- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents Survival World (SW), an empirical framework for survival prediction. It attempts to construct multiple alternative trajectories by retrieving and composing observed patient transitions. Path-wise cumulative-hazard contributions are then aggregated into head-specific survival curves, which are in turn combined into the final prediction. Major comments:
- The details of the search program, including the survival-head combinations, aggregation choices, and the complete search protocol, etc., haven’t been fully explained.
- It is unclear where the formula in the last line of Figure 1 comes from (how it relates to Eqs. (6) and (7)), how the feature weights (w) are computed, and how the transition graph is created.
- There are many confusing statements used, like “empirical futures” “state action” in Figure 1, “training-supervision” “training-fitted” ,…
- When no historical state provides a sufficiently close match, how does SW come up with the candidates? How reliable is the trajectory it generated then? 5.The learning algorithm is missing.
Critical strengths
- The proposed SW attempts to preserve the data provenance of each transition, which should make it easier to trace the predictions.
- Baseline comparisons and ablation studies show that SW might be more accurate on some predictive metrics.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is hard to understand, mostly because it's poorly presented and a lot of details are missing.
- The exact meanings of key terms like “world model” and “alternative patient futures” haven't been discussed.
- Formal definitions for the key concepts, such as Future/Observable states, Disease trajectories, and Retrieval rules, etc., are missing.
- Lack of experimental validation for the effectiveness of the resulting future states and disease trajectories.
Questions for authors
Provide a well-defined learning algorithm.