acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

ORION: EXACT CANONICAL-STATE SUPERVISION FOR SYSTEMATIC GENERALIZATION IN TRANSFORMERS

Abstract

Autoregressive Transformers generally fail on out-of-distribution reasoning due to two primary reasons: positional corruption over long sequences and structural state drift across deep execution steps. We introduce ORION, a framework that supervises exact canonical execution states via auxiliary heads to anchor latent trajectories to valid computational manifolds. Across Folding, GridShift, and CLRS-30, a pre-registered 2 x 2 factorial shows that RoPE and ORION address orthogonal axes. RoPE recovers length extrapolation (59.8%), while ORION recovers depth extrapolation (66.7%). Moreover, their combination complementarily achieves strict additive gain in joint length-depth extrapolation, while either method alone offers near satisfactory results. Negative controls confirm that the gain depends strictly on exact canonical alignment; hashed state statistics fail to constrain depth extrapolation.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
systematic generalization, algorithmic reasoning, execution trace supervision, out-of-distribution generalization, mechanistic interpretability, compositional inductive bias

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_3o5eOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ORION, which supervises intermediate Transformer representations using simulator-derived execution states. The authors study its interaction with positional encoding through a 2×2 comparison of absolute positional embeddings versus RoPE and auxiliary state supervision versus no supervision. Experiments cover Folding, GridShift, and an eight-algorithm CLRS pilot, with additional scaling, transfer, and representation analyses. The results suggest that state supervision can improve depth extrapolation when combined with RoPE, particularly at the largest model size. However, the evidence does not establish the stronger claims concerning orthogonal failure modes, the necessity of canonical alignment, or confinement to a true execution manifold.

Critical strengths
  1. The question of how positional encoding and intermediate supervision interact in algorithmic generalization is relevant. The main factorial comparison and the two distinct synthetic domains provide a useful starting point.

  2. The 26M-parameter result is promising: ORION + RoPE significantly improves Folding depth extrapolation, with positive improvements in all five seeds.

  3. The cross-domain pretraining results suggest potential transfer benefits. The explicit reporting of negative mechanistic findings is useful, including unsuccessful causal interventions and the failure of the original compression hypothesis.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper's objective and its methodological contribution are insufficiently specified. ORION needs a clearer account of what its particular representation and objective add, supported by a comparison under the same RoPE backbone and supervision budget.

  2. The representation analyses do not establish the proposed confinement mechanism. Figure 4 measures displacement in a two-dimensional PCA projection, rather than distance to valid execution states or violations of the true transition. Figure 1 also lacks a RoPE-only readout comparison.

  3. The negative controls do not isolate canonical alignment. Section 5.3 interprets the failure of N1–N5 as evidence that exact canonical alignment is necessary. However, Appendix D.3 states that all five controls use absolute positional embeddings, whereas the full model uses RoPE. Since Table 2 identifies RoPE as the dominant contributor to extrapolation, this comparison confounds the supervision target with positional encoding.

Questions for authors
  1. How are token length, state size, and execution depth independently controlled? What changes when the size split avoids an untrained size-token embedding?

  2. What is the complete implemented objective, and which component accounts for the improvement over ordinary intermediate-state prediction?

Reviewer_NRAiOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This study addresses the inability of Transformer models to handle OOD cases when performing algorithmic reasoning by decomposing the problem into two dimensions: execution depth and sequence length. The authors propose using RoPE to manage sequence length, and a method called ORION to address execution depth; ORION imposes constraints on the Transformer’s intermediate representations by incorporating "teacher representations"—derived analytically from the canonical states of the task. To demonstrate the effectiveness of these approaches, the study employs three distinct tasks and conducts a 2×2 experimental design, varying the application of the two proposed methods.

Critical strengths

The approach is commendable for addressing OOD problems, which should be solvable if the model is truly capable of algorithmic reasoning by decomposing them into two distinct factors.

The proposed method is straightforward and easy to implement: it imposes constraints during the execution process to ensure that intermediate representations resemble the analytically derived ground-truth signals.

The experimental evaluation is comprehensive, incorporating control experiments, sensitivity analyses, and other assessments to examine the properties of ORION from multiple perspectives.

Critical weaknesses

While the proposed method yields some improvement for OOD cases, it appears that RoPE has the major contribution to the fundamental gains in accuracy. Although combining RoPE and ORION leads to further improvement, the authors themselves describe them as independent approaches; therefore, the performance boost appears to be merely additive, and no analysis is provided regarding any potential synergistic effect between the two approaches. Furthermore, there is insufficient analysis and discussion concerning why RoPE is effective for OOD cases in the first place.

