- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents a neural variational method for computing bound-state wave functions of ultracold polar molecules. It combines an analytical spherical-harmonic expansion with a WKB-inspired envelope, leaving a shared MLP to learn the remaining radial structure. The method is benchmarked against accurate two-body solvers for ground and excited states across interaction strengths, with ablations examining the physical priors and parametrization. A three-body formulation is also derived, although validation is limited to its numerical components rather than a complete three-body calculation.
Critical strengths
The representation is well motivated by the target physics: analytical angular decomposition and a WKB-inspired envelope reduce what the network must learn. This gives the design a clear connection to the problem, and the ablations support its benefits for optimization.
The two-body results provide credible validation against an accurate classical solver across interaction strengths, particularly for ground states. Testing excited states and multiple random seeds adds confidence that the method works beyond a single favorable example.
Critical weaknesses
The effect of angular-channel truncation is insufficiently validated. Both the neural method and the MDVR reference use l_max=8, so their agreement does not establish convergence with respect to the angular basis. Increasing this cutoff would help determine whether important physical contributions are omitted.
The WKB-inspired envelope uses a simplified potential, a proxy energy, and an empirical broadening factor. Although the ablations show optimization benefits, they do not sufficiently establish whether these choices affect final accuracy or wave-function tails. This limits confidence in the claim that the representation captures the correct asymptotic behavior.
Questions for authors
Could you provide convergence results with increasing l_max for both the neural method and the reference solver? Since both use lmax=8, their agreement does not establish that angular truncation errors are negligible.
Beyond the optimization trajectories in the envelope ablation, how sensitive are the final energies and wave-function tails to the proxy energy and broadening factor? Does the learned residual recover the expected asymptotic decay despite the deliberately broadened envelope?
These are requests to validate the current results, rather than suggestions for future work.
We thank the Reviewer for their assessment of the physical motivation and two-body validation. We have added angular-cutoff and envelope-sensitivity studies to the revised Manuscript.
Angular-channel convergence
To test convergence in the angular basis, we performed the ground-state optimization with lmax∈2,4,6,8,10,12 for ν∈50,100,500,1000MHz. We used three random seeds for each configuration, keeping all other settings fixed. The table below provides the seed-average relative error with respect to MDVR (computed at lmax=8), and the change in the neural energy compared to the previous cutoff value, which measures convergence independently of the reference.
The energy converges quickly with lmax. In particular, the error drops from about 40% for lmax=2 to below 0.5% for lmax=6. Beyond the cutoff used in the paper, raising lmax from 8 to 10 changes the energy by at most 0.03%, and from 10 to 12 by at most 0.012% with no consistent sign, which is at the level of the seed-to-seed variation. The neural energy can therefore be considered converged (in the angular basis sense) at lmax=8.
The same results also bound the truncation error of the reference. At lmax=10 and 12 the neural energy lies at most 0.02% below the MDVR energy, so the channels omitted by MDVR at lmax=8 contribute at most about 0.02% to the ground-state energy. Both truncation errors are therefore small compared to the differences discussed in the paper. The full results, including training dynamics for each lmax, are in Appendix E.3.2.
We also tested angular convergence in the newly introduced three-body calculation. Increasing the dual-angular cutoff from lmax,Lmax=4,4 to 6,6 lowers the ground-state energy by ≈15. The subsequent enlargement to 8,8 changes the energy by ≈3, whereas the final enlargement to 10,8, or from 145 to 190 channels, changes it by only ≈0.25. This decreasing sensitivity supports the cutoff 10,8 used in the three-body benchmarks (both neural and the reference 2D DVR). The results are included in Appendix E.3.2.
Envelope sensitivity and learned tails
We expanded the envelope ablation to β∈0,0.001,0.01,0.1,1, where β=0 removes the envelope decay and β=1 retains the literal WKB envelope. We tested ground states for ν∈50,100,500,1000MHz and first excited states for ν∈400,500,700,1000MHz, with three random seeds per configuration. All runs use the same fixed logarithmic-scale grid, separating the effect of the envelope on wave function from its effect on sampling.
For our main choice (β=0.01), the seed-averaged energy error relative to MDVR is at most 0.0005% for ground states and 0.004% for excited states. Removing the envelope decay also yields accurate final energies, but convergence is several times slower. In contrast, the literal envelope is too restrictive: ground-state errors reach about 2%, and the excited-state calculation remains above the dissociation threshold at the two lowest tested frequencies. Section 3 of the General Reply summarizes the full sensitivity results.
We also directly compared the learned tails with MDVR beyond the outer turning point, for ground states at ν=50MHz and ν=500MHz and excited states at ν=400MHz and ν=1000MHz. For β=0.01, the learned wave function falls well below the broadened envelope and follows the reference MDVR decay over several orders of magnitude. The residual therefore supplies state-dependent decay that is absent from the envelope itself. At very small wave function amplitudes, the curves depart and numerical oscillations appear. Nevertheless, the evidence supports recovery of the tail over the resolved range.
These tests retain the prescribed proxy energy EWKB=minrV(r)/2, and do not vary it independently. They show that the residual compensates for its decay-rate mismatch at the chosen broadening, including for a weakly bound excited state. Appendix E.3.1 presents the energy results, training curves, and direct tail comparisons.