- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work studies coarse-to-fine generative models that repeatedly restrict a fine-scale state to a coarse one, evolve it deterministically at the coarse level, and resample the fine scale. The main claimed result is that, if the time steps compose exactly, the generated states at different times are independent given the initial "class", so all temporal dependence is determined by this class.
Critical strengths
The main results are stated with explicit assumptions and full proofs. However, due to the poor presentation, I could not reliably assess the significance and novelty of these results.
Critical weaknesses
The most critical problem of the paper is that it is badly structured and hard to follow.
-
The paper does not clearly state the motivation, contributions and importance of the work. Even the Abstract, Introduction and Conclusion do not provide this information; they rather list theoretical facts. These points are important to clearly understand the impact of the work.
-
The problem is not well motivated. The four works cited in the Introduction (Mardani et al., 2025; Fan et al., 2025; Wang et al., 2022; Li et al., 2021) do not consider the problem studied in the paper. Since the paper does not address an already established problem, it should clearly explain why this problem is important and how it differs from other approaches.
-
Sections 2-5 are technically complex and hard to read. They should be simplified and supplemented with useful commentary.
-
Section 6 does not clearly explain why these experiments are needed. Moreover, it uses but does not explain the term "fixed coarse context", which conveys the essence of Figure 2, the only experimental figure in the main text. Figure 2 also uses , which is not introduced in the main text.
Due to its very poor presentation, the paper is almost unreadable and hard to judge. I believe it needs significant revision.
Questions for authors
Please address the weaknesses above.
2 comments
Follow-up on the authors’ response
Thank you for clarifying the introduction and stating the contributions explicitly. The research question is now easier to understand, and its motivation is clearer. I also appreciate the clearer explanation of Figure 2.
However, the abstract and Sections 2–5 remain unchanged, and I still find them difficult to follow. This makes it hard for me to assess the significance of the paper’s contributions. I recognize that my own familiarity with the subject may play a role, and I ask the area chair to take this uncertainty into account when weighing my review.
Overall, presentation remains my main concern. Given that the paper’s contribution is primarily theoretical, I consider the difficulty of interpreting its main results a substantial weakness. For this reason, I am keeping my original rating.
Response to Reviewer DR7C
Thank you for your review.
We agree that Sections 2–5 are highly technical. We were aware of this when preparing the submission and tried to make the paper as accessible as possible. We keep the main results in the main text so that the logical development stays complete, and we move the proofs to the appendices. In addition, (i) the Introduction states the central result in words before the technical sections, (ii) terms are explained in words where they first appear, and (iii) Table 1 summarizes the operators and probability laws, and Figure 1 illustrates Theorem 1. The results rely on measure-theoretic tools, so some passages remain dense. If any passage is still hard to follow, we would be happy to provide more explanation.
Thank you for pointing out that the motivation was not clearly stated. Three of the four works cited in the Introduction use the structure we study, a deterministic coarse evolution with fine detail sampled from the coarse state at each time, so the question we ask arises in practice. Mardani et al. (2025) also leave the temporal coherence of the generated fine scales to future work. That said, we agree that the paper should make these points clearer. In the revision, the first paragraph of the Introduction strengthens the motivation and states the research question, and the Introduction ends with a list of contributions, as you suggested.
At the start of Section 6, we added an explanation of why the experiments are needed. We also now define "fixed coarse context" and Var(Jn) in the main text. If any other terms need clarification, please let us know.