There is existing research (e.g., VPRM, https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.17223) that utilizes analytically derived supervisory signals or verifiers for intermediate reasoning steps or states; this should be discussed in the related work section.

The terms "Size," "Length," and "State Size" are used throughout the paper. While they likely refer to the same concept, the terminology is not consistent. Furthermore, the notation is likewise inconsistent, such as (S), (N), and (n). These detract from the readability of the paper.

Questions for authors

Could you explain why RoPE is effective for length extrapolation in these tasks? An analysis of the underlying mechanism would help me assess the paper's claims. Moreover, could you explain the synergy of using both ORIONS and RoPE?

Reviewer_gN7gOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
1
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This study proposes ORION, which adds an auxiliary loss to predict exact execution states from the intermediate representations of a Transformer. It evaluates generalization when the state size or the number of execution steps increases beyond the training range on Folding, GridShift, and a subset of CLRS algorithms. In particular, it analyzes the effects of positional encoding and intermediate-state supervision by crossing the presence and absence of RoPE and ORION.

Although my limited knowledge of this domain (algorithm learning) may prevent me from fully understanding the paper, from my perspective, it appears to address a fairly obvious approach. Given the benchmarks and problem setting, I understand this as a study in neural algorithmic reasoning (NAR), and its core appears to be adding an auxiliary loss to predict ground-truth labels for intermediate execution steps when such labels are available. Such approaches can also be found in domain-specific studies where intermediate labels can be obtained, so I believe that clearer explanations and comparisons are needed to establish how this method differs from existing approaches. Furthermore, the abstract states that "RoPE and ORION address orthogonal axes," but I question whether comparing the effects of the two components through a 2×2 experiment is sufficient to establish functional orthogonality. It is difficult to understand theoretically what "orthogonal" means here, and Appendix B.6 also explains that the functional orthogonality of the two mechanisms has not been established and that they are interdependent. Indeed, in Table 2, most of the performance improvement from combining RoPE and ORION also appears to come from RoPE.

Critical strengths

[S1] A benchmark setup that supports intermediate supervision and generalization analysis

  • In Folding and GridShift, an exact simulator can generate not only the final answers but also intermediate execution states. The state size and the number of execution steps can also be varied to construct conditions beyond the training range. I therefore consider this a meaningful experimental environment for examining the conditions under which models fail to generalize.
  • In particular, the finding that generalization remains insufficient even under ideal conditions where intermediate states are available is worth analyzing separately from failures under final-answer-only supervision. From this perspective, the benchmarks and experimental settings in this study could be useful in other ways. Personally, I found the dataset construction in this paper more interesting than the model architecture.
  • However, these are results under ideal conditions where intermediate-state labels are available. Such labels are often difficult to obtain in practice, which limits the generalizability of the approach.

[S2] Various control experiments and the reporting of negative results

  • In addition to the experiments crossing the presence and absence of RoPE and ORION, the authors examined various conditions, including negative controls with corrupted or shuffled state targets, the fraction of intermediate-state labels provided, model scale, and cross-domain transfer. I appreciated the effort to analyze the conditions under which the method is effective, rather than merely reporting final performance.
  • In particular, I appreciate that Appendix C.8 reports experiments that did not support the authors' hypotheses. The absence of the expected changes after ablating the directions identified by a state read-out probe or editing the hidden state is also important information for assessing the scope of the proposed explanation. However, these results and limitations should also be consistently reflected in the main claims of the paper.
Critical weaknesses

[W1] Insufficient differentiation from existing intermediate supervision and insufficient baseline comparisons

  • The core of this study is to provide exact intermediate states as a training signal, but this approach itself has already been explored in prior work. The paper also introduces studies using scratchpads and intermediate execution states in Related Work, yet it does not present a direct comparison with existing training methods that provide the same ground-truth state information. From the current results alone, it is difficult to distinguish whether providing additional intermediate ground-truth information was effective or whether ORION's canonical representation and training method were particularly effective.
  • For example, training a model to predict the same intermediate states autoregressively as part of the output sequence seems like a natural comparison. Comparing against such a method with the same Transformer, RoPE, data, and intermediate ground-truth information would make ORION's specific contribution clearer.
  • I acknowledge that comparisons with other backbones are provided in Appendix C.2 and Table 7. However, these are comparisons with basic sequence models such as an S4-style SSM, Hyena, and RWKV, rather than comparisons with and without the same intermediate-state supervision on each backbone. In particular, the SSM does not achieve sufficiently high performance even on the training distribution in either domain, which limits what can be concluded about generalization from these results. Examining other SSMs, such as Mamba models, could also be helpful, but I believe that comparisons under matched supervision conditions should take priority.
  • Since the auxiliary loss appears applicable to other backbones, I would like to see comparisons of the effect of adding the same supervision in a plug-in manner. Otherwise, it is difficult to determine whether ORION's effect is specific to Transformers or whether other models could also obtain it by receiving intermediate-state labels.
  • Furthermore, the coverage of recent related work and comparison methods needs improvement. For example, it would be helpful to explain how this method differs from recent studies that learn states and state transitions, such as Discrete Neural Algorithmic Reasoning (ICML'25), and to compare them on shared tasks where possible.

