- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscripts argues for a gap in 3D pose estimation where the input modalities are a combination of RGB, lidar, and mmWave, while accounting for their fusion and subject-level privacy aware training. The authors claim for three contributions: modality alignment, subject membership inference attack for 3D HPE with leakage analysis, and a sampling strategy ATS for more unbiased subject-level differential privacy learning. THe proposed framework is validated on the MM_Fi dataset.
Critical strengths
The problem posed by the paper is very relevant. THe privacy preserving problem is well-motivated. The core strength is the integration of multimoda learning for pose estimation, privacy preserving auditing and training.
Critical weaknesses
THe paper could be strengthened with better support in additional ablation studie. This contribution of the kinematic structure and adaptive gating mechanism could be illustrated as why this multimodal fusion design is useful. The ATS sampling strategy could also be compared with other alternative sampling strategies to highlight the advantage of the unbiased training motivation. These would be espeically useful in considered jointly with and arguing why the framework is still novel and effective, when the tradeoff against keeping privacy budget low causing a considerable drop in accuracy (would an joint error estimate still be useful if it's on the order of 1000mm, if so, in what context?)
Questions for authors
it would help if the authors could motivate why this privacy training requires this multimodal fusion framework and vice versa.
for suggestions for additional ablation studies, please see critical weaknesses. Establihshing the novelty and effectivei of ATS would be convincing for me to raise my score, followed by the fusion strategy.
How sensitive are the values in table 2? would it vary a lot with some other subset of participants?