- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
I'm unable to summarize the contributions of this manuscript due to its lack of clarity.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
The paper is unreadable to me. As illustrated by the abstract, it reads as an inventory of technical claims whose importance is poorly explained. I don't see any motivation for the problem: "Given the local geometry of a regular solution, what is the best achievable local contraction, and which inertial parameters attain it?" I don't understand what "local geometry" refers to, what an inertial parameter is, and why this technical question matters, what are the insight provided by this study etc. The mathematical exposition doesn't look better; the algorithm is not described in the Problem Setup section; notations such as or are not defined, etc.
Questions for authors
What audience is this paper written for?
5 comments
Weakness 2 - Mathematical Exposition, Algorithm Description and Notation
Weakness 2
The mathematical exposition doesn't look better; the algorithm is not described in the Problem Setup section; notations such as or are not defined, etc.
We thank the reviewer. Section 2 now states the full setup and algorithm before any theory.
Definitions (Section 2). Let be a full-column-rank analysis operator and the measured magnitudes. The two constraint sets are The consistency projection is , and the magnitude projection replaces each entry of by . One Griffin–Lim step is , and the objective is Convergence is measured against the solution orbit , since a global phase cannot be recovered.
Algorithm (eq. 2.2). AGLA keeps the current and previous iterates . With , one step with parameters is GLA corresponds to and FGLA sets . The former notation has been removed; distances are written explicitly as , and denotes the second extrapolate.
Organization. Problem setup and algorithm (Section 2) → geometry and spectrum (Section 3) → exact acceleration and spectral tolerance (Section 4) → online estimation (Section 5) → safeguarded convergence (Section 6) → experiments (Section 7) → discussion and limitations (Section 8). Each theorem is followed by a short interpretation in the main text; proofs are in Appendices A–G and the experimental protocol is in Appendix H. Figure 1 gives an overview of the method.
We sincerely thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback, which has helped us substantially strengthen the manuscript. We believe that the new theoretical results, additional experimental evidence, and clarifications directly address your concerns and further establish the significance of our contributions.
We would greatly appreciate your reassessment of the submission in light of these developments. We welcome any remaining questions or suggestions and look forward to continuing our discussion during the rebuttal period.
Thank you again for your time, expertise, and careful consideration of our work.
Weakness 1 and Question 1 - Motivation, Significance and Intended Audience
Weakness 1
Question 1
We thank Reviewer SjNC for this direct assessment. We have rewritten the abstract, introduction and problem setup to explain the motivation before the technical results.
Motivation. In audio phase retrieval, only STFT magnitudes are observed and the phase must be reconstructed. The Griffin–Lim algorithm (GLA) alternates between two constraints: consistency with an underlying signal (projection onto the subspace U) and agreement with the measured magnitudes (projection onto the set Ms). It is simple and widely used, but it converges slowly when the two constraint sets are nearly tangent, because each projection then makes only a small correction. Accelerated variants (FGLA, AGLA) add momentum and relaxation, but their parameters are usually tuned by hand, although the best choice depends on the problem instance.
What "local geometry" and "inertial parameters" mean.
Why the question matters and what we show.
Audience. The paper is written for researchers in optimization and iterative inverse problems, including signal and audio processing, who use alternating-projection or momentum methods and want principled parameter choices.