[W2] The central claims are inconsistent with the experimental results and the interpretations in the appendix

  • The main issue is the claim that RoPE and ORION address orthogonal axes of generalization. In the depth extrapolation results in Table 2, RoPE alone already provides a substantial improvement, and adding ORION yields only a small further improvement. ORION alone does not produce such an improvement. Therefore, these results are more consistent with ORION providing an additional benefit in the presence of RoPE than with the two methods each addressing a separate axis.
  • In particular, the abstract's 59.8% and 66.7% correspond to the ORION+RoPE depth extrapolation results for GridShift and Folding, respectively, in Table 2. Describing them separately as RoPE's length extrapolation performance and ORION's depth extrapolation performance does not match the table. Appendix B.6 also explicitly states that functional orthogonality has not been established and that the two mechanisms are interdependent. I therefore consider this an issue of consistency in the central claims, rather than merely overly strong wording.
  • There is a similar issue with the claim that canonical alignment is necessary. §5.3 cites the failure of negative controls such as N5 to reproduce ORION's performance, but according to Appendix D.3, all of these controls used absolute positional encodings. The consistency loss is also disabled for N5. It is therefore difficult to attribute the difference between these results and ORION + RoPE solely to the canonical representation. Moreover, Appendix B.4 explicitly states that N5 matches ORION at equal positional encoding, which conflicts with the interpretation in the main text.
  • I do not believe that ORION has no effect. The paper reports significant improvements under example-level paired tests, and the 26M model in Table 5 shows an additional gain of 8.2 percentage points over RoPE. However, the existence of a performance improvement should be distinguished from establishing the proposed mechanism and its necessity. The intervention experiments in Appendix C.8 likewise do not provide evidence sufficient to move from the observation that states can be read out to the conclusion that those state representations actually drive the computation.
  • Therefore, I believe that the paper needs to distinguish the performance improvements it has demonstrated from the explanations it has not yet established, and to make the claims in the abstract, main text, and appendix consistent.
Questions for authors

The following questions are based on the weaknesses discussed above.

[Q1] Could you provide comparisons with existing studies that use the same intermediate-state information?

  • It would be helpful to compare ORION with a setting that uses the same Transformer and RoPE but is trained to predict exact intermediate states as a scratchpad or output sequence.
  • What I would like to understand is the additional benefit of ORION's state representation and auxiliary loss formulation beyond the effect of providing intermediate ground-truth information itself. I would also appreciate a clear explanation of the differences from existing hint supervision or intermediate-state supervision.
  • Furthermore, please consider explaining the differences from related work such as Discrete Neural Algorithmic Reasoning and comparing them on shared tasks where the input format and supervision conditions can be matched.

[Q2] Could you provide comparisons that apply ORION to other backbones, such as Hyena, Mamba, or RWKV?

  • Table 7 is useful for examining the performance of other backbones, but it does not show the effect of adding ORION to the same backbone. It would be helpful to compare performance with and without intermediate-state supervision on models that can adequately fit the training distribution.
  • Through this comparison, I would like to understand whether the method is specific to Transformers or is a training approach that can also be applied to other sequence models.

[Q3] Could you clearly explain the meaning of and evidence for "orthogonal axes" in this study?

  • It is unclear whether this means that the two methods can be independently enabled and disabled, that they address different causes of failure, or that they involve mathematically orthogonal representations or operations.
  • In particular, Appendix B.6 explains that functional orthogonality has not been established and that the two mechanisms are interdependent. I would like to understand how this statement should be reconciled with the claim in the abstract.
  • Furthermore, the 59.8% and 66.7% attributed to RoPE and ORION, respectively, in the abstract are presented in Table 2 as depth extrapolation results from combining the two methods. I would appreciate clarification of this description.

[Q4] Are there results that test the necessity of canonical alignment under matched conditions?

