more influential (−2.8 points). Step length is also predictive (+8.3 points), likely because corrupting a longer step perturbs more content; the length-controlled analyses above (Tables R9–R10) show that both Structural Responsibility and Step Efficacy remain predictive beyond length.
Note.Table R12 evaluates whether each signal identifies causally important steps in a fixed trained policy, whereas the ablation in Table 2 measures each signal’s contribution to training. The two are complementary rather than comparable. Structural Responsibility has the larger training effect (Table 2) because it sets the score of dead-end steps to zero, whereas Step Efficacy only rescales the credit of the remaining steps within a bounded range.
Table R12. Accuracy drop (pp) after corrupting the highest- vs. lowest-scored step within the same rollout. # Rollouts reports how many rollouts contain at least two perturbable reasoning steps with distinct scores under each selection criterion, allowing a valid highest- vs. lowest-scored step comparison. Extra drop denotes the difference in accuracy reduction between the highest- and lowest-scored steps.
| Selection criterion | # Rollouts | High-score drop (pp) (Accuracy: before → after) | Low-score drop (pp) (Accuracy: before → after) | Extra drop (pp) | 95% CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Structural Responsibility | 870 | 27.6 (50.0→22.3) | 18.7 (49.6→30.9) | +8.9 | [6.0, 11.8] |
| Step Efficacy | 1,310 | 31.7 (53.0→21.3) | 20.9 (46.6→25.7) | +10.8 | [8.4, 13.2] |
| Combined RECAP Weight | 1,268 | 32.1 (52.2→20.1) | 21.2 (50.6→29.4) | +10.9 | [8.5, 13.3] |
| Random | 1,310 | 24.6 (50.3→25.7) | 24.5 (50.3→25.8) | +0.1 | [−2.1, 2.4] |
| Position | 1,310 | 25.9 (50.6→24.7) | 28.7 (50.4→21.7) | −2.8 | [−5.7, −0.2] |
| Step Length | 1,309 | 28.3 (50.3→22.0) | 20.0 (50.6→30.6) | +8.3 | [5.9, 10.7] |
W2 & Q2. Stability and consistency of step efficacy’s contribution
We thank the reviewer for raising the question of whether Step Efficacy provides stable and consistent improvements. Following the reviewer's suggestion, we conducted an additional ablation on DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B (Table R13), comparing full RECAP against the variant without Step Efficacy.
Across both backbones, Step Efficacy improves pass@1 and reduces reasoning tokens while maintaining comparable pass@8, with larger gains on the long-thinking model (+1.20 pp pass@1, −18.8% tokens). At the step level, it further distinguishes answer-directed contributions that Structural Responsibility alone cannot differentiate (Table R10).
These results suggest that Structural Responsibility provides the primary credit signal, while Step Efficacy adds a complementary, answer-directed calibration. Its aggregate effect is larger on the long-thinking model.
Table R13. Ablation of Step Efficacy (pooled over GSM8K, MATH-500, AIME 2024, and AIME 2025). pass@1 is reported as mean ± std over 8 sampled runs. Δ is full RECAP minus w/o step efficacy, with 95% confidence intervals from a paired bootstrap over problems (5,000 resamples, stratified by benchmark).
| Model | Method | pass@1 ↑ | pass@8 ↑ | tokens ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen2.5-Math-7B | RECAP (full) | 81.90± 0.40 | 91.80 | 352 |
| w/o step efficacy | 81.32± 0.60 | 92.18 | 370 | |
| Δ [95% CI] | +0.59 |
| −0.37
| −4.7% [−7.2, −2.0] | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B | RECAP (full) | 89.11± 0.47 | 95.65 | 976 | | | w/o step efficacy | 87.91± 0.37 | 95.53 | 1202 | | | Δ [95% CI] | +1.2
| 0.12
| −18.8% [−20.3, −17.5] |
Rebuttal by authors (Part 1)
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful feedback and for recognizing RECAP's semantic dependency-aware credit assignment framework, its effectiveness in improving the accuracy–efficiency trade-off across two model backbones and four benchmarks, and the supporting ablation and reasoning trajectory analyses.
Following the reviewer's suggestions, we add (i) counterfactual step-corruption experiments validating both credit signals (Tables R8–R12), (ii) a Step Efficacy ablation on DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B (Table R13), and (iii) a rollout-level dead-end analysis controlling for length, step count, and correctness (Tables R14-R15).
W1 & Q1. Reliability of step-Level credit assignment.
We thank the reviewer for raising the question of whether RECAP's assigned credits meaningfully reflect the contributions of individual reasoning steps.
Counterfactual corruption shows that RECAP's credit reflects meaningful step-level contributions to downstream answer accuracy: corrupting answer-reaching steps causes ~3× the accuracy drop of dead-end steps, and among structurally important steps, those with positive Step Efficacy cause a 13.2-point larger drop.
As the reviewer notes, a step may be heavily relied upon downstream without advancing the correct solution. This limitation of Structural Responsibility alone is what motivates Step Efficacy (lines 067–069 & Section 4). We therefore test both signals counterfactually.
Setup. We generate 8 rollouts per problem with the RECAP-trained Qwen2.5-Math-7B model on the 512-problem validation set and retain 234 problems with both correct and incorrect rollouts, where group-relative advantages are nonzero and step-level credit assignment affects training. This yielded 1850 validly annotated rollouts. Excluding final-answer steps, steps without numerical values, and steps lacking valid Structural Responsibility scores leaves 6393 reasoning steps. For each selected step, we corrupt all numerical values and independently sample 16 continuations from both the original and corrupted prefixes to measure changes in final-answer accuracy. Numerical corruption preserves the step's wording and position while altering its content. (In pilot deletion experiments, the model often re-derived missing steps, yielding negligible accuracy changes, so we chose corruption as the counterfactual intervention)
1) Structural Responsibility identifies steps that downstream reasoning depends on.
We compare the accuracy drops caused by corrupting dead-end steps (resp = 0) and answer-reaching steps (resp > 0).
As shown in Table R8, corrupting answer-reaching steps causes approximately three times the accuracy drop of corrupting dead-end steps (23.9 vs. 7.6 pp). This substantial difference suggests that Structural Responsibility captures meaningful downstream dependencies: the answer-reaching steps identified by Structural Responsibility have a much greater influence on subsequent reasoning than dead-end steps, supporting the use of dependency structure to distinguish reasoning steps that warrant stronger credit assignment.
Table R8. Accuracy change after corrupting dead-end vs. answer-reaching steps.
This difference persists across all step-length and numerical-count groups (Table R9). Even among steps of similar length or numerical count, corrupting answer-reaching steps consistently causes substantially larger accuracy drops than corrupting dead-end steps, indicating that Structural Responsibility captures meaningful downstream dependencies beyond these potential confounding factors.
Table R9. Counterfactual accuracy drops after numerical corruption, stratified by step length and numerical count. Each value is the mean decrease in downstream answer accuracy (percentage points, pp) obtained by individually corrupting n reasoning steps in the corresponding group and averaging their accuracy drops.