  • I understand that the negative controls, including N5, use absolute positional encodings, and that the consistency loss is also disabled for N5. Since these differences are present in the comparison with ORION+RoPE, it appears difficult to isolate the effect of the canonical representation.
  • It would be helpful to compare canonical targets with other information-preserving state representations under the same positional encoding and, as far as possible, the same loss conditions.
  • I would also like to understand how the necessity claim in §5.3 is compatible with the statement in Appendix B.4 that "N5 matches ORION at equal positional encoding."

[Q5] Could you clarify the axes and scope of the generalization experiments?

  • Introduction and §4.2 describe extrapolation with token length and execution depth held fixed in turn, whereas Table 2 and Appendix D.1 distinguish the experiments by state size and number of operations. It would be helpful to clearly explain how state size, input token length, and execution depth vary in each split.
  • The paper acknowledges as a limitation the assumption that exact intermediate states can be generated. In my view, analyzing how far generalization is possible even under these ideal conditions could itself be a clearer contribution. I would like to understand whether you consider the core of this study to be the proposal of a new supervision method or the analysis of existing generalization limitations.

[Q6] Could you check the related work and bibliographic information?

  • The entry listed as "End-to-end algorithm synthesis with recurrent neural networks" differs from the original paper in its title and author information and needs to be checked.
  • Furthermore, Veličković & Blundell (2021) is cited as the source of CLRS, but "The CLRS Algorithmic Reasoning Benchmark" (ICML'22), which introduced the benchmark itself, should also be cited.
  • It would be helpful to review recent studies on NAR and intermediate-state supervision and explain how this method differs from them.
1 comment
Reviewer_gN7gOpenReview ↗

Response to the Authors' Rebuttal

I apologize for the somewhat delayed response. Thank you for the response. I understood your explanations, but concerns about the contribution of this study remain, and some parts of the response have not been reflected in the manuscript.

[Q1] Differentiation from existing intermediate supervision

I understood the explanation that supervision is applied to predict intermediate states from internal representations. However, this can also be viewed as a standard auxiliary-task formulation, so ORION's specific contribution remains unclear. Without comparisons with methods such as scratchpads that use the same intermediate-state information, it is difficult to distinguish the effect of additional ground-truth information from the effect of ORION's specific design.

[W1,Q2] Application to other backbones

From Equations (2) and (4), ORION appears applicable to other backbones in a plug-in manner. Therefore, I would like to see comparisons with and without ORION on the same backbone. It is also disappointing that there are no experiments with the Mamba family, which has addressed the problems of existing SSMs.

“Applied only to Transformers” and “designed to address the limitations of Transformers” are different. From the very first sentence of the Abstract, this paper frames the problem around the latter, but it lacks a Transformer-specific design rationale or comparisons on other backbones. Simply limiting the experimental scope to Transformers does not resolve the concerns about the contribution.

[W2,Q3] Orthogonality and interpretation of the performance figures

I also noted your response that functional orthogonality has not been established and that ORION provides an additional benefit alongside RoPE's dominant contribution. However, the following sentence remains in the abstract.

“RoPE recovers length extrapolation (59.8%), while ORION recovers depth extrapolation (66.7%).”

The figures of 66.7% and 59.8% are the depth-extrapolation performance of RoPE+ORION on Folding and GridShift, respectively. I still do not understand why these are described separately as RoPE's length-extrapolation performance and ORION's depth-extrapolation performance, and this needs to be corrected.

[W2,Q4] Necessity of canonical alignment

I understood your response that the current controls do not establish necessity and that you withdraw this claim. However, the necessity claim remains in the title and text of §5.3, so this needs to be revised. Furthermore, it remains unverified what advantages the canonical representation offers over other information-preserving representations.

[Q5] Generalization settings and central contribution

Thank you for explaining the experimental settings in detail. The explanation that token length and execution depth are not independently controlled should also be reflected in the manuscript.

If the contribution of this study is an analysis showing that “even exact intermediate-state supervision does not guarantee extrapolation,” this does not seem consistent with the current flow of the paper. The manuscript focuses on demonstrating ORION's superiority, but the novelty of ORION itself is not sufficiently clear either. The organization and claims of the paper need to be aligned with its central contribution.

[Q6] Related work and bibliographic information

I confirmed that the bibliographic information I pointed out has been corrected. Thank you.


Overall, I understood the response, but the contribution that this study can claim appears to be substantially reduced as a result. Furthermore, in the current PDF, it is difficult to identify revisions or additional experiments addressing the other questions beyond the bibliographic corrections in Q6. In particular, the concerns about the specific contribution over existing intermediate supervision and the lack of comparative experiments remain unresolved, so I would like to maintain my original score.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.